[2023] QCAT 184
QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
REID, Judicial Member
Assisted by:
MS ASHCROFT
MS BANWELL
MR LEWISNo OCR 058 of 2022
HEALTH OMBUDSMAN Applicant
v
MCGILVRAY, Adam Kenneth Graeme Respondent
BRISBANE
THURSDAY, 23 MARCH 2023 JUDGMENT
[1]JUDICIAL MEMBER: The respondent was, in October 2021, a 36-year-old father of four and a registered nurse, having completed his Bachelor of Nursing degree only in 2020. He has, today, outlined some of his background. He says that he had suffered a significant history of mental health issues during his youth, but prior to commencing nursing studies worked principally in support work/aged care-type employment. It is of interest that both of his parents had a history of working as nurses. The respondent worked in that capacity in 2021, at a private clinic in South East Queensland. The clinic was an adult mental health clinic.
[2]On the 21st of August 2021, the respondent was given what is described as the first and final warning after a patient complained of inappropriate comments that he had made. I otherwise do not know the facts of that offending and it is not here important. What is important is the giving of the warning. The respondent, when aware of the patient’s history of post-traumatic stress disorder, alcohol abuse, depression, anxiety and thoughts of self-harm, exchanged phone numbers with her when she was discharged from the clinic, albeit in June 2021, and so prior to the warning having been given. He subsequently exchanged a number of personal texts, including passages about catching up for coffee. Following the giving of the warning however, the patient contacted him by text. As a result, they met at a pub where she drank gin and tonic. During this meeting he kissed her. They were there for about one hour. This event occurred on the 30th of September 2021.
[3]On the 3rd of October, she again texted him. He went to her place. The schedule of facts says she was intoxicated. They there had consensual sex and he then dropped her again to a pub.
[4]Following the complaint made on the 5th of October by a friend of the patient to the Health Ombudsman, the respondent met, also, the clinic’s CEO/Director of Nursing. In that meeting he admitted having sex with the patient. The clinic then also reported the matter to the Health Ombudsman. He was, on that day, dismissed from his employment.
[5]The Health Ombudsman, on the 17th of November, proposed immediate registration action, prohibiting the respondent from having contact with female patients.
[6]After his employment with the clinic had terminated, he initially obtained work as a nurse with a general practitioner. But upon the imposition of the condition of his employment, prohibiting contact with female patients, he too left that work. He was then unemployed it seems for the whole of 2022. In early 2023, he has obtained employment driving trucks with a transport company.
[7]He is, as I have said, the father of four children. Two are employed.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Ombudsman v Mcgilvray, Adam Kenneth Graeme and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] QCAT 184
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Tribunal involved determining whether the respondent's conduct amounted to professional misconduct, the appropriate sanctions to impose, and whether the conditions proposed by the Health Ombudsman were justified. The Tribunal had to consider the respondent's history, his conduct, and the potential impact on the public and the nursing profession. It was also necessary to examine the Health Ombudsman's decision to impose conditions on the respondent's registration and whether these conditions were appropriate.
The Tribunal concluded that the respondent's conduct did indeed amount to professional misconduct and that a reprimand and suspension were appropriate sanctions. The Tribunal accepted the Health Ombudsman's submission that conditions should be imposed on the respondent's registration, finding that the proposed conditions were necessary to protect the public and maintain the integrity of the nursing profession. The Tribunal set aside the Health Ombudsman's decision to impose conditions on the respondent's registration, instead imposing its own conditions, and ordered that each party bear their own costs of the proceedings.
The Tribunal's final orders included a finding of professional misconduct, a reprimand, a twelve-month suspension of the respondent's registration, the imposition of specific conditions on the respondent's registration, and a review period for the conditions. The Tribunal also set aside the Health Ombudsman's decision to impose conditions on the respondent's registration and ordered that each party bear their own costs of the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi