Helbig v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

[2008] TASSC 28

CITATION:Helbig v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal [2008] TASSC 28

PARTIES:  HELBIG, Fritz Paul Dieter
  v
  RESOURCE MANAGEMENT AND PLANNING
  APPEAL TRIBUNAL
  KING ISLAND COUNCIL

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  APPELLATE
FILE NO/S:  907/2007 and 259/2008
DELIVERED ON:  11 June 2008
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  13, 22, 28 February, 19 March, 6 May 2008
JUDGMENT OF:  Evans J

CATCHWORDS:

Administrative Law – Judicial review – Grounds of review – Error relating to facts – Misrepresentation of facts to tribunal – Relief if misrepresentation is of no consequence.

Judicial Review Act2000 (Tas), s27.
Von Stalheim v Anti-Discrimination Tribunal and Attorney-General for the State of Tasmania [2007] TASSC 9, referred to.
Aust Dig Administrative Law [1031]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Applicant:  K J Stanton
             Respondent (RMPAT):  No appearance
             Respondent (Council):  G W Tremayne
Solicitors:
             Applicant:  Walsh Day
             Respondent (RMPAT):  No appearance
             Respondent (Council):  Jackson Tremayne & Fay

Judgment Number:  [2008] TASSC 28
Number of paragraphs:  32

Serial No 28/2008
File Nos 907/2007
             259/2008

FRITZ PAUL DIETER HELBIG v RESOURCE MANAGEMENT AND
PLANNING APPEAL TRIBUNAL and KING ISLAND COUNCIL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  EVANS J

11 June 2008

  1. I will not detail the tortuous path that these proceedings have taken before this Court, it does not bear repeating.  The proceedings challenge a decision of the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal ("the Tribunal") to the effect that Fritz Helbig, who I will refer to as "the applicant", had no standing to appeal to the Tribunal against a decision of the King Island Council ("the council").  In their final form, the proceedings involve:

·an originating application issued by the applicant seeking a review of the Tribunal's no standing decision pursuant to the Judicial Review Act 2000; and

·an appeal against that decision by the applicant pursuant to the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal Act 1993, s25(1).

  1. The decision of the council that was the subject of the appeal to the Tribunal was the council's approval of its own application for a permit to erect a public amenities building at Naracoopa.  The council gave notice of that application as required by the Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993 ("the Act"), s57(3). The Act, s57(5) provides:

"57 ¾  (5)      Any person may make representations relating to the application during the period of 14 days commencing on the date on which notice of the application is given under subsection (3) or such further period not exceeding 14 days as the planning authority may allow."

  1. The Act, s61(5), relevantly confines the entitlement to appeal to the Tribunal against the grant of a permit to "any person who … has made a representation under section 57(5)".

  1. The applicant did not make a representation to the council in relation to the application within the period of 14 days as prescribed by s57(5). However, by letter dated 29 August 2007, the applicant, by his solicitors, wrote to the council and for present purposes the relevant portion of that letter is as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Helbig v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] TASSC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Helbig v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal, the applicant, Mr Helbig, sought to appeal a decision made by the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal, which had dismissed his appeal on the grounds that he lacked standing to bring it. The central issue was whether Mr Helbig had made a representation under Section 57(5) of the Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993, thereby granting him the right to appeal. The Tribunal concluded that Mr Helbig had not made a representation within the prescribed time and therefore had no standing to appeal the council's decision.

The legal issues before the court were primarily centred around the interpretation of Section 57(5) of the Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993 and the subsequent acknowledgment by the Council of Mr Helbig's representation. The court had to determine whether the Council's conduct in acknowledging receipt of Mr Helbig's representation and considering it, despite it being submitted late, amounted to an extension of time for making representations. Additionally, the court examined whether the Council's actions constituted a formal acceptance of Mr Helbig's representation under the Act.

The court found that the Council had not acknowledged receipt of a representation within the legal meaning of Section 57(5) of the Act. It pointed out that the Council had expressly noted the lateness of the representation and had not addressed any request for an extension of time, as no such request had been made. The court further determined that the Council's presentation of the representation to itself for consideration was done 'as a matter of courtesy' and not as an acceptance of the representation under the Act. Consequently, the court held that no extension of time for making representations had been granted, and Mr Helbig lacked standing to appeal the council's decision.

