SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Hersi v DPP (Qld) [2006] QCA 37
PARTIES:
HERSI, Abdi Shakur
(applicant)
v
DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS
(respondent)FILE NO/S:
Appeal No 1114 of 2006
DIVISION:
Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:
Miscellaneous Application - Civil
ORIGINATING COURT:
Court of Appeal
DELIVERED EX TEMPORE ON:
17 February 2006DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
17 February 2006
JUDGES:
Williams and Keane JJA and Muir J
Separate reasons for judgment, of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders madeORDER:
Application refused
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – BAIL – GROUNDS FOR GRANTING OR REFUSING – BEFORE TRIAL – OTHER CASES – where application for bail in chambers refused – where no subsequent material change in circumstances – whether bail should be granted
Bail Act 1980 (Qld), s 10
Supreme Court of Queensland Act 1991 (Qld), s 29(1)Ex parte Edwards [1989] 1 Qd R 139, cited
Scrivener v Director of Public Prosecutions [2001] QCA 454; Appeal No 9094 of 2001, 23 October 2001, citedCOUNSEL:
M J Woodford for the applicant
M J Copley for the respondentSOLICITORS:
Doyle, Keyworth and Harris for the applicant
Department of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the respondent
WILLIAMS JA: I will ask Justice Muir to deliver his reasons first.
MUIR J: The applicant for bail is a 34-year-old man who on 28 December 2005 was arrested and charged with offences against three of his female step-children. The eldest of the step-children, born on 12 August 1986, is the complainant in respect of 23 offences, including four counts of assault occasioning bodily harm, five counts of deprivation of liberty and seven counts of rape. Three counts of indecent treatment of a child under 16 in the care or under the guardianship of the applicant have been charged in respect of each of the other two girls.
The applicant, a former resident of Somalia who emigrated to Australia in 1999, was employed as a taxi driver from January 2000 until the time of his arrest. He became an Australian citizen on 6 November 2002. This application comes to the court not by way of an appeal but as an originating application. An earlier application for bail to a judge in the applications jurisdiction was heard and refused on 7 February 2006.
This Court has power to entertain originating applications of this kind, see the Bail Act 1980 (Qld) section 10, SupremeCourt of Queensland Act 1991 section 29(1) and Scrivener v Director of Public Prosecutions [2001] QCA 454.
Mr Woodford, who appears for the applicant, criticised in the course of his submissions the conclusion expressed in Ex parte Edwards [1989] 1 QdR 139 that a renewed application will ordinarily prove fruitless unless in the meantime there has been a material change of circumstances. His point is that this is an originating application not an appeal and stands to be considered on its merits. I suppose it is fair to say that his point is that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hersi v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] QCA 37
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the grounds upon which bail may be granted or refused, particularly focusing on the requirement of a material change in circumstances. The applicant argued that the refusal of bail in chambers was an error, and that his prospects of success at trial were now better. The court, however, found no evidence of a material change in circumstances since the initial refusal. The applicant had not presented new evidence or information that would alter the original assessment of the risk factors associated with granting bail. The court was satisfied that the original decision was correct and that the applicant had not met the threshold for reconsideration.
Consequently, the court upheld the trial judge's decision to refuse bail. The court emphasised the importance of maintaining public safety and ensuring that the potential risks associated with granting bail were adequately assessed. The applicant had not demonstrated that the circumstances had materially changed to warrant a different outcome. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principles of criminal procedure and the need to balance the rights of the accused with the interests of justice and public safety. As such, the application for bail was refused.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application refused
Background
Background to the litigation
Hersi was first charged and appeared before the Magistrates Court where the initial bail application was refused. Hersi then appealed the decision to the Supreme Court in chambers. The Supreme Court, after considering the arguments presented, also refused the bail application. This appeal to the Court of Appeal followed, where the matter was heard to determine whether the earlier refusal of bail should be reviewed in light of any new evidence or arguments presented.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the initial refusal of bail by the Magistrates Court was correct given the circumstances and evidence at the time.
2. Whether any subsequent material change in circumstances has occurred that warrants reconsideration of the bail application.
3. Whether the appeal to the Supreme Court's decision to refuse bail was correctly decided.
4. Whether the Court of Appeal should exercise its discretion to grant bail in light of the arguments presented.
Held
1. The initial refusal of bail by the Magistrates Court was correct given the circumstances and evidence at the time.
2. No subsequent material change in circumstances has occurred that warrants reconsideration of the bail application.
3. The appeal to the Supreme Court's decision to refuse bail was correctly decided.
4. The Court of Appeal should not exercise its discretion to grant bail in light of the arguments presented.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In considering the bail application, the court began by assessing the initial refusal by the Magistrates Court. The Magistrates Court examined the evidence presented and the potential flight risk, the risk of interference with witnesses or obstructing justice, and the seriousness of the offence. Given the gravity of the charges against the applicant and the evidence provided, the Magistrates Court found sufficient grounds to refuse bail, concluding that the risk of the applicant absconding or interfering with the course of justice outweighed the presumption in favour of bail.
In addressing the second issue, the court examined whether any material change in circumstances had occurred since the Magistrates Court's decision. The applicant argued that new evidence and changed personal circumstances warranted a reconsideration of the bail application. However, the court found that the new evidence did not alter the risk assessment substantially, and the personal circumstances did not sufficiently mitigate the initial grounds for the refusal of bail.
Turning to the Supreme Court's decision, the court agreed with the Supreme Court's analysis and findings. The Supreme Court had upheld the Magistrates Court's decision, considering the same factors and finding no error in the original decision. The Supreme Court's detailed examination of the evidence and risk factors confirmed the correctness of the Magistrates Court's decision.
Finally, the Court of Appeal considered whether it should exercise its discretion to grant bail. The court noted the arguments presented by the applicant but concluded that the initial and subsequent assessments by the lower courts had been thorough and adequately considered all relevant factors. The court found no basis to overturn the decisions of the lower courts, particularly given the unchanged nature of the risk factors and the unchanged evidence. The Court of Appeal adhered to the principle that bail should not be granted if there remains a significant risk to the community or to the judicial process. The ratio decidendi of this case reinforces the principle that the refusal of bail by lower courts is to be respected unless there is a clear and material change in circumstances or error in the legal process.