DARREN HEAFT v POLICE
[2004] SASC 37
Magistrates Appeal: Criminal
BESANKO J: This is an appeal against sentence by a defendant.
The defendant was charged with in excess of 64 counts of falsification of accounts contrary to s 178(1)(a) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). On 18th December 2003 the defendant appeared in the Adelaide Magistrates Court and pleaded guilty to 64 of the charges. The Magistrate imposed one penalty (s 18A Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (“CLSA”)) being a term of imprisonment of five years and ten months with a non-parole period of three years. The Magistrate’s starting point was eight years which she said she reduced by 20% by reason of the defendant’s pleas of guilty, six months by reason of the fact that the defendant had spent a period of a little over six months in custody in Canada and two months by reason of a period the defendant had spent on home detention bail in South Australia.
The Facts
A statement of agreed facts was put to the Magistrate setting out the nature of the defendant’s offending and the background to that offending. Much of what follows is taken from that statement.
The offences to which the defendant pleaded guilty occurred in the course of the defendant’s employment with Schenker Australia Pty Ltd (“Schenker”). Schenker operates as an international freight forwarding and customs agent arranging the import and export of cargo interstate and overseas.
The defendant had worked with Schenker and a predecessor company since 1981 and he was employed as a sea freight manager. The defendant’s duties included negotiating costing of contracts with Schenker customers, registering seafreight export shipments, acceptance of accounts payable, the generation of cheques to pay such accounts, the preparation and distribution of client invoices, and the subsequent entering of information into Schenker’s operational software program.
In November 1999 a number of anomalous export consignments were discovered in the Seafreight Export Department of Schenker. A number of incomplete export consignments were found to have incorrect details as to the identity of the exporter and consignee and the weight and dimensions of the consignment recorded on internal documents.
Schenker’s general manager spoke to the defendant concerning these anomalies and the defendant asserted that the anomalies in the consignments were due to the fact that he had extended unauthorised credit to customers. Over the next several weeks the defendant raised accounts to a number of non-existent companies and assured Schenker’s general manager that the accounts would be paid. Concern over the anomalies continued within Schenker during January 2000 and the general manager travelled to Sydney to discuss the situation with Schenker’s directors, and the managing director of Schenker in Australia travelled to Adelaide to discuss the situation with the defendant. On 28th January 2000, the defendant failed to attend at work and could not be located.
A subsequent investigation revealed that the defendant commenced committing the offences in 1994 and that they continued from that time to 1999.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Heaft v Police No. Scciv-04-14 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] SASC 37
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the sentence imposed by the Magistrate was appropriate given the mitigating factors. The court needed to determine if the reduction for the defendant’s guilty pleas and time spent in custody was correctly applied. The court also considered whether the overall sentence was just and whether it should be varied.
The court reviewed the Magistrate's application of the sentencing principles and found that while there were some miscalculations in the reductions for the defendant’s guilty pleas and time spent in custody, these errors did not warrant a reduction in the sentence. The court concluded that even if the errors had warranted re-sentencing, it would not impose a lesser sentence than that originally imposed by the Magistrate. The appeal against the sentence was therefore dismissed.
In conclusion, the court upheld the original sentence imposed by the Magistrate, finding that the sentence was appropriate and that any errors in the calculation of the mitigating factors did not justify a reduction in the sentence. The defendant's appeal was dismissed, and the original sentence remains in effect.
Background
Background to the litigation
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Heft v Police, the defendant contested the sentencing decision of the Magistrate in relation to the calculation of sentence reductions, specifically the 20% reduction for pleas of guilty and the one-for-one reduction for time spent in custody in Canada. The court found that the Magistrate did not fully apply the appropriate reductions, resulting in an over-sentence by approximately one and a half months. Despite this error, the court concluded that it did not warrant setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing because any reduction would not result in a lesser sentence than that imposed by the Magistrate.
Regarding the 20% reduction for pleas of guilty, the court considered the legal principles set out in section 18A(2)(b) of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA). This section allows for a reduction in the starting point for sentence if the defendant pleads guilty. The court held that the Magistrate should have applied the reduction by deducting 20% from the starting point of eight years, resulting in a reduction of one year and eight months. However, the Magistrate only reduced the sentence by one year and four months, falling short by four months.
In relation to the one-for-one reduction for the time the defendant spent in custody in Canada, the court noted that section 18A(2)(c) of the CLSA provides for a further reduction in the sentence for the time the defendant has spent in custody prior to sentencing. The court held that the Magistrate should have applied a six-month reduction, but instead only applied a reduction of six months, missing the exact one-for-one reduction.
The court then considered whether these errors warranted setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing. The court noted that the Magistrate’s starting point was eight years, and after applying the correct reductions, the sentence would have been four years and two months. However, the Magistrate imposed a sentence of five years and ten months. The court held that even if the errors warranted setting aside the sentence, it would not impose a lesser sentence than that imposed by the Magistrate.
In determining whether to set aside the sentence and re-sentence, the court also considered the principle of finality in sentencing. The court noted that setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing could have a detrimental effect on the finality of the sentencing process. The court held that while the errors were significant, they did not justify departing from the principle of finality and imposing a lesser sentence than that imposed by the Magistrate.
The court also considered the authority of previous cases in reaching its decision. The court noted that in R v Brown, the South Australian Court of Criminal Appeal held that errors in the calculation of sentence reductions could warrant setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing. However, the court distinguished this case on the basis that in Heft, the errors did not result in a lesser sentence than that imposed by the Magistrate. The court also noted that in R v Singh, the High Court held that errors in the calculation of sentence reductions could warrant setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing, but the court distinguished this case on the basis that the errors in Heft did not warrant setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that while errors in the calculation of sentence reductions can warrant setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing, the court will not impose a lesser sentence than that imposed by the Magistrate, even if the errors warrant setting aside the sentence. The court will also consider the principle of finality in sentencing and distinguish previous cases on the basis that the errors did not warrant setting aside the sentence and re-sentencing.