As a result, the court dismissed Mr Helbig's appeal, affirming the Tribunal's decision that Mr Helbig had no standing to bring the appeal due to the late submission of his representation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In written reasons dated 30 November 2007, the Tribunal dismissed the applicant's appeal on the basis that he had no standing to bring it. The reasons are as follows:"REASONS FOR DECISION1Mr Helbig has purported to appeal to the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal (the 'Tribunal') in respect of a permit that the King Island Council (the 'Council') granted to permit the construction and use of a public amenities building at Naracoopa on King Island. Mr Helbig claims the right to appeal pursuant to Section 61(5) of the Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993 (the 'Land Use Act') being 'a person who has made a representation' under Section 57(5) of the same Act. The issue that arises is whether in fact Mr Helbig made a representation in terms of that provision. If he did then he has standing to bring the appeal. If he did not then he has no such standing and his appeal is incompetent.Facts2 The following were agreed facts:'IA development application for the erection of a public amenities building was received by King Island Council (the "Council") on 3 August 2007.2The Council gave notice; pursuant to section 57(3) of the Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993 (the "Act") and as prescribed in Regulation 8(1) of the Land Use Planning and Approvals Regulations 2004 (the "Regulations") as follows:(a)The application was advertised in daily newspapers circulating generally in the area relevant to the application, being The Advocate newspaper and the King Island Courier newspaper, on Wednesday, 8 August 2007; and(b)Displayed the application and documentation at Council Chambers in Meech Street, Currie, King Island, during office hours between 8.00 am and 5.00 pm Monday to Friday inclusive from 8 August 2007 until 22 August 2007; and(c)Gave notice in accordance with Regulation 8(1)(c) of the Regulations to the owners and occupiers of all properties adjoining the land, including Mr Helbig, by letter dated 6 August 2007; and(d)displayed notices on the land the subject of the application, from 6 August 2007.3A letter dated 29 August 2007 was received by the Council via facsimile on 29 August 2007 from Walsh Day Williams, acting on behalf of Mr Helbig, purporting to be a representation regarding the Development Application 0507/08.4The Council replied to Walsh Day Williams by letter dated 5 September 2007 in the following terms, formal and irrelevant parts omitted:'Your correspondence of the 29th instant, providing comment on the proposed development, has been received and noted. I wish to advise you that though the correspondence cannot be deemed a representation for the purposes of Section 57(5) of the Land Use Planning & Approvals Act 1993, it shall be presented to Council for consideration as a matter of curtesy [sic].'3 Mr Helbig's argument is as follows:·A council has power to extend the time limit by Section 57(5) of the Land Use Act for representations.·There is no need to receive a specific request so to do; by its conduct a council may in fact extend time for the making of a representation;·That in fact occurred in this case because:oThe Council acknowledged the receipt of the 'representation' made by Mr Helbig;oBy so acknowledging the receipt of that 'representation' without averting to the fact that the representation had been received out of time or rejecting the request in the representation for an extension of time for it to be considered;oBy presenting the representation 'to [the] Council for consideration before the Council made its decision as to the application for a permit';oBy considering the 'representation' before making its decision as to the application for a permit;oThe Council granting the application that was the subject of the representation:oGiving the Applicant notices of its decision pursuant to Section 57(7) of the Land Use Act.4This argument may be shortly disposed of. The Council simply did not acknowledge receipt of a representation. Nor did it acknowledge receipt of that 'representation' without averting to the fact that the representation had been received out of time. It expressly pointed out that time had expired. Equally it did not address (or reject) any request in relation to an extension of time, for no request was made. Mr Helbig's solicitors wrote in the following terms:'I understand that this representation is made outside the advertised time and would ask that it be considered. The reason for the lateness is Mr Helbig did not receive the notice until after the closing date for representations.'5On the most favourable construction of this passage it is not and cannot be regarded as a request for an extension of time. All it does is acknowledge that the 'representation' is outside the time provided for in the Act, asks that it 'be considered' (whatever that might mean) and offers an explanation as to why it is late.6The 'representation' was not presented to the Council for consideration. It was presented 'as a matter of curtesy [sic]'.7That the Council granted the application notwithstanding the representation is simply not to the point. Neither is the giving of notice of its decision.8The Tribunal is affirmatively satisfied that on any view of it there has been no extension of time within which to make a representation, for the representation was made out of time and as such Mr Helbig has no standing to bring the appeal that he purports to bring. It follows that his appeal must be dismissed."

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.