Health Services Union v Presbyterian Aged Care

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read
[2021] FWC 45
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.739—Dispute resolution

Health Services Union
v
Presbyterian Aged Care
(C2020/7319)

COMMISSIONER JOHNS

SYDNEY, 25 JANUARY 2021

Dispute about any matters arising under the enterprise agreement and the NES, consequences of COVID-19 related direction not to attend work.

Introduction

[1] Twelve months ago (today) the first case of novel coronavirus (COVID-19) was confirmed in Australia after a man from Wuhan, flew to Melbourne. 1 28,766 cases and 909 deaths later, the pandemic, its social and economic affects, and day to day impacts have touched all Australians. More so in aged care where “COVID-19 presents particular risks to older people, who are particularly vulnerable to respiratory diseases”.2

[2] The special report 3 of the Royal Commission into Aged Care Quality and Safety entitled “Aged Care and COVID-19)” reported that (as at the date of the report in September 2020), “of [the deaths in Australia, 74.5%] were living in aged care homes at the time of their deaths…”.4 The Royal Commission identified infection control measures as being “nothing more important to help [aged care] providers prepare for and respond to COVID-19 outbreaks than access to high level infection prevention and control expertise”.5

[3] The dispute arises in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. In short, the dispute is about whether Presbyterian Aged Care (PAC/Respondent) was able to require staff to either utilise their leave entitlements or otherwise not pay staff when it directed 9 permanent staff to not attend the workplace when it determined that those staff had been in contact with a resident who may have been exposed to COVID-19.

[4] On 28 September 2020, the Health Services Union of Australia (HSU/Applicant) applied to the Fair Work Commission (Commission) to deal with a dispute under s.739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) with PAC.

[5] The relevant employees are covered by The Presbyterian Aged Care, NSWNMA and HSU Enterprise Agreement 2017-2020 (Agreement). By operation of clause 7.1 the Agreement displaces the operation of the underlying modern awards. The Agreement also covers the Health Services Union – New South Wales Branch.

Substantive hearing

[6] At the substantive hearing on 11 November 2020,

a) the HSU was represented by Mr L Maroney, Industrial Officer, and

b) PAC was represented by Mr S Puxty, Partner, Cantle Carmichael Legal.

[7] In advance of the substantive hearing the parties filed material. For completeness I set out below the documents relied upon by the parties. I have had regard to all of this material in coming to this decision.

Exhibit number

Description

Exhibit 1

Form F10 filed 28 September 2020 including attachments 1- 11

Exhibit 2

Respondent’s Outline of Submissions dated 16 October 2020

Exhibit 3

Witness Statement of Hanna Lee dated 16 October 2020 including attachments 1-2

Exhibit 4

Witness Statement of Janelle Margaret McDowall dated 16 October 2020 with attachments 1-4

Exhibit 5

Applicant’s Outline of Submissions dated 30 October 2020

Exhibit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Services Union v Presbyterian Aged Care and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FWC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Health Services Union contested a decision made by Presbyterian Aged Care, which was to exclude certain employees from the premises due to COVID-19 related directions. The dispute centred on the interpretation of the enterprise agreement and the National Employment Standards, particularly in the context of the pandemic's impact on workplace operations. The case was heard in the Fair Work Commission.

The legal issues at hand involved the interpretation of the enterprise agreement's provisions in light of the COVID-19 pandemic, and whether the employer's decision to exclude employees from the workplace was justified. The court needed to consider whether the exclusion of employees complied with the enterprise agreement and the National Employment Standards. It was also necessary to determine the implications of the directions issued under the Public Health Orders, and whether these orders could override the terms of the enterprise agreement.

The court ruled that the enterprise agreement did not explicitly address the scenario of employees being required to self-isolate due to a public health order. However, the court found that the enterprise agreement did not prevent Presbyterian Aged Care from implementing measures to comply with the public health orders, including the exclusion of employees from the workplace. The court concluded that the employer's decision was reasonable and lawful, given the exceptional circumstances of the pandemic. The court also noted that the National Employment Standards did not provide a basis for the Union's claim, as the employees were not dismissed but rather excluded from the workplace in accordance with public health directives.

The Fair Work Commission dismissed the Health Services Union's application, affirming the Presbyterian Aged Care's decision to exclude employees from the workplace due to the COVID-19 related directions. The court's decision recognised the need to balance the rights of employees with the public health imperatives during the pandemic. The court did not make any specific orders, as it found that the employer's actions were justified under the circumstances.