Helimount Pty Limited (in Liquidation) v Web Wealth Proprietary Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Helimount Pty Limited (in Liquidation) v Web Wealth Proprietary Limited
[2007] FCA 1936

MORTGAGES – whether equitable mortgage granted over land – where certificates of title deposited with lender – where mortgage not registered – whether lender acted in a way that surrendered its security

Held – equitable mortgage granted

Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth)
Real Property Act 1886 (SA)

Theodore v Mistford Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 612 considered
Bank of New South Wales v O’Connor (1889) 14 App Cas 273 cited
In re Wallis & Simmonds (Builders) Ltd [1974] 1 WLR 391 cited
Arnick Holdings Limited and Ankar Pty Ltd v Australian Bank Ltd (unreported, Supreme Court of New South Wales (Equity Division), Bryson J, 4 December 1987) distinguished

HELIMOUNT PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) v WEB WEALTH PROPRIETARY LIMITED

SAD 19 OF 2006

MANSFIELD J
7 DECEMBER 2007
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 19 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

HELIMOUNT PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Applicant

AND:

WEB WEALTH PROPRIETARY LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 DECEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.Web Wealth Pty Ltd has an interest in the fund held by Hugh Martin in his capacity as the liquidator of Helimount Pty Ltd (In liq) comprising the proceeds of sale of the land described in Certificates of Title Register Book Volume 9983 Folio 505 and Volume 9593 Folio 463 (“the properties”) corresponding to the equitable mortgage in its favour created by the deposit of duplicate certificates of title held by Helimount Pty Ltd in January 2005. 

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

2.Hugh Martin in his capacity as the Liquidator of Helimount Pty Ltd (In liq) pay to Web Wealth Pty Ltd such sum as represents the proceeds of sale of the properties less the costs and disbursements of the liquidator in realising the properties.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 19 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

HELIMOUNT PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
Applicant

AND:

WEB WEALTH PROPRIETARY LIMITED
Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD  J

DATE:

7 DECEMBER 2007

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The issue on this application is a short one.

  2. Helimount Pty Limited (in Liquidation) (Helimount) was wound up in insolvency by order of the Court made on 26 July 2006.  As that order was made by the Registrar, it was reviewable.  The Registrar’s decision was affirmed upon review by Besanko J:  Web Wealth Pty Ltd v Helimount Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1376. Hugh Martin (the liquidator) is the liquidator of Helimount. The winding up order was made on the application of Web Wealth Proprietary Limited (Web Wealth), based on the failure of Helimount to pay a debt which was the subject of a statutory demand dated 28 November 2005. At that time, the sole director and sole shareholder of Helimount was Domenico Callipari. It is not necessary to refer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Helimount Pty Limited (in Liquidation) v Web Wealth Propriet... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 1936
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Helimount Pty Limited, in liquidation, was the plaintiff and Web Wealth Proprietary Limited was the defendant in a case heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central issue was whether Web Wealth held an equitable mortgage over two properties belonging to Helimount, which was secured by the certificates of title to those properties. This dispute arose from a loan transaction where Helimount borrowed $630,000 from Web Wealth, which was to be repaid on a short-term basis. The evidence in question was the intention of Helimount's representative, Mr Callipari, when he handed over the certificates of title to Web Wealth's representative, Mr Stirn, and whether this constituted a security deposit for the loan.

The court needed to determine whether the certificates of title were handed over as security for the loan or if they were merely held by Mr Stirn as a form of goodwill. The court also had to decide if Mr Stirn acted as Web Wealth's agent in obtaining the certificates of title and if the deposit of these titles constituted an equitable mortgage. The primary legal question was whether the transfer of title deeds, not deposited with Web Wealth but with Mr Stirn, constituted an equitable mortgage under Section 149 of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA), given that the titles were handed over with the intent to secure the debt.

The court found that the certificates of title were indeed handed over as security for the loan, and Mr Stirn acted as Web Wealth's agent in obtaining these titles. The court concluded that an intention to create the security existed, and the deposit of the title deeds constituted an equitable mortgage. This conclusion was based on the coherence and credibility of the evidence presented by Mr Stirn and Mr Pappas, who were found to be more reliable witnesses than Mr Callipari. The court referenced the High Court decision in Theodore v Mistford Pty Ltd to reinforce that an equitable mortgage can be created by the deposit of title deeds if done with the intent to secure a debt.

