Hegarty and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 421

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No Q00/956

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )       
           Re      CATHERINE HEGARTY  
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member      

Date18 May 2001  

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the respondent with the direction that the discretion under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 be exercised in favour of the visa applicant and that his visa application be reconsidered in an expedient manner.

(Sgd)          DP BREEN
  PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – visa refusal – whether applicant of good character – immigration fraud – whether discretion should be exercised in visa applicant's favour – consideration to be given to unborn child of applicant.

Migration Act 1958 ss 501
Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422
Ly v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 339

REASONS FOR DECISION

18 May 2001          Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member                  

  1. This was an appeal against a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs dated 24 August 2000 to refuse a Temporary Partner (Provisional) Class UF (Subclass 309 – Spouse) Visa to Mr Bautista Simon Barrientos Roca.  The applicant in these proceedings is Mr Barrientos' wife, Ms Catherine Hegarty.

  2. The matter was heard by me in Brisbane on 13 February 2001.  The applicant was represented by Ms A Kemenes, Migration Agent of Four Corners Migration Consultancy.  The respondent was represented by Mr H Copley, Solicitor of Messrs Blake Dawson Waldron.  Written submissions were received from the applicant on 2 March 2001 and from the respondent on 14 May 2001.

  3. Oral evidence was received from the visa applicant, the applicant and the applicant's mother Mrs Janette Mary Hegarty.  The following documents were also taken into evidence.

  • Exhibit 1            "T" Documents

  • Exhibit 2            Medical documents from Dr Choong and Dr Theodoros

  • Exhibit 3            Bundle of documents from the applicant

  1. Mr Barrientos, the visa applicant, is 31 years of age and a Peruvian citizen.  He has two children to a former partner who reside in Peru.  In 1993 Mr Barrientos paid $US50,000 to obtain a birth certificate in the name of Jose Luis Yonkura Salas.  At that time the Japanese Government had a policy that if a Peruvian had a grandparent or a great grandparent who was of Japanese birth, then the person would be able to obtain a long stay working permit.  Mr Barrientos wanted to go to Japan as there were better work opportunities there.  He would not have been able to obtain the work permit under his own name as non-Japanese people had to have a university degree in order to get a work permit.  In May 1993 Mr Barrientos obtained a passport under the alias and travelled to Japan in June of that year.  Mr Barrientos lived and worked in Japan under the alias until mid-2000.

  2. Ms Hegarty, the applicant,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hegarty and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affai... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 421
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr Barrientos, challenged the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs' refusal of his visa application under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958. The dispute centred on the question of whether Mr Barrientos was of good character. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining if the Minister's refusal to grant Mr Barrientos a visa was lawful and justified, particularly in light of the character test required by the Act.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether Mr Barrientos' use of a false identity to enter Japan constituted an act of immigration fraud that rendered him not of good character, and if so, whether the discretionary power under Section 501 should be exercised in his favour. The court needed to weigh the seriousness of Mr Barrientos' immigration fraud against his otherwise lawful conduct in Japan and his potential contribution to the Australian community, including the welfare of his unborn child.

The court found that Mr Barrientos' use of a false identity to gain employment in Japan constituted immigration fraud, which under the Direction was viewed as serious. However, the court also recognised that Mr Barrientos did not use the alias to hide past illegal activities or evade authorities. His conduct in Japan was otherwise lawful, and he contributed positively to the community. Given the minimal risk of recidivism and the potential benefits to his unborn child, the court concluded that the discretion should be exercised in Mr Barrientos' favour. The decision was influenced by the principle that while immigration fraud is serious, the context and motivations behind it could mitigate its impact on the character assessment.

The court ordered that Mr Barrientos' visa application should be approved, taking into account the best interests of his unborn child and his otherwise good conduct. The decision underscored the importance of considering the full context of an applicant's background and the potential for rehabilitation when applying the character test.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a visa applicant who has applied for a visa to enter Australia. The applicant had previously lived in Japan for several years under a false identity, using a false birth certificate to establish this new identity. This false identity was used solely to enable him to work in Japan, and there was no evidence of any other illegal activities or criminal conduct under this alias. The applicant's conduct in Japan was otherwise exemplary, as he paid taxes, maintained his children, and was a positive member of the community. Upon returning to his home country, the applicant applied for a visa to enter Australia but was refused due to concerns about his character. The primary issue was whether the applicant was of good character, particularly in light of his use of a false identity in the past. The case also considered the impact of the applicant's actions on his unborn child and whether the discretion should be exercised in his favour.

