Hempel and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Hempel and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 3278 (3 September 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):     2024/2416

Re:Sharon Hempel

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mr S. Webb, Member

Date:3 September 2024

Place:Canberra

No jurisdiction. Application dismissed under s 42A(4) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

…….…[SGD]…………
Mr S. Webb, Member

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – jurisdiction – participant supports – compensation in respect of injury – recovery affected by special circumstances – estimate of compensation reduction amount – purported decision applying Rule relating to special circumstances – request for internal review denied – no request for reassessment of participant’s plan – purported decision lacks power and legal effect – no actual or deemed reviewable decision – no internal review decision – no jurisdiction  

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, s 25, 29, 42A

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013, s 9, 11, 32, 33, 35, 37, 47A, 48, 99, 100, 103, 107, 111, 116, 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants – Accounting for Compensation) Rules 2013 rr 3.1, 3.4, 3.5, 3.10

Cases

DYLS and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] 2965

Kennedy v Comcare [2014] FCA 82

Miller v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 13

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj [2002] HCA 11

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28

Semunigus and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 422


REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr S. Webb, Member

3 September 2024

  1. Sharon Hempel (Applicant) has life-long disability and is a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). She was injured in a motor vehicle accident and claimed compensation. The claim was resolved by consent and an amount of compensation was fixed. The National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) recovered an amount from the compensation. On review, the recovery was reversed, and the compensation amount was taken not to have been fixed in the special circumstances of the case. Subsequently, the NDIA issued a letter setting out an estimate of a ‘compensation reduction amount’ which may be applied to the Applicant’s next plan. The Applicant raised an issue of special circumstances. The NDIA issued a letter purporting to be a decision refusing to reduce the compensation reduction amount on grounds of special circumstances. It was in respect of this purported decision the Applicant lodged an application for review by the Tribunal and an application for grant of an extension of time in which to do so.

  2. The NDIA asserts the Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to review the purported decision.

  3. It is these issues, alone, which now rise for determination.

    Relevant facts

  4. The Applicant has life-long disability attributable to functional impairments resulting from Down Syndrome, Autism, and other medical conditions since birth.

  5. On 15 October 2014, the Applicant was injured in a motor vehicle accident.

  6. In 2017, the Applicant was approved entry to the NDIS as a participant.

  7. On 14 September 2017, a Statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hempel and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3278
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the matter of Hempel and the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The applicant, who has lifelong disabilities, received a $1.5 million compensation payout following a motor vehicle accident in 2014. The NDIA had previously issued a recovery notice under section 111(2) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (NDIS Act) in 2018, which was later set aside by an internal review decision under section 116 of the NDIS Act, treating the compensation as not being fixed by judgment or settlement due to special circumstances. More recently, the NDIA indicated it would be undertaking a review of the applicant's NDIS plan and that a Compensation Reduction Amount (CRA) might be applied in relation to the compensation received. The applicant sought review of what she considered to be an unjust decision by the NDIA's compensation team, arguing that the entirety of her compensation payout was being sought to cover pre-existing disabilities as well as injuries from the accident.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it had jurisdiction to review the NDIA's actions. The applicant contended that the NDIA had made, or was taken to have made, reviewable decisions relating to the calculation and application of a CRA to her NDIS plan. Specifically, the applicant argued that a decision made on 4 December 2023 was a reviewable decision under section 99(1) of the NDIS Act, and that the NDIA's subsequent refusal to review this decision constituted an implied reviewable decision under section 103. Alternatively, the applicant argued that the NDIA's failure to vary or reassess her plan, as potentially required by the Compensation Rules, constituted a reviewable decision under section 99(1), and the NDIA's refusal to undertake a review of this failure was also reviewable under section 103.

The Tribunal found that it lacked jurisdiction to proceed with the review. It determined that no actual decision had been made by the NDIA to apply a CRA to the applicant's plan. The correspondence from the NDIA indicated an intention to investigate further and prepare an estimate of a potential CRA, but this did not constitute a final decision. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the applicant's request for review on 4 January 2024 was directed at an "unjust decision" by a compensation specialist, but the NDIA responded that no reduction amount had been approved or applied, meaning there was no decision to review or appeal. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that there was no actual or deemed reviewable decision that would enliven its jurisdiction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