The court's final order was that the liquidator of Helimount Pty Limited pay to Web Wealth Proprietary Limited the proceeds from the sale of the properties, less the costs and disbursements incurred by the liquidator in realising the properties. This outcome ensures that Web Wealth is compensated for the loan it provided to Helimount, secured by the equitable mortgage over the properties in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. Hugh Martin in his capacity as the Liquidator of Helimount Pty Ltd (In liq) pay to Web Wealth Pty Ltd such sum as represents the proceeds of sale of the properties less the costs and disbursements of the liquidator in realising the properties.

Background

Background to the litigation

On about 24 January 2005, funds amounting to $630,000 were made available to Mr Callipari. These funds, a combination of cheques payable to Helimount and some cash, were handed over to Mr Stern at Mr Stern’s office. The funds had been advanced by a number of sources to Web Wealth, who then on-lent them to Helimount. The cheques were made payable to Helimount to facilitate the prompt provision of funds. The key issue in the case was the intention of Mr Callipari when he handed over the two certificates of title to Mr Stirn on 14 January 2005 when he signed the Deed. This intention was in question because of a conversation between Mr Callipari and Mr Stirn earlier on the same day. Mr Stirn testified that Mr Callipari had sought a short-term loan because the process of securing a loan from an existing financial institution was taking too long. The court found the evidence of Mr Stirn and Mr Pappas to be more reliable than that of Mr Callipari.

The case came before the court following a dispute over the evidence presented regarding the intention behind the handing over of the two certificates of title and the nature of the security provided for the loan. The court heard the testimonies of Mr Stirn, Mr Pappas, and Mr Callipari, and had to determine which testimonies were more reliable. The matter involved an interpretation of Section 149 of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) and a consideration of the case of Theodore v Mistford Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 612. The court did not consider the procedural steps beyond these testimonies and the legal interpretations involved.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On about 24 January 2005, the funds became available. Mr Callipari again attended Mr Stern’s office and was handed a combination of cheques payable to Helimount and some cash totalling $630,000. It appears that Mr Pappas had arranged for the advance of those funds from a number of sources. It was accepted during the course of the proceedings that the debt was owed by Helimount to Web Wealth, and that those sources had provided the funds to Web Wealth and that Web Wealth had on-lent them to Helimount. The fact that the payments were made payable to Helimount was simply to facilitate the prompt provision of the funds to Helimount.THE DISPUTED EVIDENCE The critical question was said to be the intention of Mr Callipari when he handed over the two certificates of title to Mr Stirn when he signed the Deed on 14 January 2005. That in turn depends upon the effect of a conversation between him and Mr Stirn earlier on that day. I have heard the evidence of Mr Stirn and Mr Pappas as to their communications on that day by telephone, and in the presence of Mr Callipari. I have also heard the evidence of Mr Stirn and Mr Callipari as to their respective communications on that day. There is much in common on the whole of the evidence of those communications. Mr Stirn was extensively cross-examined. He did not diverge in any significant way from his evidence in chief. He explained that Mr Callipari, when he first contacted Mr Stirn, indicated that he had approved borrowing from an existing significant financial institution (and he produced an approval letter for that borrowing), but that the process of settling that finance had been taking too long and he did not have the time to wait for it to be completed. That was the context in which he sought a short-term loan. In my view, the evidence of Mr Stirn and Mr Pappas, to the limited extent that it disagrees with the evidence of Mr Callipari, should be preferred to that of Mr Callipari. There are several reasons for that. The first is that I found Mr Stirn and Mr Pappas to be impressive witnesses, whose evidence was given in a straightforward way and without any attempt to gloss over matters or, alternatively, to emphasise matters which they might have been expected to have glossed over or alternatively highlighted were they trying to present a version of events favourable to their case. Secondly, their evidence is inherently both consistent and coherent. Thirdly, their evidence is inherently likely. That is, it is likely that a short term advance of substantial funds by a finance broker would have been the subject of security. Even at the apparently usurious interest rates which were agreed (I use that description even though the liquidator said he had seen short term loans at considerably higher interest rates than those expressed), it is unlikely that such a large amount of funds would have been advanced where the money was required urgently without an inquiry about the availability of security and the taking of it if available. I am fortified in that conclusion by Mr Pappas’ evidence as to what he conveyed to those who provided the funds to Web Wealth, which were then advanced to Helimount, and by the fact that Mr Stirn was himself one of the providers of funds to Web Wealth for that purpose, as I regarded Mr Stirn as a straightforward witness whose business did not involve dealing in such short term commercial loans and who would have proceeded only if his contribution to the loan funds was secured.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MANSFIELD J
Issues
1. Did Helimount give the two certificates of title to Mr Stirn on about 14 January 2005 to be held only as a form of goodwill and to be available as security for the long term loan which was planned to replace and repay the Web Wealth loan to Helimount?
2. Did Mr Callipari, on behalf of Helimount, deposit the two titles with Mr Stirn to be held as security for repayment of the Web Wealth loan of $630,000 to Helimount?
3. When Mr Stirn was handed the two titles by Mr Callipari, did he receive them as the agent of Web Wealth?

