HIGH COURT AMENDMENT (CONSTITUTIONAL WRITS
AND OTHER MATTERS) RULES 2018
9 OCTOBER 2018
EXPLANATORY STATEMENT
These Amendment Rules of Court, signed by the Justices of the High Court of Australia on 9 October 2018, are made by the Justices under the Judiciary Act 1903, the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918, the Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976 and the High Court of Australia Act 1979.
Applications for constitutional and other writs
Following a review of the provisions in the High Court Rules 2004 relating to applications for writs of mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, habeas corpus and quo warranto, the Justices of the High Court propose a number of amendments to Part 25 of the Rules to provide a more streamlined procedure for the filing and consideration of applications.
Part 25 Chapter 2
Title of the application
The Court proposes to move away from using the phrase “application for an order to show cause”, which was more appropriate in the pre-2004 rules of court which provided for a two‑step (initially ex parte) process for such applications. The Rules have been amended to reflect this change in terminology by substituting the words “application for a constitutional or other writ”.
Time for service
The time for service of an application is reduced from the present 90 days to 7 days.
Written response
To ensure the issues between the parties are identified at an early stage of the proceedings the Justices propose to include a requirement for the filing of a response by the defendant to an application (proposed rule 25.07) and a reply by the applicant (proposed rule 25.08), along the lines of the procedures adopted for applications for removal and applications for special leave to appeal.
Consideration and determination of an application
In light of the new requirement for the defendant to respond in writing to the application, the revised Rules will make clear that an application may be finally determined on the first occasion it comes before the Court, without the need for a preliminary directions hearing.
Rule 25.09 provides for the manner of determination of an application, including that the Court or a Justice may dismiss an application, without listing it for hearing, on the ground that the application does not disclose an arguable basis for the relief sought or is an abuse of the process of the Court.
Schedule 1 Form of Application, Response and Writs
The Application (Form 12) has been amended to require in paragraph 1 reference to any extension of time sought in relation to the application.
A new form (Form 12A) – Response to Application for a Constitutional or Other Writ has been added to Schedule 1.
The rules pertaining to particular writs have been simplified and the language of the forms of a Writ of mandamus (Form 13) and a Writ of Habeas Corpus (Form 16) modified accordingly.
Additional amendments to the Rules
The Court has taken the opportunity to update and…
Overview
The High Court Amendment (Constitutional Writs and Other Matters) Rules 2018, enacted on 9 October 2018, were introduced to modernise and streamline the process for filing and considering applications for constitutional and other writs in the High Court of Australia. These rules were developed by the Justices of the High Court under the authority of the Judiciary Act 1903, the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918, the Nauru (High Court Appeals) Act 1976, and the High Court of Australia Act 1979. The objective of these amendments is to enhance the efficiency of the court's processes by simplifying the terminology and procedural requirements, reducing the time for service of applications, and ensuring that the issues between the parties are identified early through written responses and replies. The changes also clarify the circumstances under which an application may be dismissed without a hearing and update various forms and procedures to reflect these modifications.
Scope and Application
The High Court Amendment (Constitutional Writs and Other Matters) Rules 2018, as per the explanatory statement, pertain to the procedures for applications involving constitutional and other writs in the High Court of Australia. These rules apply to any party seeking a constitutional or other writ, including mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, habeas corpus, and quo warranto, under the jurisdiction of the High Court. The changes primarily affect legal practitioners and parties involved in constitutional litigation before the High Court. The amendments aim to streamline the process by modifying the terminology, reducing the time for service of an application, and requiring written responses from both the defendant and the applicant. The High Court also updated and clarified additional provisions in the Rules, including those relating to the writ of summons and summary dismissal of proceedings. The rules apply nationally across Australia, as they are made by the Justices of the High Court under federal statutes. There are no stated exclusions or exemptions in these Amendment Rules, and no subordinate instruments extend or restrict their application.
Key Provisions
- The main operative sections of the High Court Amendment (Constitutional Writs and Other Matters) Rules 2018 focus on streamlining the process for applications for constitutional and other writs. Rule 25.06 introduces a new terminology for applications, replacing the phrase “application for an order to show cause” with “application for a constitutional or other writ” (Part 25, Chapter 2). The time for service of an application is reduced to seven days from the previous ninety days (Rule 25.04). Additionally, the rules now require the defendant to file a written response (Rule 25.07) and the applicant to file a reply (Rule 25.08). The rules also clarify that an application may be finally determined on the first occasion it comes before the Court without the need for a preliminary directions hearing (Rule 25.09).
- These amendments impose certain obligations on parties involved in applications for writs. The defendant must now file a written response to the application, ensuring that the issues between the parties are identified early in the proceedings (Rule 25.07). The applicant must also file a reply to the defendant's response (Rule 25.08). Furthermore, the rules provide that the Court or a Justice may dismiss an application without listing it for hearing if the application does not disclose an arguable basis for the relief sought or is an abuse of the process of the Court (Rule 25.09).
- The rules also establish potential offences and consequences for breaches. Although specific offences and penalties are not detailed in the provided text, the rules allow for the dismissal of proceedings not prosecuted with due diligence, or those that are scandalous, frivolous or vexatious, among other reasons (Rule 28.01.2). These decisions can be made by the Court or a Justice on the application of a party or on the Court's or Justice's own motion (Rule 28.01.3). The rules thus provide a framework for maintaining the integrity and efficiency of the Court's processes by ensuring that only serious and arguable applications proceed to a hearing.
- Area of Law
- Civil Litigation & Procedure
- Instrument
- Statutory Instrument
- Concepts
- Definitions & Interpretation
- Commencement Provisions
- Regulatory Standards