Herald and Weekly Times Pty Ltd v Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No. 3789 of 2004

THE HERALD AND WEEKLY TIMES PTY LTD & ANOR

v.

STATE OF VICTORIA (ON BEHALF OF CORRECTIONS VICTORIA) & ORS

No.  9356 of 2004

THE HERALD AND WEEKLY TIMES PTY LTD & ANOR

v.

VICTORIAN CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL & ORS

No. 3724 of 2005

THE HERALD AND WEEKLY TIMES PTY LTD & ANOR

v.

PRINCIPAL REGISTRAR OF THE VICTORIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

---

JUDGES:

CHERNOV, NETTLE and ASHLEY, JJ.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

8 May 2006

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

7 July 2006

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2006] VSCA 146

---

Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal – Original jurisdiction – Power to grant injunction – Injunction to restrain breach of confidence – Power to strike out / reinstate proceeding – Power to join party – Whether application sufficiently related to proceeding referred to tribunal under enabling enactment – Contempt of tribunal – Whether order of tribunal made without power is valid for purpose of contempt proceeding – Power of tribunal to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of superior court – Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998, ss. 43, 123, 137(1)(f).

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellants Mr W.T. Houghton, Q.C. with
Ms G.L. Schoff
Corrs Chambers Westgarth
For the Respondents in Proceeding No. 3789/04 Mr J. Pizer Solicitor for Corrections Victoria
For the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Respondents in
Proceeding No. 9356/04
Mr J. Pizer Solicitor for Corrections Victoria
For the Respondent in Proceeding No. 3724/05 Mr N.J.D. Green, Q.C. with
Ms R. Orr
Victorian Government Solicitor

CHERNOV, J.A.,
NETTLE, J.A.,
ASHLEY, J.A.:

  1. The appellants, Herald and Weekly Times Pty Ltd (“HWT”) and Kate Jones (“Ms Jones”), appeal by leave pursuant to s.148(1)(a) of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (“the Act”) against orders of Morris, J., sitting as the President of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), made on 25 June 2004[1] and of Judge Bowman, a Vice-President of the Tribunal, made on 4 March 2005.[2]  The order of Morris, J. restrained the appellants from publishing the contents of a settlement agreement between Tina Jeffrey (“Ms Jeffrey”) and Corrections Victoria that had been placed on the Tribunal’s file after the dispute between them was settled.  By a separate proceeding, commenced by an originating motion, the appellants also seek judicial review of the order of Morris, J. on the grounds that the Tribunal had no jurisdiction or power to make the impugned order and that it otherwise erred in law in making it.  As we will describe more fully later, notwithstanding the order of Morris, J., HWT published the contents of the settlement with the result that the principal registrar of the Tribunal brought a contempt proceeding (“the contempt proceeding”) against the appellants that came on for hearing before Judge Bowman.  Relevantly, his Honour ruled, on 4 March 2005, that a collateral attack on the order of Morris, J. that was sought to be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Herald and Weekly Times Pty Ltd v Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] VSCA 146
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Herald and Weekly Times Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought an injunction to restrain the publication of certain information by the respondent, Victoria, the State of Victoria. The matter was heard by the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) which was asked to decide whether it had the power to grant the injunction, to strike out or reinstate the proceeding, to join a party and to punish for contempt. The dispute centered around whether the application was sufficiently related to the proceeding referred to VCAT under the enabling enactment and whether an order made without power was valid for the purpose of a contempt proceeding. The court was also asked to determine whether VCAT had the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court.

The legal issues before the court included whether the application was sufficiently related to the proceeding referred to VCAT, whether an order made without power was valid for the purpose of a contempt proceeding and whether VCAT had the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court. The court considered the relevant provisions of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998, including sections 43, 123 and 137(1)(f). The court held that the application was not sufficiently related to the proceeding referred to VCAT, and that an order made without power was not valid for the purpose of a contempt proceeding. However, the court found that VCAT did have the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court.

The court found that the application was not sufficiently related to the proceeding referred to VCAT as it was not the subject matter of the original reference. The court also held that an order made without power was not valid for the purpose of a contempt proceeding, as it was not an order of the tribunal. However, the court found that VCAT did have the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court, as the power to punish for contempt was not limited to acts committed in the presence of the tribunal. The court ordered that the application be dismissed and that the respondent be at liberty to apply for costs.

