Hegarty v Townsville City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:        

Hegarty v Townsville City Council [2015] QIRC 208

PARTIES:  

Hegarty, Daryl Thomas
(Applicant)

v

Townsville City Council
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

B/2015/29

PROCEEDING:

Action on industrial dispute

DELIVERED ON:

3 December 2015

HEARING DATES: 

29 and 30 October 2015

HEARD AT:

Townsville

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Neate

ORDER:

The application is dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW - ACTION ON INDUSTRIAL DISPUTE - Disciplinary action against Council employee - employer satisfied that allegations in relation to specified behaviour by employee substantiated - Step 3 warning issued under counselling and disciplinary procedure of the relevant certified agreement - whether evidence supported findings about allegations - whether Step 3 warning was appropriate in relation to specified behaviour

CASES:

Industrial Relations Act 1999 ss 229, 230, 274, 274A

Hallett Brick Industries Ltd v Kennewell (1976) 43 SAIR Pt 1 477
Bi-Lo Pty Ltd v Hooper AND Hooper v Bi-Lo Pty Ltd (1992) 59 SAIR 342; 53 IR 224
Hegarty v Townsville City Council [2015] QIRC 165
Raymond Harris AND Gold Coast City Council (D/2010/121) - Decision < v P & O Resorts (Heron Island) AND Simpson v P & O Resorts (Heron Island) (1993) 144 QGIG 914

APPEARANCES:

Mr J. O'Donnell, advocate, instructed by the Applicant
Mr J. Healy of the Respondent

Decision

  1. Daryl Thomas Hegarty has been employed by Townsville City Council ("the Council") since January 2002.  He is a Local Law officer.  Following a disciplinary process commenced in February 2014 in relation to certain alleged behaviour by him, Gavin Lyons, the Director of Community and Environment with the Council, decided that certain allegations against Mr Hegarty were substantiated.  As a consequence, Mr Lyons, issued a Step 3 warning to Mr Hegarty.  That warning was contained in a letter dated 21 August 2015 in which Mr Lyons advised Mr Hegarty that a copy of the warning would be placed on his personal file for 12 months and would be taken into account if any further reports of similar behaviour are received.

  2. On 24 August 2015, Mr Hegarty gave notice of an industrial dispute.  The notice was filed in the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission ("the Commission") in relation to the Step 3 warning.  These proceedings were preceded by other proceedings in the Commission in relation to aspects of the disciplinary process that led to the Step 3 warning.  It is not necessary to recount in detail those proceedings other than to note they have involved a separate conciliation conference before Deputy President Swan, and an application for an injunction which was heard and decided by Deputy President O'Connor.[1]

Orders sought and Commission's power to make those orders

  1. The Notice of Industrial Dispute under s 229 of the Industrial Relations Act 1999 ("the Act") identified the relief sought in the following terms:

    "The purpose of this section 229 - Dispute Notification is to seek the assistance of the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission in relation to the harsh disciplinary penalty which has been imposed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hegarty v Townsville City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QIRC 208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hegarty v Townsville City Council was heard by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission. The dispute involved disciplinary action taken by the Townsville City Council against an employee, Mr Hegarty, regarding specific allegations of inappropriate behaviour. The Council had issued a Step 3 warning under its counselling and disciplinary procedure, and Mr Hegarty contested the appropriateness of this action. The central legal issues for the court were whether the evidence supported the Council's findings about the allegations and whether the Step 3 warning was appropriate in relation to the behaviour in question.

The court found that there was sufficient evidence to support the Council's decision to initiate a formal disciplinary process. Ms de Lucey and Mr Lyons provided evidence that multiple attempts had been made to manage Mr Hegarty's conduct before disciplinary action was considered. However, the seriousness of the complaints warranted a formal investigation, and the complaints were reviewed in conjunction with other relevant matters related to Mr Hegarty's employment. The court noted that the Council had followed its disciplinary policy, including considering Mr Hegarty's employment history and ensuring that the disciplinary matter was not referenced beyond the permitted 12-month period. The court concluded that the evidence did support the Council's findings and that the Step 3 warning was appropriate.

The court dismissed Mr Hegarty's application, affirming the Council's decision to issue the Step 3 warning as justified based on the evidence presented. The court found no grounds to overturn the disciplinary action taken by the Council.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Decision-making process: There was evidence from Ms de Lucey and Mr Lyons that the formal disciplinary process was initiated (at least in part) because of Mr Hegarty's behaviour in the workplace. According to Ms de Lucey, Mr Hegarty's employment history was part of the consideration to move to a disciplinary action. If he had not received feedback or other attempts at managing his conduct before February 2014, then it was "unlikely" that they "would have moved straight to disciplinary action."[12] She described disciplinary investigations or actions as "a last resort." Ordinarily, in the absence of a serious event or matter, other means are explored first. In this case, she considered the number of attempts that Mr Hegarty's managers had made to address his inappropriate conduct over a period of time. Mr Lyons confirmed, in his affidavit and oral evidence, that a formal investigation was appropriate given the history of Mr Hegarty's behaviour and performance. (Exhibit 6, [27])[12] Transcript of Proceedings, Hegarty v Townsville City Council (Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, B/2015/29, Industrial Commissioner Neate, 30 October 2015) 6. However, Ms de Lucey also gave evidence that, irrespective of that background, the complaints were serious enough to move to disciplinary action. Although the purpose of the investigation was to conduct a thorough and objective review of the events that occurred on 5 and 18 February 2014, the Investigation Report states that these events "have been reviewed in conjunction with other relevant matters related to Mr Daryl Hegarty's employment." Some such matters in 2012 and 2013 were mentioned as Additional Background Information in the Report. Ms de Lucey gave evidence that the information from Mr Hegarty's personnel file which she considered in drafting the Investigation Report is included in the Report.[13] She distinguished between the relevance of Mr Hegarty's employment history to the commencement of a disciplinary investigation, and the level of the penalty imposed on him. She also stated that, in accordance with disciplinary policy,[14] she could not refer to a disciplinary matter that is more than 12 months old.[15][13] Transcript of Proceedings, Hegarty v Townsville City Council (Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, B/2015/29, Industrial Commissioner Neate, 30 October 2015) 5-6.[14] Transcript of Proceedings, Hegarty v Townsville City Council (Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, B/2015/29, Industrial Commissioner Neate, 30 October 2015) 7-8, 11.[15] The Townsville City Council (Queensland Local Government Officers) Certified Agreement 2012 provides at clause 22.5 Documentation: "All documentation associated with the outcome of a disciplinary action taken against an employee in accordance with this Disciplinary Procedure shall not be used or held on the employee's personnel file after a period of 12 months following the date of the last relevant nemo issued to the employee concerned over the particular incident which initiated the disciplinary action."

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.