The matter came before the court as a visa refusal appeal, challenging the decision made by the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. The applicant had initially applied for a visa under the Migration Act 1958 and was refused on the grounds that he was not of good character, as per section 501. The applicant then appealed this decision, arguing that despite his use of a false identity, he had otherwise led a law-abiding life and had no criminal record. The case was heard by the court which reviewed the previous decisions and the relevant legal principles to determine whether the discretion should be exercised in the applicant's favour, considering the seriousness of his conduct, the risk of recidivism, and the best interests of his unborn child.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant is of good character under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958.
2. Whether the Tribunal should exercise its discretion in the visa applicant's favour despite his use of a false identity.
3. How the protection of the Australian community, the expectations of the Australian community, and the best interests of the applicant's unborn child should be balanced in exercising the discretion.

Held
1. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant is not of good character under Section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 due to the use of a false identity and immigration fraud.
2. The Tribunal decided not to exercise its discretion in the visa applicant's favour despite his use of a false identity, leading to the dismissal of his application.
3. The Tribunal found that while the protection of the Australian community and the expectations of the Australian community weighed against the applicant, the best interests of the applicant's unborn child did not override these considerations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The provision of false information on immigration forms, the use of false documents with respect to immigration and generally engaging in breaches of immigration law are all activities listed under the Direction which may lead to a finding that a person is not of good character. It is important that people provide correct details of their identity to immigration authorities so that the authorities are aware of exactly who it is that they are letting into the country. While the use of a different identity, which does not involve the covering up of previous illegal activity, is not indicative of character flaws as serious as those indicated by persons engaged in rape, murder, drug trafficking or terrorism, it is still of concern to authorities. The use of a false birth certificate to gain a new identity shows a level of dishonesty which creates a concern as to a person's enduring moral qualities (see Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 68 FCR 422). The fact that the visa applicant persisted with the false identity for so long compounds the matter. Therefore, it is this Tribunal's finding that as a result of the immigration fraud perpetrated by the visa applicant, under Section 501 he fails the character test. The Tribunal must then consider whether the discretion should be exercised in the visa applicant's favour. There are three primary considerations under the Direction – protection of the Australian community, expectations of the Australian community and, where the applicant is involved in a parental relationship with any children, the best interests of those children. Considering, firstly, the protection of the Australian community, the Tribunal must have regard to the nature of the seriousness of the crimes committed, the risk of recidivism and the general deterrence effect that the cancellation of the visa will have on other non-citizens. With respect to the seriousness and nature of the offences, the Direction provides that immigration fraud is to be viewed as serious and the Tribunal agrees with that view. However, in this case the applicant did not engage in this deception in order to obscure past illegal conduct or to evade creditors and the like. It was simply done to enable him to work in another country. The visa applicant did not chop and change identities. As such, any activities he engaged in during those seven years were directly referrable to him. Although he did travel to Australia under that alias, his explanation was that he only had travel documents in the alias so that he was unable at that time to travel in is own name. Finally, there is no evidence that the visa applicant committed any criminal activity under that alias. He in fact worked hard, paid maintenance for his children, paid taxes and was otherwise a positive member of the community in which he lived. All of these factors reduce the seriousness of the conduct engaged in, although only marginally. Considering then the risk of recidivism. The respondent has submitted that the past conduct of a visa applicant is the best indicator of their future conduct. This is a view with which the Tribunal agrees. While Mr Barrientos did use a false identity to gain entry into Japan, his conduct whilst there was extremely good. He did not breach other laws, he paid his taxes and even purchased his own health insurance rather than relying on State benefits. Whilst in Australia he did not engage in any criminal conduct or breach any other laws except, of course, in relation to the application for the visa. As such, the Tribunal is of the view that there is a very minimal risk that the visa applicant, if permitted to come to Australia, would disregard other Australian laws.