Hemjum Pty Ltd v Osachy

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Hemjum Pty Ltd v Osachy [2019] QSC 262

PARTIES:

HEMJUM PTY LTD as trustee for THE PARK RIDGE NO 1 UNIT TRUST
ACN 606 975 740

(plaintiff)

v
WALLY OSACHY

(defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 11498 of 2016

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

29 October 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4 – 6 June 2019

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

I will hear the parties on the form of judgment or final order, including as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

ESTOPPEL – ESTOPPEL BY CONDUCT – CAUSATION ­– DETRIMENT ­– EQUITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – UNCONSCIONABILITY, UNCONSCIONABLE DEALINGS AND OTHER FORMS OF EQUITABLE FRAUD – CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – IMPLIED TERMS – where the plaintiff and the defendant entered into a contract for the sale of a parcel of land owned by the defendant – where the contract of sale failed to settle and was terminated by the defendant because the plaintiff failed to pay the balance of the purchase price – where the plaintiff seeks specific performance of the contract and contends that the failure to complete was caused by its reliance on representations made by the defendant that he would provide vendor finance and agree to extend the completion date ­– whether the defendant represented to the plaintiff that he would provide vendor finance to complete the contract ­– whether the plaintiff did not obtain alternative finance in reliance on the defendant’s alleged representations ­– whether the defendant was estopped from asserting his right to terminate the contract because of the alleged representations ­– whether the defendant breached an implied contractual obligation to cooperate with the plaintiff – whether the termination of the contract was unconscientious or unlawful – whether the defendant agreed to extend the completion date and thereby waived his right to insist on the contractual completion date

Foran v Wight (1989) 168 CLR 385, cited
Tanwar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi (2013) 217 CLR 315, followed

COUNSEL:

H Blattman for the plaintiff

N Ferrett QC, with P Travers, for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Enyo Lawyers for the plaintiff

Gopal Lawyers for the defendant

  1. In this proceeding, the plaintiff, Hemjum Pty Ltd, sought specific performance of a contract (Contract) with the defendant, Wally Osachy, for the sale and purchase of a parcel of land at 193-205 Green Road, Park Ridge (the Land).[1]  The defendant opposed that relief on the basis he lawfully terminated the Contract on 18 August 2016, after the plaintiff failed to tender payment of the balance of the purchase price. 

    [1]Lot 5 on Registered Plan 80184, County of Stanley, Parish of Mitchell, title reference 13393081.

    Matters in issue and legal contentions

  2. There were three principal factual matters in dispute:

    (a)whether, by conduct between 2 and 6 August 2016, the defendant represented to the plaintiff that he would provide vendor finance to complete the Contract; 

    (b)whether the plaintiff put itself in the position…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hemjum Pty Ltd v Osachy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 262
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hemjum Pty Ltd sued Osachy over a failed land sale. The dispute centred on whether Osachy represented that he would provide vendor finance and extend the completion date, causing Hemjum to not secure alternative finance. Hemjum sought specific performance of the contract, arguing that Osachy was estopped from terminating due to these representations. The court had to decide if Osachy represented he would provide vendor finance and if Hemjum relied on this to not seek alternative finance. The court also had to determine if Osachy breached an implied obligation to cooperate and if terminating the contract was unconscionable.

The court held that there was no evidence Hemjum sought finance from any lender until June 2016, despite the contract requiring completion by 18 August 2016. There was also no evidence Hemjum would have obtained finance by the completion date even if it had sought it earlier. The court found that Hemjum did not rely on any representation about vendor finance to not seek finance and that Osachy did not represent he would provide vendor finance. The court also found that terminating the contract was not unconscionable.

The court dismissed Hemjum's claims. The parties will now discuss the form of judgment or final order, including costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

I will hear the parties on the form of judgment or final order, including as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The plaintiff pleaded that it “commenced seeking finance from a number of financiers to complete the Contract” in or around “June 2016”.[8] It also pleaded that, but for the alleged representation about vendor finance, the plaintiff “would have secured finance and attended to settlement of the Contract on 18 August 2016.” It was for the plaintiff to prove these allegations on the balance of probabilities.[9] [8]Until an amendment made by leave on the first day of the trial, the plaintiff’s case had been that it commenced seeking finance “in or around late July” 2016. [9]At the conclusion of the trial, it was submitted for the plaintiff that there was “no evidence that the Plaintiff could not or would not have obtained finance”. If, by this submission, the plaintiff contended there was a presumption the plaintiff could and would have obtained finance or that the defendant bore an onus to disprove the plaintiff’s ability to secure finance, it was in error.Evidence of the plaintiff seeking finance to complete At the trial, it was common ground that between 15 May 2015, when the Option was executed, and about 23 June 2016, nothing was done by HDK or the plaintiff to arrange finance for settlement of the transaction contemplated by the Option. There was no evidence that, at any time, the plaintiff sought finance from any financier to complete the Contract. The evidence of what occurred may be briefly summarised. On or about 23 June 2016, Mr Kashkari spoke with Paul Maraia, a RAMS Home Loans franchisee. Mr Maraia organised for Mr Kashkari to meet with Daniel Dumble of Arete Finance at a café on 27 June 2016. Neither Mr Maraia nor Mr Dumble nor either of their companies was a financier. Each was an authorised credit representative of a finance broker with an Australian credit licence. On 28 June 2016, Mr Dumble sent a lengthy, and appropriate, request to Mr Kashkari, seeking information “to assist with an application for subdivision finance.” Mr Dumble said shortly after that date, he “established that there was no way we could get development finance approved with such a short time frame.” He said the focus changed from a development finance application to finance for funds “to secure the site.” On 5 July 2016, the plaintiff’s accountant sent Mr Dumble a diagram of the companies in the group that included the plaintiff.[10] [10]The diagram was not tendered. On 11 July 2016, Mr Dumble warned Mr Kashkari and his accountant by email, “We’re fast running out of time to arrange the finance for the purchase”. Nothing appears to have been done about progressing a finance application over the following two weeks.[11] [11]In the interim, on 19 July 2016, the plaintiff exercised the Option, triggering a Contract with a date for completion of 18 August 2016. On Wednesday 27 July 2016, Mr Dumble met with the plaintiff’s accountant and Mr Kashkari, presumably in an attempt to obtain information required to prepare a finance application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established