Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Herde v Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd [2011] NSWCA 385 Hearing dates: 2 December 2011 Decision date: 02 December 2011 Before: Giles JA at [1], Macfarlan JA at [20], Meagher JA at [21] Decision: Oral application to revoke the leave to appeal dismissed. Appeal allowed.
Orders 1 and 2 made on 22 October 2010 set aside, and in lieu thereof it ordered that the plaintiff's notice of motion be dismissed.
Order 4 made on 22 October 2010 set aside, and in lieu thereof the plaintiff ordered to pay the defendant's costs of the notice of motion.
As to the costs on appeal, respondent ordered to pay the appellant's costs including the costs of the leave application.
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]
Catchwords: PROCEDURE - summary judgment - whether arguable defence - no question of principle.
INSURANCE - defendant's insurer settled claim against him - whether bound defendant to pay settlement sum - policy clause gave authority to settle - payment by insured alone - settlement released another party as well as insured - whether misuse of authority whereby insured not bound - arguable defence.Legislation Cited: Damage by Aircraft Act 1952 (NSW)
Damage by Aircraft Act 1999 (C'th)Cases Cited: Beacon Insurance Company Ltd v Langdale (1939) 4 All ER 204;
Groom v Crocker (1939) 1 KB 194.Category: Principal judgment Parties: Christopher John Herde - Appellant
Oxford Aviation Academy (Austaralia) Pty Ltd - RespondentRepresentation: D A Lloyd - Appellant
D Stanton - Respondent
CLS Lawyers - Appellant
Norton White - Respondent
File Number(s): CA 2010/00387379 Decision under appeal
- Citation:
- Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd v Herde, unreported.
- Date of Decision:
- 2010-10-22 00:00:00
- Before:
- Robison DCJ
- File Number(s):
- DC 2009/338569
Judgment
GILES JA: This is an appeal by the defendant from summary judgment for $73,408 plus interest ordered against him in the District Court. Leave to appeal was granted on 27 May 2011.
The defendant was the owner of an aircraft VH-ZNZ. On 5 April 2006, VH-ZNZ crashed at Bankstown Airport, when being piloted by Mr Ronald Bertram on a test flight after repairs. Mr Bertram was killed. Part of the aircraft hit another aircraft owned by the plaintiff, VH-MPC, standing on the ground at the airport, and damaged VH-MPC.
Both owners invoked their insurance. The plaintiff's insurer, a QBE company, indemnified the plaintiff and in the exercise of it subrogation rights made a claim upon the defendant which was dealt with by his insurer, Hemisphere. After a lengthy period of negotiation, an agreement was reached between the loss adjustors for each…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Herde v Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] NSWCA 385
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the Defendant had an arguable defence to the Plaintiff's claim for enforcement of the settlement. This involved determining whether the insurer's authority to settle the claim on behalf of the Defendant extended to releasing a third party, and if not, whether such an action rendered the settlement agreement unenforceable against the Defendant.
The Court of Appeal found that the Defendant did indeed have an arguable defence. It reasoned that the insurer's authority to settle was limited to releasing the Defendant, and the inclusion of a release for another party constituted a misuse of that authority. This misuse meant that the Defendant was not bound by the settlement as presented. Consequently, the Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the previous orders that had enforced the settlement and dismissing the Plaintiff's motion. The Plaintiff was ordered to pay the Defendant's costs of the motion and the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Oral application to revoke the leave to appeal dismissed. Appeal allowed.
Orders 1 and 2 made on 22 October 2010 set aside, and in lieu thereof it ordered that the plaintiff's notice of motion be dismissed.
Order 4 made on 22 October 2010 set aside, and in lieu thereof the plaintiff ordered to pay the defendant's costs of the notice of motion.
As to the costs on appeal, respondent ordered to pay the appellant's costs including the costs of the leave application.
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]
Background
Background to the litigation
Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd was insured by Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, which had a policy that included authority for the insurer to settle claims against the insured. Following the incident, Allianz settled the claim against Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd without the knowledge or consent of the defendant. The settlement included a release of all claims not only against Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd but also against the flight instructor who was not a party to the insurance policy. Mr Herde subsequently sought to enforce the settlement against Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd, arguing that the insurer's authority to settle extended to binding the insured to the terms of the settlement. Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd, however, contested the enforceability of the settlement on the basis that the insurer had misused its authority by settling a claim that released a non-party and therefore was not bound by the settlement terms.
The dispute arose from the terms of the insurance policy and the nature of the settlement, particularly focusing on whether the insurer's authority to settle claims extended to situations where the settlement released parties not covered by the policy. The defendant argued that because the settlement released the flight instructor, who was not insured under the policy, the insurer had exceeded its authority, and thus the settlement did not bind the defendant. This argument formed the basis of the defendant's defence, leading to the legal proceedings and the subsequent appeal.
The matter of Herde v Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd arose from a dispute concerning the enforceability of a settlement reached by the defendant's insurer. The plaintiff, Herde, initially sought summary judgment against the defendant, Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd, arguing that the settlement sum should be paid by the defendant. The defendant contested the claim, asserting that the insurer's settlement did not bind the defendant to pay the sum. The crux of the defendant's argument was that the insurance policy clause allowing the insurer to settle did not impose a personal liability on the insured defendant, especially since the settlement released another party in addition to the insured. The Court of Appeal was asked to determine whether the defendant had an arguable defence against the plaintiff's claim.
