Hendricks v El-Dik (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Hendricks v El-Dik & Anor (No 3)

Citation:

[2015] ACTSC 417

Hearing Date:

3 September 2015

DecisionDate:

3 September 2015

Before:

Mossop AsJ

Decision:

See [17]

Category:

Ruling on Evidence

Catchwords:

EVIDENCE – Objection to admission of expert evidence served late in proceeding – assessment of reason for late service, significance of expert evidence, prejudice to objecting party, potential disruption to proceeding – turns on own facts

Parties:

Mohgamat Hendricks (Plaintiff)

Walid El-Dik (First Defendant)

Insurance Australia Limited trading as NRMA Insurance (Second Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr A Black SC, Mr A Muller and Mr D Crowe (Plaintiff)

Mr J Poulos QC and Mr B Wilson (First and Second Defendants)

Solicitors

Slater & Gordon (Plaintiff)

Sparke Helmore (First and Second Defendants)

File Number:

SC 460 of 2013

Introduction

  1. The plaintiff has objected to the tender of a report of Dr Robert Casey dated 28 August 2015.  That is a report which, for the first time in this case, provides expert evidence about the nature of the controller on the electric motor the subject of these proceedings.  I will refer to that motor as the accident motor.  The amount of power and the acceleration able to be produced by the accident motor have been the subject of expert investigation for some time.  By orders dated 19 March 2015 I directed that the experts participate in the preparation of a joint expert report and produce such a report by 15 May 2015.  The parties were then permitted to serve any supplementary liability expert reports by 29 May 2015.  Although testing of electric motors for the purposes of preparing the joint expert report took place on 29 April 2015, the process of preparation of the joint expert report took longer than expected with the result that the joint expert report was only finalised and dated 24 August 2015.  It became available to the parties shortly thereafter.  The relevant experts who participated in the process were Dr Robert Casey, a mechanical engineering consultant, Mr William Keramidas, a traffic engineer, Mr Grant Johnston, a traffic engineer, and Mr Alan Joy, a traffic engineer.  My statement of the particular expertise of these witnesses is inevitably inadequate and fails to give full recognition to the details of their qualifications.  The point to note at present is that Dr Casey is the only mechanical or electrical engineer involved at present and he has been retained by the defendants.  No report of a similarly qualified person has been served by the plaintiff.

  1. Following the provision of the joint expert report further instructions were received by two of those experts.  As a result of the plaintiff’s solicitors obtaining further data from the Australian Federal Police, Mr Johnston produced a further report dated 27 August 2015 relating to the estimated speed of the first defendant’s vehicle as he reversed out of the driveway.  As a result of the service of this report, Mr Keramidas produced a further report dated 28 August…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hendricks v El-Dik (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ACTSC 417
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Hendricks v El-Dik (No 3), the primary point of contention was the admission of expert evidence provided by Dr Casey and Mr Keramidas. The plaintiff sought to introduce this evidence late in the proceedings, which the defendants objected to, citing the late service of the objection and the potential prejudice it could cause them. The court was required to assess the validity of the objection, considering the reasons behind the late submission, the significance of the expert evidence, the prejudice to the defendants, and the potential disruption to the proceeding.

The court considered the legal principles governing the admissibility of late-served evidence, particularly in cases where expert opinions are involved. The court noted that the late submission of expert evidence could be justified if there were compelling reasons, such as the necessity of the evidence for the case or if the delay did not significantly prejudice the opposing party. The court also examined whether the defendants' right to a fair trial was compromised due to the late objection, and whether the evidence could still be considered without causing undue delay or disruption.

The court determined that while the objection was indeed served late, the significance of the expert evidence and the potential prejudice to the defendants warranted its admission. The court found that the defendants had not demonstrated substantial prejudice that would warrant excluding the evidence, and that the overall fairness of the proceedings would not be compromised by admitting it. The court also emphasised the importance of the experts participating in a further meeting to address any concerns and potentially prepare a joint expert report. The court reserved the issue of costs associated with the admission of the expert evidence for later determination.

The court made orders for the defendants to serve any further reports from Dr Casey and Mr Keramidas by a specific time. It also ordered the plaintiff to provide a response from their own expert by a date to be fixed. Additionally, the court directed that the experts participate in a further meeting to discuss their findings, with the possibility of preparing a joint expert report. The court reserved the question of costs associated with the admission of Dr Casey's report for future consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

That course will also generate the need for some further directions. Subject to any submissions of the parties I propose to make directions and orders to the following effect:

The defendants serve upon the plaintiff any further report from Dr Casey and Mr Keramidas arising out of the inspection by Dr Casey of the controller of the motor involved in the accident by 4.30 pm today.

The plaintiff serve a further report from Mr Joy, Mr Johnston or any other expert responding to the report of Dr Casey dated 28 August 2015 or the reports served pursuant to the previous order by a date to be fixed.

That each expert participate in a further meeting either in person or by telephone not later than a date to be fixed after I have heard submissions.

I will hear the parties as to whether or not a further joint expert report should be prepared arising out of such a meeting.

I will reserve the question of costs arising out of the admission of the report of Dr Casey dated 28 August 2015.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established