Hebberman v Police No. Scciv-02-178

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

HEBBERMAN v POLICE

[2002] SASC 267

Magistrates Appeal

  1. WICKS J               This is an appeal against sentence.

    Background

  2. On 18 December 2001, at Christies Beach Magistrates Court, the appellant pleaded guilty to a charge of larceny as a servant, contrary to s 176(1)(a) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935.

  3. The appellant admitted that on 1 July 1998, at Woodcroft, being a clerk or servant to Riding for the Disabled Association of South Australia, Inc (“the Association”) she stole cash in the amount of $11,338.72 from the Association, contrary to s 176(1)(a) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act.  It was alleged that the money was stolen over a 28 month period, between 1 July 1998, and 31 October 2000.  At all material times, the Association was a charitable institution.

  4. On 15 January 2002 the learned Magistrate sentenced the appellant to a term of 16 months imprisonment, with a non-parole period of eight months, and declined to suspend the sentence.

  5. The appellant appeals to this Court on the grounds that the sentence was manifestly excessive in the circumstances, and that the learned Magistrate erred by not suspending the term of imprisonment.

    Facts

  6. The facts of the matter were outlined by the learned Magistrate.  Essentially, in June of 1998 the appellant commenced working as the volunteer treasurer with the Association.  Her position required her to receive money by way of cash and by way of cheque donated to the Association by the public.  Her duty was to issue a receipt for monies received by the Association and to bank the money.  The appellant embarked upon a scheme whereby when cash was donated to the Association she issued a receipt for the money but did not bank that money.  She kept the cash for her own purposes and to cover her action, when cheques were donated to the Association she failed to issue a receipt but banked them as if those monies were the cash which she had received and receipted.

  7. In October 2000 concerns were expressed about the financial position of the Association.  The appellant relinquished her voluntary position on 31 October 2000.  An audit of the Association’s finances was undertaken and when the appellant was questioned in relation to missing money she admitted stealing money from the Association.  When questioned by police the appellant told them she took the money for her living expenses, an explanation which was believed by the learned Magistrate.

    Fresh Evidence

  8. The appellant has sought to tender fresh evidence by way of affidavit.  The appellant has deposed as to her medical history, and her belated willingness to, with the assistance of her family, repay $5,669.36 of the sum stolen immediately, and the remainder at the rate of $100 per month.

  9. On the hearing of this appeal, I allowed this affidavit to be tendered.

    Ill health of the appellant

  10. Two exhibits were tendered along with the affidavit which related to the appellant’s health.  The first exhibit was a letter from Dr Lovell dated 23 January 2002 outlining the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hebberman v Police No. Scciv-02-178 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 267
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hebberman v Police No. Scciv-02-178, the appellant appealed against her sentence, arguing it was manifestly excessive and that the Magistrate erred in not suspending the term of imprisonment. The appellant had been a volunteer treasurer for an association and embezzled funds by not depositing cash donations and misrepresenting cheques as cash. When confronted, she admitted the theft, attributing it to her living expenses. The Magistrate found this explanation credible.

The legal issues before the court were whether the sentence was manifestly excessive and if the Magistrate erred in not suspending the term of imprisonment. The appellant also presented fresh evidence, including her medical history and willingness to repay the stolen funds. The court had to determine the admissibility of post-sentence health evidence to assess the significance of the appellant’s health condition at the time of sentencing.

