FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Higgins v JSS Logistics Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2) [2023] FCA 92
File number: WAD 265 of 2021 Judgment of: BANKS-SMITH J Date of judgment: 9 February 2023 Date of publication of reasons: 14 February 2023 Catchwords: CORPORATIONS - application by liquidators of company for approval of entry into settlement deed under s 477(2A) and s 477(2B) of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) - settlement involves payment from funds held on trust - dispute as to access to trust funds - compromise of debt due to company in liquidation - whether resolution of a number of claims by way of settlement deed commercially reasonable and in interests of creditors - potential for performance to exceed three months - application granted Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 477, Division 6, Part 5.6 Cases cited: Ball, in the matter of ACN 605 650 182 Pty Ltd (in liq) [2022] FCA 2
Corporate Affairs Commission v ASC Timber Pty Ltd (1998) 16 ACLC 1642
Higgins v JSS Logistics Pty Ltd (in liq) [2022] FCA 1320
Lindholm (liquidator), in the matter of Aviation 3030 Pty Ltd (in liq) [2021] FCA 1244
Re Opel Networks Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 1245
Vardy v Linz, in the matter of Bondi Pizza Pty Ltd (in liq) [2021] FCA 530
Division: General Division Registry: Western Australia National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency Number of paragraphs: 41 Date of hearing: 9 February 2023 Counsel for the Plaintiff: The Plaintiff did not appear Counsel for the First and Second Defendants: The First and Second Defendants did not appear Counsel for the Third Defendant: Mr AG Norwood Solicitor for the Third Defendant: Trinix Lawyers ORDERS
WAD 265 of 2021 BETWEEN: SARAH JONINE HIGGINS
Plaintiff
AND: JSS LOGISTICS PTY LTD (IN LIQ) (ACN 134 369 761)
First Defendant
JAMES LAURENCE STEWART
Second Defendant
GREGORY BRUCE DUDLEY AND JEROME HALL MOHEN AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATORS OF JSS LOGISTICS PTY LTD (IN LIQ) (ACN 134 369 761)
Third Defendants
ORDER MADE BY:
BANKS-SMITH J
DATE OF ORDER:
9 FEBRUARY 2023
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.Gregory Bruce Dudley and Jerome Hall Mohen as joint and several liquidators of the first defendant be joined as third defendants.
2.Pursuant to s 477(2A) and s 477(2B) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the third defendants on behalf of the first defendant be authorised nunc pro tunc to enter into the deed of settlement dated 10 November 2022 with Simm Group Assets Pty Ltd and Simmcal Pty Ltd.
3.Paragraph 4 of the orders made 20 December 2021 be vacated, and the surplus proceeds of sale from the agreement of sale between Simm Group Assets Pty Ltd and the first defendant dated on or about 15 November 2021, as amended by a deed of amendment dated 15 November 2021, currently held in the trust account of the plaintiff's solicitors (Mendelawitz Morton),…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Higgins v JSS Logistics Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] FCA 92
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court considered the principles established in previous cases, emphasizing that it does not generally interfere with the commercial judgment of the liquidator unless there is a lack of good faith, an error in law or principle, or substantial grounds for doubting the prudence of the liquidator's conduct. The Court noted that the liquidators had provided detailed reasons for considering the settlement deed to be in the best interests of the creditors, including the avoidance of further litigation costs and uncertainty, and the potential for performance of obligations to exceed three months.
After reviewing the liquidators' affidavits and the evidence presented, the Court found that the settlement deed was commercially reasonable and in the interests of the creditors. The Court granted the liquidators' application, authorizing them to enter into the deed nunc pro tunc, and ordered that the surplus proceeds of sale, currently held in a trust account, be released to the liquidators. The Court also ordered that the liquidators' costs of the application be considered proper costs of the liquidation.
In summary, the Court approved the liquidators' entry into the settlement deed, acknowledging the commercial benefits of resolving the disputes through the deed rather than continuing litigation, and the potential for the obligations under the deed to be discharged within a period longer than three months. The orders of the Court effectively allowed the liquidators to implement the settlement deed and provided for the release of trust funds to facilitate the resolution of the disputes.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Gregory Bruce Dudley and Jerome Hall Mohen as joint and several liquidators of the first defendant be joined as third defendants.
2. Pursuant to s 477(2A) and s 477(2B) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the third defendants on behalf of the first defendant be authorised nunc pro tunc to enter into the deed of settlement dated 10 November 2022 with Simm Group Assets Pty Ltd and Simmcal Pty Ltd.
3. Paragraph 4 of the orders made 20 December 2021 be vacated, and the surplus proceeds of sale from the agreement of sale between Simm Group Assets Pty Ltd and the first defendant dated on or about 15 November 2021, as amended by a deed of amendment dated 15 November 2021, currently held in the trust account of the plaintiff's solicitors (Mendelawitz Morton), be released to the third defendants.