It is these issues, alone, which now rise for determination.Relevant facts The Applicant has life-long disability attributable to functional impairments resulting from Down Syndrome, Autism, and other medical conditions since birth. On 15 October 2014, the Applicant was injured in a motor vehicle accident. In 2017, the Applicant was approved entry to the NDIS as a participant. On 14 September 2017, a Statement of Participant Supports (SOPS) was approved for the Applicant and her first participant’s plan commenced. On 6 April 2018, the District Court of NSW issued a consent judgment awarding compensation fixed in the amount of $1.5 million to the Applicant. On 12 April 2018, the NDIA issued a recovery notice under s 111(2) Of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (NDIS Act) in respect of an amount to be recovered under s 107 of that Act. The Applicant requested review of the notice decision. On 30 November 2018, a delegate of the NDIA Chief Executive Officer (CEO) issued an internal review decision to set aside the notice decision and stated:I am satisfied it is appropriate, in the special circumstances of the case, to treat the whole of the compensation payment Sharon Hempel received as not having been fixed by a judgement (including a consent judgement) or settlement.This decision is made under section 116 of the [NDIS Act]. On 21 March 2023, a delegate of the CEO approved a SOPS for the Applicant and a new participant’s plan came into effect under s 37 of the NDIS Act. On 22 March 2023, a delegate of the CEO wrote to the Applicant, seeking additional information by 12 April 2023 and stated:… [the NDIA] will be undertaking a review of Sharon’s [NDIS] plan. At this time, a Compensation Reduction Amount (CRA) may be applied to Sharon’s plan in relation to the compensation received on or around 6 April 2018.What is a Compensation Reduction Amount?Compensation payments are often made to cover, amongst other things, a person’s past and future care needs. The National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants – Accounting for Compensation) Rules 2013 (Compensation Rules) are about ensuring that where individuals receive compensation payments, the NDIS does not duplicate the funding for supports already provided for by these payments.When compensation is received by an individual who is or who becomes a participant, the NDIS may reduce the funding for supports that may otherwise be approved in a participant’s plan. This is called a Compensation Reduction Amount… On 27 March 2023, the Applicant’s mother and nominee, Valda Hempel (Ms Hempel), provided information to the NDIA. Further information was provided on 21 June 2023. Correspondence between the NDIA and Ms Hempel ensued. On 31 August 2023, a compensation specialist officer of the NDIA (Sarah F), wrote to Ms Hempel and stated:… Sharon’s case was heard today [by the Complex Case Committee], the outcome is we still need to investigate the compensation further.In order to do this, I will need to prepare an Estimate of Compensation Reduction Amount that could be applied to Sharon’s next and future plans.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 4 January 2024, Ms Hempel wrote to the CEO and requested “a review of the unjust decision made by the NDIS compensation team’s [Sarah F] on 6/11/2023” and stated:Since birth Sharon has required high level 24/7 care. (Around the clock).On top of severe Down Syndrome, Sharon suffers Autism, significant skeletal and joint conditions of the cervical spine, bilateral hips (right hip dysplasia) and several joints. Early degenerative changes of osteoarthritis and scoliosis with global pain and spasticity causing mobility issues. All pre-accident, medically provable beyond doubt.…Yet your compensation team want the entirety of Sharon’s compensation payout to pay for all the disabilities Sharon has always had (pre accident) as well as for injuries from the car crash. On 21 March 2024,, a Senior Resolutions Specialist of the NDIA (Lauren S), informed Ms Hempel “no reduction amount has been approved or applied to [the Applicant’s] NDIS plan so there is no decision that can be reviewed or appealed”. On 24 April 2024, the Applicant’s legal representative lodged an application for review of the 4 December 2023 ‘decision’ with an application for grant of an extension of time in which to do so.Issues There are two issues for determination:(a)the Tribunal’s jurisdiction; and if necessary(b)grant of an extension of time for the Applicant to lodge an application for review.Jurisdiction The Applicant accepts she received compensation and damages in respect of personal injuries sustained in the motor vehicle accident. She argues the compensation payment is not within the meaning of ‘compensation’ as defined in s 11 of the NDIS Act and the Compensation Rules are not applicable as the compensation payment was not wholly or partly in respect of the cost of supports that may be provided to a participant in the NDIS. The Applicant asserts the NDIA has made, or is taken to have made, decisions applying or relating to the calculation and application of a ‘compensation reduction amount’ (CRA) to her participant plan. In seeking review, the Applicant draws several threads which, she argues, enliven the Tribunal’s jurisdiction. Firstly, the Applicant contends the NDIA made a decision on 4 December 2023 under s 116 of the NDIS Act, which is a reviewable decision under s 99(1) of the NDIS Act. On 6 December 2023 and 4 January 2024, a request was made for review of this decision under s 100 but, so this argument goes, the NDIA refused to undertake the review. Relying on Semunigus and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs[1] (Semunigus) and Kennedy v Comcare[2] (Kennedy), the Applicant asserts the NDIA impliedly affirmed the 4 December 2023 decision and the application for review by the Tribunal is in respect of this implied decision.[1] [1999] FCA 422.[2] [2014] FCA 82. Secondly, the Applicant contends the decision on 4 December 2023 required the NDIA to undertake a review pursuant to Division 4, Part 2, Chapter 3 of the NDIS Act. She asserts the NDIA failed to vary her plan under s 47A(2) or to revise her plan under s 48(4) of the NDIS Act as required by rule 3.4 of the Compensation Rules. In her submission, a decision not to vary or not to reassess a participant’s plan is a reviewable decision under s 99(1). In this argument, the requests for review made on 6 December 2023 and 4 January 2024 should be construed as requests for review of the implied decision not to vary or not to reassess her plan, and the NDIA’s express or implied decision not to undertake a review, as requested, under s 100 is a decision capable of review by the Tribunal under s 103 of the NDIS Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established