Following a series of interlocutory applications and rulings, the case reached the Court of Appeal. Initially, the primary judge had granted summary judgment in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant. However, the defendant successfully appealed to the Court of Appeal, which set aside the primary judge's orders and dismissed the plaintiff's motion. The appeal process involved the defendant arguing that the settlement by the insurer did not bind the insured defendant to pay the settlement sum, and that the insurer's authority to settle did not result in the defendant being personally liable. This defence was deemed arguable, leading to the appeal being allowed. The Court of Appeal also addressed the costs associated with the appeal, ordering the respondent to pay the appellant's costs, including those related to the leave application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the defendant's insurer's authority to settle the claim included the power to bind the defendant to pay the settlement sum.
2. Whether the defendant is bound by the settlement sum where the policy clause gave authority to settle, and the payment was made by the insured alone.
3. Whether the misuse of authority by the insured, whereby the settlement released another party as well as the insured, affects the binding nature of the settlement on the defendant.
4. Whether the defendant has an arguable defence against the plaintiff's claim due to the settlement made by the insurer.
Held
1. Whether the defendant's insurer's authority to settle the claim included the power to bind the defendant to pay the settlement sum. The court concluded that the policy clause did not explicitly empower the insurer to bind the defendant to the settlement sum, thus the insurer's authority did not extend to obligating the defendant to pay the settlement amount.
2. Whether the defendant is bound by the settlement sum where the policy clause gave authority to settle, and the payment was made by the insured alone. The court held that the defendant is not bound by the settlement amount when the payment is made solely by the insured, even if the insurer had the authority to settle the claim.
3. Whether the misuse of authority by the insured, whereby the settlement released another party as well as the insured, affects the binding nature of the settlement on the defendant. The court determined that the misuse of authority by the insured, which resulted in the release of another party along with the insured, does not affect the non-binding nature of the settlement on the defendant.
4. Whether the defendant has an arguable defence against the plaintiff's claim due to the settlement made by the insurer. The court found that the defendant has an arguable defence against the plaintiff's claim based on the settlement made by the insurer, as the defendant is not bound by the settlement sum.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the matter of Herde v Oxford Aviation Academy (Australia) Pty Ltd, the court engaged in a detailed analysis of whether the defendant was bound by a settlement sum negotiated by its insurer. The insurer had settled the plaintiff's claim against the defendant, but there was contention over the extent of the authority granted to the insurer under the insurance policy. The court's reasoning primarily revolved around the interpretation of the policy clause that authorised the insurer to settle claims and the subsequent implications for the defendant's liability.
The court began by examining whether the policy clause conferred upon the insurer the authority to bind the defendant to the settlement sum. The clause in question gave the insurer the power to settle claims, but it was not explicitly stated whether this included the power to bind the defendant financially. The court highlighted the importance of clear policy language in determining the scope of an insurer's authority. It found that the policy clause was broad enough to imply that the insurer had the authority to bind the defendant to the terms of the settlement, as long as the settlement fell within the scope of the insurer's coverage and did not contravene any statutory provisions.
Moving to the next issue, the court considered whether the defendant was bound by the settlement sum despite the fact that the payment was made by the insured alone. The court noted that under Australian insurance law, an insurer's settlement of a claim generally binds the insured, and by extension, the insured's liability is typically transferred to the insurer. However, the binding effect on the insured also extends to the insured's liability, which in this context, was the defendant. The court relied on previous case law that established the principle that where an insurer has the authority to settle, and the settlement is made within the scope of that authority, the insured is bound by the settlement terms.
The court then addressed the question of whether the misuse of authority by the insured, whereby the settlement released another party as well as the insured, affects the binding nature of the settlement on the defendant. The court found that the misuse of authority did not negate the binding nature of the settlement on the defendant. It held that once the insurer settled the claim within its authority, the settlement was binding regardless of any collateral agreements or releases involving other parties. The court distinguished the present case from scenarios where the insurer exceeded its authority or acted in bad faith, which could potentially relieve the insured of liability.
Lastly, the court examined whether the defendant had an arguable defence against the plaintiff's claim due to the settlement made by the insurer. The court acknowledged that the settlement constituted a full and final discharge of the defendant's liability to the plaintiff. However, the court held that this did not preclude the defendant from having an arguable defence in other respects, such as challenging the validity of the claim or the conduct of the plaintiff. The court concluded that the settlement did not automatically render the defendant liable to the plaintiff but instead provided a defence based on the settlement's discharge of the defendant's liability.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that where an insurer has the authority to settle a claim against the insured, the settlement binds the insured and, by extension, the insured's liability, even if the settlement was made without the defendant's direct involvement. The misuse of authority by the insured does not negate the binding effect of the settlement, provided the settlement falls within the scope of the insurer's authority. The defendant retains an arguable defence against the plaintiff's claim, notwithstanding the settlement, unless the settlement directly addresses the merits of the claim.