4. The third defendants' costs of this application are proper costs of the liquidation.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The liquidators consider that the obligations under the Deed may also take longer than three months to be discharged, so formed the view that approval is likely and should be sought under s 477(2B) of the Corporations Act in order to implement the Deed.Consideration of the merits by liquidators Mr Dudley explains in his affidavit why he considers that entry into the Deed is reasonable, proper and beneficial for the creditors of JSS Logistics. He set out six reasons, which I paraphrase. First, he notes that JSS Logistics will be released from debts that total some $832,000, having regard to the missing plant and equipment of $332,000, and missing stock claimed at $500,000, according to the amounts claimed by Simm Group. It will also be released from claims relating to the alleged excluded fleet. Second, and in return, the Simm parties are to be paid $500,000 from the trust account plus have the benefit of the release of the Simmcal debt. The liquidators consider the real value of that debt may be only $64,651.51, so that the benefit to the Simm parties can reasonably be assessed at $564,651.51, an amount considerably less than the $832,000 claimed from JSS Logistics. Third, JSS Logistics will obtain the benefit of immediate access to the balance funds in the trust account without further dispute and, in particular, without awaiting the outcome of the disputed damages claim. Fourth, the damages claim, being the largest claim by the Simm parties, does not need to be resolved immediately and will be subjected to the usual proof of debt process, with the added contractual obligation of the Simm parties to assist the liquidators in providing relevant information for that process. Fifth, any opposition to the sale of the excluded fleet items by the liquidators is avoided and they may now proceed to realise those assets in the usual course. Sixth, the uncertainty and costs of litigation that might otherwise have been incurred by the liquidators in resolving the various claims involving the Simm parties and JSS Logistics is avoided, including claims relating to the funds held on trust.Principles - power under s 477(2A) and s 477(2B) The principles that apply to the exercise of power under s 477(2A) and s 477(2B) of the Corporations Act are well known and were usefully collected by Halley J in Vardy v Linz, in the matter of Bondi Pizza Pty Ltd (in liq) [2021] FCA 530. I respectfully adopted those reasons in Rathner v Fopar Nominees Pty Ltd, in the matter of Reliance Franchise Partners Pty Ltd (in liq) [2022] FCA 1313 at [14], and again adopt the following from his Honour's reasons:[13]Section 477(2A) of the Corporations Act, combined with reg 5.4.02 of the Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth) provides that, except with the approval of the Court, of the committee of inspection or of a resolution of the creditors, a liquidator of a company must not compromise a debt to the company if the amount claimed by the company is more than $100,000.[14]Section 477(2B) of the Corporations Act provides that except with the approval of the Court, of the committee of inspection or of a resolution of the creditors, a liquidator of a company must not enter into an agreement on the company's behalf if the term of the agreement may end, or obligations of a party to the agreement may, according to the terms of the agreement, be discharged by performance more than three months after the agreement was entered into.[15]It is well established that the Court does not concern itself with the commercial desirability of the transaction in an application for approval pursuant to ss 477(2A) and 477(2B) of the Corporations Act. As Giles J stated in the much quoted passage in Re Spedley Securities Ltd (in liq) (1992) 9 ACSR 83; 10 ACLC 1742 at 85-86:… the court pays regard to the commercial judgment of the liquidator (re Chase Corporation (Australia) Equities Ltd (1990) 8 ACLC 1118). That is not say that it rubber stamps whatever is put forward by the liquidator but, as is made clear in Re Minerals Securities Australia Ltd [1973] 2 NSWLR 207 at 231-2, the court is necessarily confined in attempting to second guess the liquidator in the exercise of his powers, and generally will not interfere unless there can be seen to be some lack of good faith, some error in law or principle, or real and substantial grounds for doubting the prudence of the liquidator's conduct.[16]Further, the observations of Bathurst CJ in Fortress Credit Corporation (Australia) II Pty Ltd v Fletcher and Barnet (2015) 89 NSWLR 110; [2015] NSWCA 85 at [125] are apposite:Further, it is not generally the function of the court, in granting approval under s 477(2B) of the Act, to review a liquidator's commercial judgment or to second guess its decision. The court will generally not interfere unless there seems to be some lack of good faith, some error of law or principle, or a real or substantial ground for doubting the prudence of the liquidator's conduct. However, as was pointed out in each of the cases cited, the court does not act as a mere rubber stamp and will confer the power only when it is satisfied that a case for its exercise, in the particular circumstances, has been shown.[footnotes omitted]…[22]A further potential issue arises by reason of the fact that the Deed of Settlement and Release has already been entered into, albeit that it is subject to the approval of the Court. While approval should normally be obtained in advance of the exercise of the power in question, there appears to be no doubt that the Court has the power to give approval that operates from an earlier time: Re Bell Group Ltd (in liq); ex parte Woodings (2013) 97 ACSR 117; [2013] WASC 409 at [34]; Chamberlain v RG & H Investments Pty Limited, in the matter of Hardy Bros (Earthmoving) Pty Limited (in liq) (No 2) (2009) 76 ACSR 415; [2009] FCA 1531 at [22]-[24]; and Re Bell Group Ltd (in liq); ex parte Woodings [2020] WASC 121 at [61]-[62].[23]As noted in those authorities, there is some divergence of opinion as to the precise basis as to how retrospective approval ought to be effected. The divergence of opinion, however, would appear to make clear that, for an abundance of caution, it may be prudent for the Court to order that the approval be granted nunc pro tunc and potentially also make a declaration under s 1322(4)(a) that the settlement agreement is not invalid by reason of it having been entered into without the Court's prior approval. In addition, consideration has been given in those authorities to the making of directions under s 479(3) of the Corporations Act that each plaintiff may rely on the settlement agreement as if it had been entered into with the prior approval of the Court, and that in appropriate circumstances, an extension of time might be required for a plaintiff to bring an application for approval under s 477(2A) or s 277(2B), and in those circumstances, an order may be made that time be extended. Section 479(3) of the Corporations Act has since been repealed, but I note that such a direction could now be made pursuant to s 90-15 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations), being Sch 2 of the Corporations Act.