HILL and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

HILL and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) [2019] AATA 756 (26 April 2019)

Division:Taxation and Commercial Division 

File Number(s):2019/0448      

Re:Richard HILL

APPLICANT

AndTax Practitioners Board

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Date:26 April 2019

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal rejects Mr Hill’s application to stay the Board’s 10 January 2019 decision to terminate his registration as a tax agent. The Tribunal also rejects Mr Hill’s application to stay the Board’s determination that Mr Hill is ineligible to apply for registration as a tax agent for a period of five years.

……………………[sgd]…………………….

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Catchwords

POLICY AND PROCEDURE – stay application – tax agent registration cancellation – whether decision to cancel tax agent registration should be stayed – whether decision to prevent reapplying for tax agent registration for five years should be stayed – conduct of personal affairs – prospects of success – public interest – futility of stay – stay rejected

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 41

Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth) ss 2-5, 90-5, 2-10, 50-5, 43605, 43605, 20-15, 20-15, 20-45, 20-25, 20-50, 43768, 30-35, 20-45, 30-15, 40-5, 70-10

Cases

Allied Asia Holdings (Aust) Pty Ltd v Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2002] FCA 566

Ampol Petroleum Pty Ltd v Findlay Fullagar J, Supreme Court of Victoria, 30 October 1986
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCAFC 185; (2009) 181 FCR 130
Brewarrana v Commissioner of Highways (1973) 4 SASR 476
Carter v Tax Practitioner’s Board [2017] AATA 528
Delis v Tax Practitioner’s Board [2015] AATA 820
Delis v Tax Practitioner’s Board [2016] FCA 570
Levi v Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board [2013] FCA 719 
Pioneer Concrete Services Ltd v Yelnah Pty Ltd (1986) 5 NSWLR 254
Re Jeffers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2015] AATA 537
Re Mclean and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] AATA 22
Re Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798; (2009) 51 AAR 114
Secretary Department of Social Services and McNamara [2016] AATA 189
Su v Tax Agents’ Board South Australia [1982] AATA 127; (1982) 61 FLR 1

Toohey v Tax Agents Board of Victoria [2008] FCA 1796; (2008) 106 ALD 506

Secondary Materials

Explanatory Memorandum to the 2009 Tax Agent Services Bill

Explanatory Paper TPB 01/2010

Explanatory Paper TPB 02/2010

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

  1. Mr Hill is a chartered accountant, and currently a director of about fourteen private companies (in many of which he is also a shareholder). Mr Hill is the principal of the firm DFK Richard Hill and has practised as an accountant, business consultant and tax agent since about 1980. After the commencement of the Tax Agents Services Act 2009 (Cth) (“TASA”) he became, and until the Board decision that gives rise to the present proceedings he was, a registered tax agent. In addition, two companies of which Mr Hill is a director…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HILL and Tax Practitioners Board (Taxation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 756
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Hill for a stay of the Tax Practitioners Board's decision to cancel his registration as a tax agent and to prevent him from reapplying for registration for five years. The application was heard by Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the decision to cancel Mr Hill's tax agent registration should be stayed, and whether the decision to prevent him from reapplying for registration for five years should also be stayed. In considering these issues, the Tribunal had to assess Mr Hill's prospects of success in the substantive review proceedings, the public interest, and whether a stay would be futile.

In assessing Mr Hill's prospects of success, the Tribunal noted that such an evaluation must consider the available information, the potential for new material, and the incomplete awareness of all issues. The Tribunal referred to previous decisions emphasizing caution in this regard. The core purpose of the Tax Agent Services Act 2013 (TASA) is to ensure tax agent services are provided to appropriate professional and ethical standards, with registration being a fundamental mechanism for this. Eligibility for registration requires an applicant to be a "fit and proper person," which generally involves good fame, integrity, and character. This assessment can be informed by various factors, including convictions for fraud, dishonesty, serious taxation offences, bankruptcy, or imprisonment within the preceding five years. The Tribunal noted that Mr Hill's personal tax debt, along with those of associated companies, was substantial and ongoing at the relevant times, and that his statements to the Board regarding these liabilities appeared inaccurate.