The court acknowledged that generally, post-sentence health evidence is not admissible. However, it found that such evidence could be considered to elucidate the full extent and implications of health conditions existing at the time of sentencing. The court allowed the evidence regarding the appellant’s health, as it was pertinent to understanding her condition at the time she was sentenced. The court concluded that the evidence did not change the outcome of the sentence, as the primary factors for sentencing remained unchanged. The appeal was ultimately dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant appeals to this Court on the grounds that the sentence was manifestly excessive in the circumstances, and that the learned Magistrate erred by not suspending the term of imprisonment.Facts The facts of the matter were outlined by the learned Magistrate. Essentially, in June of 1998 the appellant commenced working as the volunteer treasurer with the Association. Her position required her to receive money by way of cash and by way of cheque donated to the Association by the public. Her duty was to issue a receipt for monies received by the Association and to bank the money. The appellant embarked upon a scheme whereby when cash was donated to the Association she issued a receipt for the money but did not bank that money. She kept the cash for her own purposes and to cover her action, when cheques were donated to the Association she failed to issue a receipt but banked them as if those monies were the cash which she had received and receipted. In October 2000 concerns were expressed about the financial position of the Association. The appellant relinquished her voluntary position on 31 October 2000. An audit of the Association’s finances was undertaken and when the appellant was questioned in relation to missing money she admitted stealing money from the Association. When questioned by police the appellant told them she took the money for her living expenses, an explanation which was believed by the learned Magistrate.Fresh Evidence The appellant has sought to tender fresh evidence by way of affidavit. The appellant has deposed as to her medical history, and her belated willingness to, with the assistance of her family, repay $5,669.36 of the sum stolen immediately, and the remainder at the rate of $100 per month. On the hearing of this appeal, I allowed this affidavit to be tendered.Ill health of the appellant Two exhibits were tendered along with the affidavit which related to the appellant’s health. The first exhibit was a letter from Dr Lovell dated 23 January 2002 outlining the appellant’s medical history and attaching a letter from Dr Tony Mylius. The second was a letter from Dr Lovell dated 21 February 2002 providing a more detailed summary of the appellant’s medical history and also commenting on the effect of 10 days imprisonment upon her health. Ordinarily, I would not consider admitting into evidence the comments of Dr Lovell in relation to the appellant’s reaction to her incarceration. It is not open to an appeal court to receive evidence in relation to events which have occurred since the imposition of sentence: see R v O’Shea (1982) 31 SASR 481. In R v Smith (1986-7) 44 SASR 587 King CJ dealt with a situation where evidence was sought to be adduced in relation to an appellant’s deterioration in health due to the stress associated with serving a period of imprisonment. He stated at p 588 that: "A clear distinction is necessary between fresh evidence as to events occurring before sentence and evidence as to events occurring after sentence."However, he continued:" While the evidence sought to be admitted on this appeal in a sense establishes the occurrence of events occurring after the passing of sentence, it does so for the purpose of explaining the full extent and implications of the appellant’s condition of health which existed at the time of sentence. I think that the authorities show that it is permissible to have regard to events occurring after sentence for the purpose of showing the true significance of facts which were in existence at the time of sentence"

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In October 2000 concerns were expressed about the financial position of the Association. The appellant relinquished her voluntary position on 31 October 2000. An audit of the Association’s finances was undertaken and when the appellant was questioned in relation to missing money she admitted stealing money from the Association. When questioned by police the appellant told them she took the money for her living expenses, an explanation which was believed by the learned Magistrate.Fresh Evidence The appellant has sought to tender fresh evidence by way of affidavit. The appellant has deposed as to her medical history, and her belated willingness to, with the assistance of her family, repay $5,669.36 of the sum stolen immediately, and the remainder at the rate of $100 per month. On the hearing of this appeal, I allowed this affidavit to be tendered.Ill health of the appellant Two exhibits were tendered along with the affidavit which related to the appellant’s health. The first exhibit was a letter from Dr Lovell dated 23 January 2002 outlining the appellant’s medical history and attaching a letter from Dr Tony Mylius. The second was a letter from Dr Lovell dated 21 February 2002 providing a more detailed summary of the appellant’s medical history and also commenting on the effect of 10 days imprisonment upon her health. Ordinarily, I would not consider admitting into evidence the comments of Dr Lovell in relation to the appellant’s reaction to her incarceration. It is not open to an appeal court to receive evidence in relation to events which have occurred since the imposition of sentence: see R v O’Shea (1982) 31 SASR 481. In R v Smith (1986-7) 44 SASR 587 King CJ dealt with a situation where evidence was sought to be adduced in relation to an appellant’s deterioration in health due to the stress associated with serving a period of imprisonment. He stated at p 588 that: "A clear distinction is necessary between fresh evidence as to events occurring before sentence and evidence as to events occurring after sentence."However, he continued:" While the evidence sought to be admitted on this appeal in a sense establishes the occurrence of events occurring after the passing of sentence, it does so for the purpose of explaining the full extent and implications of the appellant’s condition of health which existed at the time of sentence. I think that the authorities show that it is permissible to have regard to events occurring after sentence for the purpose of showing the true significance of facts which were in existence at the time of sentence" I have allowed the evidence in relation to events occurring after the passing of sentence for the purpose of showing the true significance of facts which were in existence at the time of sentence. It was submitted to me by counsel for the appellant that had evidence been placed before the learned Magistrate in relation to the appellant’s health, the Magistrate would then have been in a position to consider s 38(2c) of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WICKS J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WICKS J

Full text does not contain this section.