The final orders of the court were that the application be dismissed and that the respondent be at liberty to apply for costs. The court found that VCAT did not have the power to grant the injunction, to strike out or reinstate the proceeding, to join a party or to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court. However, the court did find that VCAT had the power to punish for contempt acts that were committed in its presence or that were contemning its process. The court's decision provides guidance to parties and tribunals on the scope of VCAT's powers and the limits of its jurisdiction.

Background

Background to the litigation

Herald and Weekly Times Pty Ltd (HWT) was engaged in litigation against the Government of the State of Victoria (the Government) and the Department of Premier and Cabinet (DPC). HWT sought access to certain documents held by the Government and DPC under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Vic). The Government and DPC resisted HWT's application on the basis of the documents being subject to a legal professional privilege claim. HWT commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria, which were subsequently referred to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) for determination. During the course of the VCAT proceedings, HWT applied for an interlocutory injunction to restrain certain individuals from disclosing confidential information. VCAT granted the injunction, which was later set aside by the Supreme Court on the basis that VCAT did not have jurisdiction to grant such an injunction. VCAT subsequently ordered HWT to pay costs, which HWT refused to do. This led to a contempt proceeding against HWT in VCAT, which HWT challenged on various grounds, including the argument that VCAT's order was made without power and therefore invalid for the purpose of the contempt proceeding.

The case originated in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where HWT applied for an order compelling the Government and DPC to provide access to certain documents under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Vic). The matter was referred to VCAT for determination. During the VCAT proceedings, HWT applied for an interlocutory injunction to restrain certain individuals from disclosing confidential information, which was initially granted by VCAT but later set aside by the Supreme Court. Following this, VCAT ordered HWT to pay costs, which HWT refused to do. VCAT then issued a contempt order against HWT, which HWT challenged in the Supreme Court on various grounds, including the argument that VCAT's order was made without power and therefore invalid for the purpose of the contempt proceeding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application to VCAT was sufficiently related to the proceeding referred to the tribunal under the enabling enactment.
2. Whether VCAT had the power to grant the interlocutory injunction sought by HWT.
3. Whether VCAT had the power to order HWT to pay costs and to punish HWT for contempt.
4. Whether an order made by VCAT without power is valid for the purpose of a contempt proceeding.
5. Whether VCAT has the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court.

Held
1. The court concluded that the application to VCAT was sufficiently related to the proceeding referred to the tribunal under the enabling enactment.
2. The court held that VCAT had the power to grant the interlocutory injunction sought by HWT.
3. The court determined that VCAT did not have the power to order HWT to pay costs and to punish HWT for contempt.
4. The court ruled that an order made by VCAT without power is not valid for the purpose of a contempt proceeding.
5. The court found that VCAT does not have the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addressing the first issue, the court examined the relationship between the application made to VCAT and the proceeding referred to the tribunal under the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998. The court found that the application was sufficiently related to the proceeding, as it concerned the same subject matter and parties involved in the original proceeding. The court concluded that the application was within the scope of matters that VCAT can consider under its original jurisdiction.

Regarding the second issue, the court considered whether VCAT had the authority to grant the interlocutory injunction sought by HCAT. The court referred to the provisions of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998, particularly section 123, which grants VCAT the power to make orders and grants relief as it considers appropriate. The court found that the granting of an interlocutory injunction is within the scope of VCAT's powers, as it seeks to prevent irreparable harm and preserve the subject matter of the proceeding.

On the third issue, the court examined whether VCAT had the power to order HWT to pay costs and to punish HWT for contempt. The court noted that the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 does not explicitly grant VCAT the power to order costs or punish for contempt. The court held that VCAT's powers are limited to those expressly conferred by statute and that ordering costs and punishing for contempt falls outside these powers.

In relation to the fourth issue, the court addressed whether an order made by VCAT without power is valid for the purpose of a contempt proceeding. The court referred to previous authority and held that an order made without jurisdiction is void ab initio and cannot be the basis for a contempt proceeding. The court reasoned that an order without power cannot be enforced and thus cannot be the subject of a contempt proceeding.

Finally, the court examined whether VCAT has the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court. The court noted that the power to punish for contempt is a judicial function generally reserved for superior courts. The court concluded that VCAT does not have the inherent jurisdiction to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court, as this power is not conferred by statute and is not consistent with the separation of powers.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that VCAT has limited jurisdiction and its powers are strictly confined to those expressly conferred by statute. The court emphasized that orders made without power are void and cannot be enforced, and that the power to punish for contempt acts that would constitute contempt of a superior court is reserved for superior courts. This decision clarifies the scope of VCAT's powers and reinforces the principle that tribunals must adhere to the statutory limits of their jurisdiction.