The Tribunal rejected Mr Hill's application for a stay. It found that the available material strongly indicated significant outstanding personal and corporate taxation debts, and that Mr Hill's assertions to the Board about these matters were likely misleading. Given the extent of these apparent contraventions of the TASA's fit and proper person requirements, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Hill had not demonstrated a sufficient likelihood of success in the substantive review to warrant a stay of the Board's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Schedule 2 details dealing with outstanding taxation related debts reveal a similar picture in relation to the Board’s findings about the inaccuracy of Mr Hill’s statements about outstanding taxation liability payments. Mr Hill would appear, at the time of each of his statements to the Board, to have had an outstanding personal tax debt approximating at least $50,000. And if the 2013 judgment debt should be added, his total outstanding personal taxation debt at all presently relevant times approximated at least $370,000. In addition, the taxation debts of companies of which one or other of Mr Hill and his wife were the only shareholders and directors typically exceeded $100,000 and, by November 2018 had increased to over $500,000. At all presently relevant times other companies with which Mr Hill was associated had very substantial outstanding taxation liabilities. Typically those liabilities were substantially more than $260,000.Mr Hill’s opposition to the Board decision and determination The Board provided Mr Hill with a copy of the November 2018 submission on 10 December 2018. His 9 January 2019 response made the points set out in the following paragraphs. The lodgement and payment defaults identified by the Board did not relate to Mr Hill’s obligations as an individual taxpayer. As an individual, he had “never had substantial overdue tax obligations”. He had not failed to pay the 13 August 2013 judgment debt. At about that time Mr Hill had settled with the ATO in relation to a tax debt for a similar amount. He was unaware of “any judgment amount outstanding”. In so far as the lodgement defaults related to Mr Hill, in his status as the trustee of the Forte Investment Trust, the trust had never derived any income. In so far as the various defaults related to corporate entities, two of the companies (23 Martin Place Pty Ltd and Eleventh Floor Pty Ltd) had more than one other director, and other shareholders. One company (Forte Private Wealth Pty Ltd) was in liquidation. Irrespective of the identity of the corporate directors and shareholders, none of the contentious matters involved “personal tax obligations”, and none of the responses in his March 2016 application and his personal Annual Declarations in 2017 and 2018 could be regarded as misleading. In any event, the companies with which he had been associated had not “consistently failed to meet their taxation obligations”. The 24 July 2017 Annual Declaration Mr Hill submitted for DFK Richard Hill Pty Ltd was incorrect in asserting there were no outstanding taxation obligations. But Mr Hill had completed that Declaration relying on information provided by his then co-director (Mr Sharp, who was also a registered tax agent). Neither the 1 August 2018 Annual Declaration for that company, nor the 5 October 2018 Annual Declaration for Forte Financial Pty Ltd, was incorrect or misleading. He had completed the latter declaration “on the assumption that the disclosure of personal tax affairs was similar to that required of an individual”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Consideration of an applicant’s prospects of obtaining a more favourable outcome in the review proceedings must take into account the state and quality of the currently available information, the prospect of additional relevant material, and the potentially incomplete awareness of all material issues. Those kinds of considerations require caution in evaluating an applicant’s apparent prospects of success in the course of determining a stay application:- see Re Mclean and Australian Securities and Investments Commission[2016] AATA 22 at [8]; Re Jeffers and Australian Securities and Investments Commission[2015] AATA 537 at [38]. Nevertheless, it is appropriate to consider the extent to which the available material is apparently sufficient to permit an informed view about the likelihood of an ultimately favourable variation of the reviewable decision.Tax agent registration and regulation– legislative provisions The basic purpose of the TASA provisions is to ensure that tax agent services are provided “in accordance with appropriate standards of professional and ethical conduct”:- see TASA s 2-5. (The expression “tax agent services” generally includes providing advice and representation services relating to Commonwealth taxation matters: see TASA s 90-5.) The TASA registration regime is a fundamental means of effectuating that purpose. Unless they do so as a practising lawyer, a person must be registered to be able to charge for providing “tax agent services”:- see TASA ss 2-10 & 50-5. The registration eligibility criteria for an individual tax agent include appropriate qualifications, experience and professional indemnity insurance. An individual registration applicant must also satisfy the Board that they are “fit and proper”:- see TASA s 20-5 A corporate applicant for tax agent registration must satisfy the Board about similar criteria. Each of its directors must be a “fit and proper person”. The corporation must not have incurred a conviction for fraud, dishonesty or a “serious taxation offence” within the preceding five years. It must also have both (i) sufficient registered tax agents to appropriately to provide (and supervise the provision of) competent tax agent services and, (ii) appropriate professional indemnity insurance:- TASA ss 20-5(3). An otherwise competent individual applicant (and any director of a corporate applicant) will likely be regarded as “fit and proper” if they are of “good fame, integrity and character”:- TASA s 20-15(a). The considerations that may inform such an assessment are not prescriptively defined:- see TASA s 20-15(b); Toohey v Tax Agents Board of Victoria [2008] FCA 1796; (2008) 106 ALD 506 at [3]. They must include, but the assessment is neither limited to nor explicitly determined by, circumstances where, in the preceding five years, the person has(a)been convicted, or otherwise sanctioned, for a “serious taxation offence” or certain other kinds of tax related misconduct:- TASA ss 20-15(b)(i) & 20-45(a)(c)&(d)(b)been convicted of any offences involving fraud or dishonesty:- TASA ss 20-15(b)(i) & 20-45(b)(c)served, or has been sentenced to, a term of imprisonment:- TASA ss 20-15(b)(i) & 20-45(f); 20-15(b)(iii)(d)had the status of an undischarged bankrupt:- TASA ss 20-15(b)(ii).