Held
1. The court rejected Helimount's claim that the two certificates of title were given to Mr Stirn on about 14 January 2005 to be held only as a form of goodwill and to be available as security for the long term loan which was planned to replace and repay the Web Wealth loan to Helimount. Instead, it found that Mr Callipari on behalf of Helimount deposited the two titles with Mr Stirn to be held as security for repayment of the Web Wealth loan of $630,000 to Helimount.
2. The court found that Mr Callipari, on behalf of Helimount, deposited the two titles with Mr Stirn to be held as security for repayment of the Web Wealth loan of $630,000 to Helimount.
3. The court concluded that when Mr Stirn was handed the two titles by Mr Callipari, he received them as the agent of Web Wealth.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MANSFIELD J

In the course of that conversation, I find that Mr Callipari acknowledged that Mr Stirn held the two Certificates of Title so that, if Helimount did not repay the loan, the properties could be sold out. Mr Pappas said he was not sure that in that conversation Mr Stirn used the word “security”, or whether Mr Callipari used that word, but he did say that Mr Callipari acknowledged that Web Wealth or “you” hold the titles. In that context, Mr Callipari made the comment that the debt plus accumulated interest now exceeded the value of the land covered in the titles which were held. He would not have said that unless he appreciated that the titles were held as security for the advance by Web Wealth. Mr Pappas in response made the point that the two titles could be sold and any extra funds outstanding could be pursued by the winding up of Helimount.CONSIDERATION OF CONTENTIONS Mr Callipari contended that Web Wealth did not hold an equitable mortgage over the land in the two certificates of title securing its debt because(1)the titles were not deposited with Web Wealth at all, but with Mr Stirn, and that Mr Stirn did not receive them as the agent of Web Wealth; and(2)Helimount, through Mr Callipari, did not intend to create security for repayment of the Web Wealth loan by way of an equitable mortgage over the land. Section 149 of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) provides:An equitable mortgage of land may be created by deposit of the certificate or other instrument of title, and such deposit shall have the same effect as a deposit by way of equitable mortgage of the title deeds of land not under the provisions of this Act. I have rejected Mr Callipari’s claim that Helimount gave the two certificates of title to Mr Stirn on about 14 January 2005 to be held only as a form of goodwill and to be available as security for the long term loan which was planned to replace and repay the Web Wealth loan to Helimount. Rather, I have found, Mr Callipari on behalf of Helimount deposited the two titles with Mr Stirn to be held as security for repayment of the Web Wealth loan of $630,000 to Helimount. In Theodore v Mistford Pty Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 612, the High Court (Gleeson CJ, McHugh, Gummow, Callinan and Heydon JJ) recognised and reinforced that an equitable mortgage can be effected by the deposit of title deeds if they were deposited with intent that the land to which they relate be security for payment of a debt. As in that case (discussed at 621, [24]), this is not a case where I need to consider whether to presume an intention to create a security from the relationship of debtor and creditor and the delivery of title deeds: see Bank of New South Wales v O’Connor (1889) 14 App Cas 273 at 282 – 283; In re Wallis & Simmonds (Builders) Ltd [1974] 1 WLR 391 at 395. I have found that an intention to create the security existed. I also conclude that, when Mr Stirn was handed the two titles by Mr Callipari, he received them as the agent of Web Wealth. He was given the title deeds precisely because Mr Stirn, on behalf of Web Wealth, and after the issue was raised by Mr Pappas in his discussion with Mr Stirn, asked what security would be available to support the proposed advance by Web Wealth. In part, because that security was proffered, Mr Stirn on behalf of Web Wealth indicated the short term finance acquired would be available. Mr Pappas did not speak to Mr Callipari at all on the day the agreement to make the loan was reached; Mr Stirn was the agent of Web Wealth in all those dealings. He was its agent in the discussions once he had been informed by Web Wealth through Mr Pappas that the requested funds may be available, including agreeing orally to advance the funds and the terms upon which they would be advanced and in obtaining the titles and in arranging for the Deed of Arrangement to be drawn up and signed.