HIH Claims Support v Insurance Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

[2011] HCATrans 144

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Melbourne  No M24 of 2011

B e t w e e n -

HIH CLAIMS SUPPORT (ACN 096 857 635)

Appellant

and

INSURANCE AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 000 016 722)

Respondent

GUMMOW ACJ
HAYNE J
HEYDON J
CRENNAN J
KIEFEL J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT CANBERRA ON THURSDAY, 2 JUNE 2011, AT 10.18 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR B.W. WALKER, SC:   May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friend, MR P. KULEVSKI, for the appellant.  (instructed by TressCox Lawyers)

MR D.F. JACKSON, QC:   If the Court pleases, I appear with my learned friends, MR M.W. THOMPSON, SC and MS C.M. HARRIS, for the respondent.  (instructed by Norris Coates)

GUMMOW ACJ:   Yes, Mr Walker.

MR WALKER:   Your Honours, may I start with the agreed facts, which are found in the appeal book starting at page 245.  Paragraph 1 introduces Mr Steele who may be treated as the insured wrongdoer.  Paragraph 2 refers to the accident by which damage was caused, ultimately, it was held, for which he was responsible.  Paragraph 4 introduces the HIH policy which is at the root of my client’s position.  Paragraph 5 is his claim upon it.  Paragraph 6 is the proceedings in which he was sought with another to be made liable. 

Paragraphs 7 and 8 are the cross‑claims in relation to other players in the accident.  Those are the New South Wales proceedings to distinguish him from other proceedings in Victoria.  In paragraph 9, which may be linked with paragraph 16, there is the narration of HIH, at that time still solvent and operating, accepting liability to indemnify under that policy and 16 shows there was, in due course, a payment.  There was another policy which also was established after considerable contest on a number of grounds to respond to the accident so as to provide indemnity to Mr Steele.

GUMMOW ACJ:   Just looking at paragraph 14 on 246, it says:

On 15 June, 2000, HIH and Steele brought a proceeding No. 5769 of 2000 in this Honourable Court against SGIC

So, is Mr Steele suing SGIC on the policy?

MR WALKER:   Yes, as a named insured.

GUMMOW ACJ:   Would SGIC have had a defence?  I do not know whether it be an equitable offence, but a defence as to 90 per cent satisfaction already having been received?

MR WALKER:   That is in due course exactly what was established, yes, it did.  That was held so. 

GUMMOW ACJ:   The controversy then is, having the benefit of that defence which arises by reason of the Commonwealth intervention, to use that expression, SGIC does not have any burden or contribution.

MR WALKER:   That is right.

GUMMOW ACJ:   Mr Jackson says, well, that is because of the particular framework of a Commonwealth intervention and it has made its bed in a particular way and it has got to lie in it.

MR WALKER:   Quite so.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HIH Claims Support v Insurance Australia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] HCATrans 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a dispute between HIH Claims Support Limited (in liquidation) and Insurance Australia Limited. The core of the disagreement concerned the interpretation and application of certain provisions within the *Insurance Contracts Act 1984* (Cth) and the *Life Insurance Act 1995* (Cth), particularly in relation to the transfer of liabilities and the rights of policyholders following the insolvency of an insurer. HIH Claims Support, acting on behalf of HIH Insurance Limited (also in liquidation), sought to recover certain payments and establish its entitlement to specific assets, which Insurance Australia Limited contested.

The central legal questions before the High Court were whether Insurance Australia Limited was liable to HIH Claims Support for certain claims and liabilities that had been transferred to it under a scheme of arrangement, and whether the statutory provisions governing such transfers had been correctly applied. Specifically, the Court had to determine the scope of the indemnity provided by the legislation to transferees of insurance business, and the extent to which HIH Claims Support could pursue claims against Insurance Australia Limited in light of those statutory provisions and the terms of the scheme of arrangement.

The High Court's reasoning focused on the statutory framework established by the *Insurance Contracts Act* and the *Life Insurance Act* for dealing with insolvent insurers and the transfer of their business. The Court analysed the nature of the indemnity conferred by these Acts, concluding that it was intended to protect transferees from certain liabilities and to facilitate the orderly transfer of insurance portfolios. The Court examined the specific terms of the scheme of arrangement and the relevant legislative provisions, determining that the scheme, as approved, had the effect of transferring certain liabilities and that the indemnity provisions operated to limit the recourse available to HIH Claims Support against Insurance Australia Limited in respect of those transferred liabilities. The Court applied principles of statutory interpretation to ascertain the legislative intent behind the indemnity provisions.

The High Court allowed the appeal in part, varying the orders of the Full Federal Court. The Court held that Insurance Australia Limited was not liable to HIH Claims Support for certain claims and liabilities that had been transferred under the scheme of arrangement, due to the operation of the statutory indemnity provisions.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 15 June 2000, Mr Steele, the insured, commenced proceedings against HIH and SGIC to establish liability for an accident that occurred. HIH, an insurance company, accepted liability to indemnify Mr Steele under a policy. However, HIH became insolvent, leading to the Commonwealth government intervening to provide financial assistance to HIH policyholders like Mr Steele through the HIH Claims Support Scheme. The scheme was established by the Appropriation (HIH Assistance) Act 2001 (Cth), and administered by HIH Claims Support Trust, with HIH Claims Support Limited as the trustee. The scheme operated by requiring policyholders to assign their rights under their HIH policies to the trustee in exchange for payments of up to 90% of the policy value. HIH Claims Support Limited paid Mr Steele 90% of his policy value. SGIC, now insured by Insurance Australia Limited (IAL), resisted liability but was ultimately held liable. IAL argued that HIH Claims Support Limited had no right to contribution from them since HIH Claims Support Limited had no mutual obligation with SGIC. HIH Claims Support Limited argued that the scheme payments created an equitable obligation to contribute, as the payments reflected HIH's obligation under the policy.

