Health Ombudsman v Kennedy (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Health Ombudsman v Kennedy (No.2) [2021] QCAT 88

PARTIES: HEALTH OMBUDSMAN

(applicant)

v

MARIANNE RUTH KENNEDY

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR078-18

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

24 March 2021

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Judge Allen QC, Deputy President

ORDERS:

Each party must bear the party’s own costs for the proceeding.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS – NURSES – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS – SANCTION – where the respondent is a registered nurse – where the referral charged, and the respondent admitted, a range of misconduct in relation to misappropriation of Schedule 8 and Schedule 4 drugs, contravention of a condition, and a failure to notify the Board of a relevant event – where the respondent disputed a charge of placing a patient at risk of harm – where the applicant was unsuccessful in proving the charge of placing a patient at risk of harm to the requisite standard of proof – where the respondent made an “offer to settle” before the hearing – where the orders of the Tribunal were no less favourable to the respondent than the orders proposed by way of the “offer to settle” – where the respondent applied for an order that the applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the proceeding including costs incurred after the “offer to settle” on the indemnity basis – whether the interests of justice require the Tribunal to order that the applicant pay all or a stated part of the costs of the respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALS – QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL – COSTS – where the respondent is a registered nurse – where the referral charged, and the respondent admitted, a range of misconduct in relation to misappropriation of Schedule 8 and Schedule 4 drugs, contravention of a condition, and a failure to notify the Board of a relevant event – where the respondent disputed a charge of placing a patient at risk of harm – where the applicant was unsuccessful in proving the charge of placing a patient at risk of harm to the requisite standard of proof – where the respondent made an “offer to settle” before the hearing – where the orders of the Tribunal were no less favourable to the respondent than the orders proposed by way of the “offer to settle” – where the respondent applied for an order that the applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the proceeding including costs incurred after the “offer to settle” on the indemnity basis – whether the interests of justice require the Tribunal to order that the applicant pay all or a stated part of the costs of the respondent

Health Ombudsman Act 2013 (Qld), s 103, s 104, s 107
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 100, s 102, s 105

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009, r 86

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Health Ombudsman v Barber (No.2) [2019] QCAT 252
Health Ombudsman…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Health Ombudsman v Kennedy (No.2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCAT 88
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Health Ombudsman v Kennedy (No.2), the applicant sought a departure from the default position on costs under section 100 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) Act. The respondent, who was subject to a referral to the Tribunal for professional misconduct, argued that the applicant unreasonably proceeded with the litigation despite the matters in dispute being resolved in her favour. The respondent based her argument on an alleged "offer to settle" and sections 105 of the QCAT Act and rule 86 of the QCAT Rules. The primary legal issue was whether section 105 and rule 86 applied to costs in disciplinary proceedings, and if the applicant acted unreasonably by not conceding the remaining disputes.

The Court considered the arguments put forward by the respondent and noted that while there are strong policy reasons for the Tribunal to respect agreed positions in such proceedings, it is not bound to do so. The Court found that section 105 and rule 86 do not apply to disciplinary proceedings, as previously held in Health Ombudsman v Barber (No 2) and Medical Board of Australia v Putha. The Court held that the applicant was not unreasonable in proceeding with the litigation, as the evidence at the time of the hearing reasonably supported their position. The Tribunal's ultimate decision in favour of the respondent did not render the applicant's submission on sanctions unreasonable. Therefore, the Court found that the interests of justice did not require a departure from the default position on costs.

The Court did, however, consider the respondent's argument that negotiations between parties could be taken into account under section 102(3)(f) of the QCAT Act. The Court found that the negotiations did not impact the outcome of the costs decision. The Court ultimately agreed with the applicant's submission that no order as to costs should be made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant submitted that the interests of justice did not require a departure from the default position pursuant to section 100 of the QCAT Act and there should be no order as to costs.Consideration The respondent does not argue that she should not have been a subject of referral to the Tribunal. She concedes that she was properly the subject of referral to the Tribunal because of conduct that was found by the Tribunal to constitute professional misconduct requiring that the respondent be reprimanded. The respondent’s application for costs rests upon the fact that the only matters remaining in dispute between the parties at the time of the hearing were determined by the Tribunal in the respondent’s favour. The respondent argues that the applicant was unreasonable in litigating that dispute in the hearing but should instead should have conceded such matters and reached an agreed position as to factual findings and orders for sanction. The respondent buttresses such argument by reference to an “offer to settle” in those terms and section 105 of the QCAT Act and rule 86 of the QCAT Rules. I respectfully agree with the reasons of Deputy President Sheridan DCJ in Health Ombudsman v Barber (No 2) and the Hon J B Thomas QC, Judicial Member, in Medical Board of Australia v Putha why section 105 of the QCAT Act and rule 86 of the QCAT Rules do not apply in consideration of costs in disciplinary proceedings such as these. Whilst there are strong policy reasons why the Tribunal will not readily depart from an agreed position contended for by parties in such proceedings,[9] the Tribunal is not bound to do so. It remains for the Tribunal to make its own determinations pursuant to section 107 of the HO Act. Whilst parties will always be encouraged to resolve matters in dispute, the parties cannot settle the proceeding as might parties to a commercial dispute to which the terms of rule 86 of the QCAT Rules are apt. That does not mean that the fact of negotiations between parties to disciplinary proceedings might not be considered pursuant to section 102(3)(f) of the QCAT Act. I have considered such matter in the exercise of discretion pursuant to section 102 of the QCAT Act. [9]Legal Services Commissioner v McLeod [2020] QCAT 371 at [31]-[32] per the Hon Peter Lyons QC, Judicial Member. I do not consider it was at all unreasonable for the applicant to proceed as it did before the Tribunal. As the evidence stood as revealed by the contents of material filed in the Tribunal prior to the hearing, it was at least reasonably arguable that the factual dispute should be resolved in favour of the applicant. That the viva voce evidence of the applicant’s witnesses was not entirely in accord with their prior written statements, such that the case of the applicant was weaker than it earlier appeared, does not mean that it was unreasonable for the applicant to proceed as it did. Ultimately, the Tribunal did not prefer the evidence of the respondent to that of the applicant’s witnesses but, in light of the burden and standard of proof, could not be satisfied, on the evidence adduced by the applicant, that a finding adverse to the applicant should be made.[10] Once that finding was made in favour of the respondent, the applicant’s position on sanction was weakened but it was not unreasonable for the applicant to contend, nevertheless, for orders cancelling the respondent’s registration and disqualifying her from applying for re-registration for a period of up to six months. It does not necessarily follow from the fact that the Tribunal did not accept such submission that such submission was unreasonable.[10] Health Ombudsman v Kennedy [2019] QCAT 319 at [43].