HC and MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

[2012] AATA  141

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/5579

Re

HC

APPLICANT

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

The Hon. Brian Tamberlin QC, Deputy President
Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

Date 6 March 2012
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed

...........[sgd].............................................................

The Hon. Brian Tamberlin QC
Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP:  Visa cancellation – character test - substantial criminal record - exercise of discretion to cancel applicant's visa pursuant to s 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 – Direction [41] applied – protection of the Australian community – seriousness and nature of the relevant conduct – the risk conduct may be repeated – Decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 501

Direction [No. 41] - Visa Refusal and Cancellation under section 501

CASES

Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs v Batey (1993) 112 ALR 198

Re Stone and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1981) 23 ALN 81

Rosson v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2011) 191 FCR 390

SECONDARY MATERIALS

-

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. Brian Tamberlin QC, Deputy President, Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

6 March 2012 

  1. This is an application for review of a decision by a ministerial delegate on 5 December 2011 who exercised the minister’s discretion under s 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act) to cancel the Applicant’s class BC Subclass 100 Spouse visa. 

  2. In reaching his conclusion the delegate gave significant weight to the extremely serious nature of the Applicant’s sexually based offences against a vulnerable child and placed some weight on forensic psychiatric opinions regarding the Applicant’s mental state.  The delegate also considered information in relation to his risk of recidivism in relation to crimes of a sexual nature against children and also that the risk could be lessened after completion of a sexual offenders rehabilitation program in prison.  The delegate noted the Applicant’s willingness to participate in such a program and that due to apparent delays he did not take part in such a program. The delegate expressed concerns regarding the Applicant’s overall rehabilitation having regard to probation and parole views as to his understanding of the seriousness of the offence and the delegate found that even if the Applicant’s risk of reoffending was low the seriousness of the offence and the protection of the community outweighed any countervailing considerations including any emotional distress his brother might suffer and also took into account any hardship the Applicant might experience if returned to Lebanon.

  3. The Applicant was born in Lebanon and is 31 years of age.  In 1996 one of his brothers, the father of the child victim, moved to Australia and married and subsequently had a family.

  4. In 2001 the Applicant met his wife who was visiting Lebanon and in July 2001 he married her in Lebanon.  She returned to Australia in 2001. They maintained their relationship by phone and email. 

  5. In March 2003 the Applicant came to Australia to be with his wife whom…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HC and MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 141
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court, HC and MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP involved a dispute regarding the cancellation of a visa under the Migration Act 1958. The Applicant, who had been convicted of multiple serious sexual offences against a minor, sought to challenge the decision to cancel his visa based on the character test stipulated in the Act. The case hinged on the exercise of discretion by the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship to cancel the Applicant's visa under section 501(2) of the Act.

The primary legal issue was whether the Minister had correctly exercised the discretion to cancel the Applicant’s visa. This involved assessing whether the Applicant’s substantial criminal record warranted the cancellation of his visa for the protection of the Australian community, considering the seriousness and nature of the offences, the risk of repetition, and other relevant factors such as family ties and potential hardship. The court needed to determine if the decision to cancel the visa was reasonable and aligned with the statutory criteria.

The court considered the extensive documentary evidence and oral testimony provided during the proceedings. The Applicant had a history of serious sexual offences against a minor, which were not isolated incidents but rather continuous over a period of two years and one month. Despite the absence of a prior criminal record, the nature and number of offences, along with the breach of trust, were deemed significant. The court also noted the heavy sentence imposed, reflecting the community's abhorrence of such crimes. The Applicant's mitigating factors, such as his expressed remorse and the impact of personal stresses, were weighed against the gravity of his crimes. Ultimately, the court concluded that the Minister's decision to cancel the Applicant's visa was correct, considering the protection of the community and the risk of repetition of such conduct.

