Helen Seldenv.Sydney Water Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

[2011] FWA 3330


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.394 — Application for a remedy for alleged unfair dismissal

Helen Selden
v.
Sydney Water Corporation
(U2010/14373)

COMMISSIONER CONNOR

WOLLONGONG, 27 MAY, 2011

Applications for alleged unfair dismissal - out-of-time application - representational error as a cause of the delay

Preliminary

[1] Mrs Helen Selden was from the middle of 1976 employed by the Sydney Water Corporation. She was located in the Wollongong region but the position she occupied (an accounts payable officer) was subsequently relocated to Sydney (Parramatta). There are certain medical restrictions on Mrs Selden's travel from her residence in the Illawarra region to the Parramatta office and as a consequence she was medically retired on Tuesday, 2 November, 2010. Mrs Selden is a member of the Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union [the ASU] which on Wednesday, 24 November, 2010 lodged an application on her behalf under s.394 of the federal Fair Work Act, 2009 (the FW Act) to Fair Work Australia (FWA).

[2] Conciliation had been arranged by teleconference on Monday, 13 December, 2010. That attempt at conciliation was unsuccessful, however, and the matter was allocated to me for arbitration. All proceedings before me were conducted in the premises at 90 Crown Street, Wollongong which Fair Work Australia now shares with the Industrial Commission of New South Wales.

[3] I set the matter down for mention and programming on Thursday, 27 January, 2010. However, at the request of Mrs Selden's representative, I adjourned those proceedings for mention and programming on Tuesday, 15 February, 2011 and ultimately for arbitration in a hearing on Wednesday, 20 April, 2011. Mr Fry represented Mrs Selden and the ASU in the hearing. He called Mrs Selden to give evidence in the hearing. He also called Mr Benjamin Chapman, who had up to Wednesday, 20 April, 2011 been an organiser of the ASU, as a witness in the hearing. Mr Mattson represented Sydney Water in the hearing. He called Mr Nicholas Saunders, the human resources manager of Sydney Water, as a witness in the proceedings.

[4] Mrs Selden has permanent medical restrictions and Sydney Water has received advice to that effect from her treating vascular surgeon [Dr Laurencia Villalba]. Those restrictions do not arise from her work for Sydney Water, however. Nevertheless, I believe that the medical retirement of an employee, against her wishes, would be still properly categorised as a dismissal for the purposes of the unfair dismissal jurisdiction flowing from s.394. It is Mrs Selden's assertion, and the assertion of Mr Fry on her behalf, that there would be comparable clerical work available to her in Sydney Water in the Illawarra region.

[5] However, there are jurisdictional objections to the ASU application. Firstly, Sydney Water argued that the application should be dismissed because it was lodged outside the 14 day period prescribed in s.394(2). Her services were terminated on Tuesday, 2 November, 2010 and the ASU lodged her s.394 application 22 days later, on Wednesday, 24 November, 2011.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Helen Seldenv.Sydney Water Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FWA 3330
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Helen Selden versus Sydney Water Corporation, the Fair Work Commission was tasked with assessing the merits of an out-of-time application for unfair dismissal brought by Ms Selden against her former employer, Sydney Water. The primary dispute arose from Ms Selden's assertion that she had been unfairly dismissed from her position as a senior planner. Sydney Water contested the claim, arguing that the application was lodged beyond the statutory time limit and, therefore, should be dismissed.

The legal issues before the Commission involved the interpretation of the statutory time limits for filing an unfair dismissal claim and whether an alleged representational error by the Commission's staff could be considered as a sufficient ground for excusing the delay in filing the application. Ms Selden argued that an error in the advice provided by the Commission's staff regarding the availability of an extension constituted a representational error, which should warrant an exception to the strict time requirements. Conversely, Sydney Water maintained that the statutory time limits were mandatory and that any error on the part of the Commission did not absolve Ms Selden of her obligation to comply with these deadlines.

The Fair Work Commission, in its decision, recognised that the statutory time limits for unfair dismissal applications were indeed strict and mandatory. However, the Commission also acknowledged the possibility of extending these time limits in cases of exceptional circumstances. In this instance, the Commission found that the error in advice provided by its own staff constituted a significant factor that contributed to the delay. Consequently, the Commission exercised its discretion to accept the out-of-time application, finding that the representational error was a compelling reason to excuse the delay. As a result, the application was deemed admissible, and the substantive claim of unfair dismissal proceeded to be heard on its merits.