The matter before the High Court is an appeal from a decision of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria in HIH Claims Support v Insurance Australia Limited [2009] VSCA 329. The appellant, HIH Claims Support, is seeking to recover a contribution from the respondent, Insurance Australia Limited (IAL), for payments made under a Commonwealth government scheme designed to assist policyholders of the now-defunct HIH Insurance. The central issue revolves around whether IAL, having assumed the liabilities of another insurer, SGIC, can avoid contributing to the payments made by HIH Claims Support on the basis that the scheme payments are not mutual obligations between co-insurers. The Court of Appeal held that IAL could rely on the satisfaction defence, arguing that the payments made by HIH Claims Support were not mutual and thus did not trigger any obligation for contribution. HIH Claims Support argues that the payments, while not strictly mutual, create an equitable obligation for contribution due to the special circumstances of the Commonwealth scheme and the inequity of IAL retaining the full benefit of the discharge without contributing. The appeal raises questions about the nature of mutuality in contribution claims, particularly in the context of government intervention and insolvency.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the nature and scope of the HIH Claims Support Scheme established by the Commonwealth, and how does it relate to the obligations of the insurers under the policy?
2. Can the Commonwealth be held liable for contribution under the HIH Claims Support Scheme when it has made payments to policyholders, and if so, under what circumstances?
3. Does the HIH Claims Support Scheme create mutuality between the insurers that would allow for a claim of contribution, or does the Commonwealth's intervention disrupt the traditional principles of co-insurance?
4. Are the payments made by the Commonwealth under the HIH Claims Support Scheme considered to be obligations enforceable by the policyholders, and if so, how does this affect the relationship between the Commonwealth, the insurers, and the policyholders?
5. Does the HIH Claims Support Scheme alter the traditional principles of equitable contribution between co-insurers, and if so, how does this impact the ability of one insurer to claim contribution from another under the scheme?
6. Can the Commonwealth be required to contribute to the payment made by one insurer to a policyholder when the other insurer has already been discharged from its liability due to the Commonwealth's intervention under the HIH Claims Support Scheme?

Held
1. The HIH Claims Support Scheme established by the Commonwealth provides financial assistance to HIH eligible persons, including policyholders, who suffered financial loss due to the insolvency of HIH. The scheme operates by the Commonwealth funding payments to eligible applicants through the HIH Claims Support Trust.

2. The Commonwealth can be held liable for contribution under the HIH Claims Support Scheme if it has made payments to policyholders and the circumstances allow for such a claim, particularly if the payments reflect the obligations of the co-insurers under their policy.

3. The HIH Claims Support Scheme does not create mutuality between the insurers in the traditional sense that would allow for a claim of contribution. The Commonwealth's intervention disrupts the traditional principles of co-insurance by altering the sequence in which insurers bear the burden of loss.

4. Payments made by the Commonwealth under the HIH Claims Support Scheme are considered obligations enforceable by the policyholders, as the scheme is designed to fulfill the obligations of the insolvent insurer, HIH, towards its policyholders.

5. The HIH Claims Support Scheme alters the traditional principles of equitable contribution between co-insurers by introducing a government-funded mechanism that pays policyholders directly, thereby potentially disrupting the co-insurers' mutual obligation to contribute equally to the payment of a loss.

6. The Commonwealth can be required to contribute to the payment made by one insurer to a policyholder if the other insurer has already been discharged from its liability due to the Commonwealth's intervention under the HIH Claims Support Scheme, as the fairness of the situation demands an equitable distribution of the burden among the parties involved.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court was tasked with determining the nature and scope of the HIH Claims Support Scheme established by the Commonwealth, and how it relates to the obligations of the insurers under the policy. The HIH Claims Support Scheme was established to provide financial assistance to individuals who had insurance policies with companies that were part of the HIH group, which had become insolvent. The court analyzed the legal framework and documentation surrounding the scheme, including the Appropriation (HIH Assistance) Act 2001 (Cth), the HIH Claims Support Trust Deed, the Commonwealth Management Agreement, and the Claims Management Agreement. The court concluded that the scheme was a trust arrangement, with the Commonwealth as the settlor and the HIH Claims Support Trustee as the trustee. The trustee was obligated to make payments to eligible applicants under the scheme, and these payments were considered to be obligations enforceable by the policyholders.

The court also considered whether the Commonwealth could be held liable for contribution under the HIH Claims Support Scheme when it had made payments to policyholders. The court found that the Commonwealth's intervention through the scheme did not necessarily disrupt the traditional principles of co-insurance, and that the scheme could create a mutuality between the insurers that would allow for a claim of contribution. However, the court held that the Commonwealth could not be required to contribute to the payment made by one insurer to a policyholder when the other insurer had already been discharged from its liability due to the Commonwealth's intervention.

The court further determined that the HIH Claims Support Scheme did not alter the traditional principles of equitable contribution between co-insurers, but it did impact the ability of one insurer to claim contribution from another under the scheme. The court held that the Commonwealth's payment under the scheme could be considered as fulfilling the obligations of the insolvent insurer, and that this payment could form the basis for a claim of contribution from the solvent insurer.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the HIH Claims Support Scheme, while providing financial assistance to policyholders, does not necessarily alter the traditional principles of co-insurance and equitable contribution between insurers. However, the court's intervention through the scheme can create a mutuality between the insurers that allows for a claim of contribution, and the scheme's payments can be considered as fulfilling the obligations of the insolvent insurer, forming the basis for a claim of contribution from the solvent insurer. The Commonwealth, however, cannot be held liable for contribution under the scheme when it has made payments to policyholders.