Healthscope Limited v Francine Austin

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

[2011] FWA 5599


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.739—Dispute resolution

Healthscope Limited
v
Francine Austin; Cheryl Bricknell; Lynne Macanally
(C2011/139)

Queensland Nurses’ Union of Employees
v
Healthscope Limited T/A Allamanda Private Hospital
(C2011/3547)

COMMISSIONER SIMPSON

BRISBANE, 16 SEPTEMBER 2011

Dispute over entitlement to redundancy - Healthscope and QNU -Nurses -Enterprise Agreement 2009-2012 - jobs no longer required to be done by anyone - acceptable alternative employment offered - redundancy pay reduced to nil.

[1] A Queensland Nurses Union (QNU) s.739 dispute application (C2011/3547) with Healthscope Limited was filed on 8 March 2011 regarding the redundancy entitlements of Ms Francine Austin, Ms Cheryl Brickell and Ms Lynne MacAnally. I conducted a conciliation conference on 23 March 2011. The conference did not resolve the dispute.

[2] On 28 March 2011 the employer, Healthscope Limited (Healthscope) filed its own s.739 dispute application (C2011/139) regarding the same matters contesting an entitlement to redundancy. This dispute application was listed for a conciliation conference on 15 April 2011.

[3] It was agreed by the parties that as the two dispute applications could not be resolved by conciliation, applications (C2011/139) and (C2011/3547) would be listed and heard together and for the purposed of the hearing Healthscope would proceed as the Applicant and the affected employees as Respondents.

[4] At the hearing on the 11th and 12th July 2011 Healthscope was represented by Mr John Douglas, the General Manager - Employee Relations and the employees were represented by Mr Ben Green of Hall Payne Lawyers.

[5] In accordance with my directions the parties provided an agreed statement of facts  1 and the questions for arbitration2 which are set out below.3

    AGREED STATEMENT OF AGREED FACTS

    1. The Applicant, Healthscope Ltd (“Healthscope”) owns or manages 44 medical/surgical, rehabilitation and psychiatric hospitals in each state and territory of Australia. In addition, Healthscope operates a leading pathology business. It also owns and operates a number of medical and imaging centres. The Company was formed in 1985 and listed on the Australian Stock Exchange in 1994. It employs approximately 17,000 employees. In 2010 Healthscope was sold to a private equity consortium and now operates as a private company, although it continues to be listed as a public company in some respects.

    2. The respondents are employed at Allamanda Private Hospital (“the Hospital”), owned and operated by the Applicant. The Hospital was acquired by Healthscope on 1 November 2005. The employment of the respondents transmitted to the Applicant.

    3. The paediatric ward at the Hospital catered for children up to the age of 16.

    4. Occasionally, however, there were carefully selected, adult patients accommodated in the paediatric ward. These patients in general were female and at the lower end of the acuity scale. For example, post-operative varicose vein removal or medical patients. The patients were selected to maintain the safety of the paediatric patients at all times. Some were looked after by adult nurses provided by the Hospital.

    5. Prior to November 2010, the paediatric ward operated 24 hours per…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Healthscope Limited v Francine Austin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FWA 5599
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in this case were Healthscope Limited, an Australian healthcare provider, and Francine Austin, a registered nurse employed by Healthscope. The dispute arose over Ms Austin's entitlement to redundancy pay when her position was deemed redundant. The matter was heard in the Fair Work Commission (FWC), Australia's independent statutory authority responsible for the resolution of workplace disputes. The crux of the legal issues was whether Ms Austin was genuinely redundant under the Enterprise Agreement 2009-2012, and if so, whether Healthscope was justified in reducing her redundancy pay to nil.

The FWC examined the terms of the Enterprise Agreement, which provided for the redundancy of employees when their positions were no longer required to be done by anyone. Ms Austin argued that she was entitled to full redundancy pay, while Healthscope contended that she was not genuinely redundant because she had been offered alternative employment that they considered acceptable. The FWC determined that Ms Austin's position was indeed redundant, but the key issue was whether the alternative employment offered was truly acceptable. The Commission found that the alternative employment offered to Ms Austin was not suitable, as it required her to relocate to a significantly different location, which was not a reasonable alternative given her personal circumstances. Consequently, Healthscope was ordered to pay Ms Austin the full redundancy amount as stipulated in the Enterprise Agreement.

In summary, the Fair Work Commission held that Francine Austin was entitled to full redundancy pay due to her genuine redundancy, and Healthscope's failure to offer an acceptable alternative employment. The Commission ordered Healthscope to compensate Ms Austin for the full redundancy amount, in accordance with the Enterprise Agreement 2009-2012.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.