The final orders affirmed the decision of the Minister to cancel the Applicant's visa, upholding the need to protect the Australian community from individuals who pose a significant risk due to their criminal conduct.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The other considerations which are to be taken into account but, which should generally be given less weight than that given to the primary considerations, include family ties, the nature and extent of any relationships; the person’s age; the person’s health; links to the country to which they would be removed; hardship likely to be experienced by the person or their immediate family or other persons lawfully resident in Australia and the level of education of the Applicant.THE EVIDENCE In addition to the extensive documentary evidence, oral evidence was given by the Applicant, his sister-in-law and mother of the victim, and his brother, the father of the victim. The mother of the victim gave evidence about the Applicant coming to live with them and about learning about the “horrible” acts of sexual assault towards her daughter. Her daughter complained about the Applicant and the mother set up a video camera in her daughter's bedroom to show her husband on his return from Lebanon. She was concerned he would not believe the complaints. The sexual assaults were discovered when the daughter took the tapes to her school headmistress. The police were called and the family were separated from their father for over a year by authorities. According to a victim’s impact statement referred to by the sentencing judge, the family was separated “in response to reports of the verbal aggression and intimidation by the victim's natural father”. The victim’s mother gave evidence of a vague, general, hearsay nature that the daughter loved her father very much and her daughter knows that her father would never do anything to hurt her. She says the daughter has come to accept that her uncle is very regretful. The daughter is now 16 years of age but was not called to give evidence. The mother of the victim has been married to the brother of the Applicant for 17 years and together that have six children although for long periods of time they have not been living together and at present they are living apart. The brother of the Applicant described the circumstances in which his brother came to live with them on the breakup of the Applicant’s marriage. He said that he had difficulty understanding what had happened. Initially he could not accept that the Applicant had engaged in such conduct but later accepted that it had occurred. He feels a strong sense of duty to protect the Applicant. As his only brother in Australia he had to support him notwithstanding what his brother had done. He repeats hearsay statements from the Applicant to the effect that his brother is willing to do anything to get his forgiveness and that he wants to apologise to the victim. At least until his daughter turns 18 the father will not allow the Applicant to have any dealing with her because he is concerned about her feelings. He says that his brother was not in the right frame of mind when the sexual assaults took place. He asserts that his daughter has accepted the situation as a bad moment of her life. He says he will help his brother rehabilitate himself if allowed to remain. He believes his brother has learnt from his mistakes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issue for determination is whether the correct or preferable decision in the circumstances is to exercise the discretion to cancel the Applicant’s visa.CONSIDERATION It is clear that the crimes involve violence against vulnerable persons including a very young minor. The offences were against a child and were strongly sexually based. It is within the category of a serious offence. This is reinforced by the sentence imposed for the crimes in question. The offences took place over a period of two years and one month. They involved breaches of trust placed in the Applicant by the victim and her parents and their family. They involved the victim complaining of sexual offences but no effective action was taken over this lengthy period until a very late stage when the child victim produced evidence to her school headmistress. The remarks of the sentencing judge took into account all the relevant mitigating circumstances at the time. He reached the conclusion that there was community abhorrence of such offences. The objective seriousness of the offences was found to be mid-range in relation to sexual intercourse of a child and just below the mid-range in relation to the indecent assault matters. Of particular importance is the fact the judge considered the offences could not be considered isolated or opportunistic offences and that they were aggravated because they involved a serious breach of trust. The total sentence of eight years imprisonment commencing on 6 October 2007 is to expire on 5 October 2015 with a non-parole period which could lead to release on 5 April 2012. This is a heavy sentence. Although the Applicant did not have a prior criminal record it is important to consider the number and nature of the offences and the period between them. There were numerous offences, they were continuous and there was physical coercion for two of the offences. There has been no repetition since the most recent offence. The Applicant has been in custody for most of that time. As regards mitigating factors, these are referred to in the sentencing remarks. The Applicant stated that he felt sorry for the victim and asserted that he understands how she felt as he had been sexually abused on one occasion and he did not why he engaged in the conduct. Further, as a mitigating factor the Applicant refers to his disturbance at the breakup with his spouse a few days after his arrival in Australia and he asserted that he felt like something was pushing him. There was some indication based on the Applicant’s account of the history to the Doctor, a forensic psychiatrist, in 2005, that the Applicant was suffering depressive symptoms after being rejected by his fiancée. There were other possible stresses of adjusting to a new society. The Doctor’s views expressed in his report were based on the Applicant’s untested assertions. He noted that the offender did not manifest any symptoms consistent with psychotic disorder or significant anxiety disorder. A central issue in this case is the risk of repetition of the conduct having regard particularly to evidence of the extent of rehabilitation.