HBMB and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

[2012] AATA 436

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2012/1617

Re

HBMB

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance

Date 11 July 2012
Place Melbourne

1.The reviewable decision, being the decision of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship made 19 April 2012 to cancel the Applicant’s BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa, is set aside.

2.In substitution it is decided that the Applicant’s BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa not be cancelled under subsection 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) by reason of the Applicant’s conviction of criminal offences in the County Court of Victoria on 18 February 2009.

...........[sgd].............................................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP AND IMMIGRATION – cancellation of a BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa – Direction [no. 41] – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – character test – substantial criminal record – primary considerations – the seriousness and nature of the conduct – the risk that the conduct may be repeated – other considerations – family ties, the nature and extent of any relationships – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 35

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 499(1), 499(2A), 501(2), 501(6) and 501(7)

Sex Offenders Registration Act 2004 (Vic)

CASES

Jason Schuster-McFadyen v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2011) 124 ALD 68; [2011] FCA 1303

Rosson v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 194; (2011) 191 FCR 390

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Direction [no. 41] – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501

REASONS FOR DECISION

Tribunal:        Deputy President J W Constance

Date:             11 July 2012

INTRODUCTION

  1. In 2007 Mr B entered Australia on a BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa and has resided in Australia continuously since that time.   

  2. On 19 April 2012 the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship cancelled Mr B’s visa as the Minister reasonably suspected that Mr B did not pass the character test set out in the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and Mr B had failed to satisfy the Minister that he passed the test.

  3. Mr B has applied to the Tribunal to review the decision of the Minister.

  4. For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be set aside.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND

  5. Unless otherwise stated the following findings of fact are based on the evidence of Mr B.

  6. Mr B was born in the United Kingdom in 1978.  He grew up and was educated there.  He met his wife, Ms B, in 1996 and they married in 2003.

  7. Mr B and Ms B immigrated to Australia in February 2007.  Mr B entered Australia as the holder of a BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa.  He is a trained teacher and holds tertiary qualifications in accounting.  He gained these qualifications before he entered Australia.

  8. Upon settling in Australia the couple purchased land and built a home. They both gained employment, Mr B as a teacher in secondary schools.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HBMB and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 436
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of HBMB and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship involved the cancellation of a BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa of Mr. B, who had a substantial criminal record, including multiple convictions for sexual offences against a minor. The dispute was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The court was required to decide whether the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship's decision to cancel Mr. B's visa was lawful and whether the primary and other considerations under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) were appropriately applied.

The legal issues centered around the interpretation and application of the character test for visa cancellation under section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), specifically concerning the primary consideration of protecting the Australian community from serious criminal conduct and the other considerations such as family ties. The court had to evaluate whether the seriousness and nature of Mr. B's conduct, along with the risk of re-offending, warranted visa cancellation. Additionally, the court considered Mr. B's participation in a rehabilitation program and his prospects for rehabilitation as relevant to the risk of re-offending.

The court found that the Minister's decision to cancel Mr. B's visa was flawed due to an inadequate consideration of the primary and other relevant factors. The court determined that while Mr. B's criminal conduct was serious, there were mitigating factors such as his participation in a rehabilitation program and the psychologist's assessment that his risk of re-offending was low. The court also highlighted the importance of family ties and Mr. B's stable relationship with his wife as significant other considerations that should have been given appropriate weight. Consequently, the court set aside the Minister's decision and determined that Mr. B's visa should not be cancelled.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be set aside.FACTUAL BACKGROUND Unless otherwise stated the following findings of fact are based on the evidence of Mr B. Mr B was born in the United Kingdom in 1978. He grew up and was educated there. He met his wife, Ms B, in 1996 and they married in 2003. Mr B and Ms B immigrated to Australia in February 2007. Mr B entered Australia as the holder of a BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa. He is a trained teacher and holds tertiary qualifications in accounting. He gained these qualifications before he entered Australia. Upon settling in Australia the couple purchased land and built a home. They both gained employment, Mr B as a teacher in secondary schools. For a period of approximately two months in mid-2008, Mr B had a sexual relationship with one of his female students, who was 15 years of age at the time. On 18 February 2009, in the County Court of Victoria, Mr B was convicted of the following offences:oCount 1 – indecent act with a child under 16 years;oCount 2 – indecent act with a child under 16 years;oCount 3 – sexual penetration of a child under 16 years;oCount 4 – sexual penetration of a child under 16 years;oCount 5 – sexual penetration of a child under 16 years;oCount 6 – sexual penetration of a child under 16 years;oCount 7 – sexual penetration of a child under 16 years;oCount 8 – sexual penetration of a child under 16 years;oCount 9 – possession of child pornography. The following sentences were imposed:oCount 1 – 6 months imprisonment;oCount 2 – 12 months imprisonment;oCount 3 – 3 years imprisonment (the base sentence);oCount 4 – 2 years imprisonment;oCount 5 – 18 months imprisonment;oCount 6 – 18 months imprisonment;oCount 7 – 18 months imprisonment;oCount 8 – 2 years imprisonment;oCount 9 – 12 months imprisonment. The total effective sentence was fixed at four years and six months and the non-parole period was fixed at three years.[1] The maximum term of imprisonment which could have been imposed in respect of each of counts 3 – 8 inclusive was 15 years. At the time he was convicted Mr B’s details were recorded in accordance with the Sex Offenders Registration Act 2004 (Vic) and he became subject to mandatory reporting for the rest of his life.[1] Exhibit A19. During the latter half of 2011 (whilst he was still in prison), Mr B took part in a sex offender program, the Modular Management & Intervention Program. This program was facilitated by two psychologists, Ms Buttigieg and Ms Shott.[2] Mr B participated in the entire course of 37 three hour sessions.[3][2] Exhibit A37.[3] Exhibit R2. The design of the program is stated to be as follows:The Modular Management and Intervention Program (MMIP) is a group-based intervention designed to target sexual offending behaviour. It is based on international best-practice principles and has the capacity to be individualised to the needs of each participant. The program offers practical ways of understanding offending, including helping participants admit more fully what they have done, helping them take responsibility for their offences, and providing them with practical ways in which to tackle these problems.[4][4] Exhibit R2, p. 2.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Direction provides further guidance in assessing the risk that the conduct may be repeated. Direction 10.1.2(2) provides:The flowing factors are to be considered as particularly relevant to this assessment:(a) a recent history of convictions, which should be considered as indicating an increased risk of re-offending;(b) evidence of the extent of rehabilitation already achieved and the prospect of further rehabilitation. Greater weight should generally be given to evidence from independent and authoritative sources, such as judicial comments, professional psychological reports, pre-sentence reports for the courts, parole assessments, and similar sources of authoritative information or assessment; and(c) evidence that the person has breached judicial orders, including parole, bail, bonds, suspended sentences and any other relevant undertakings or conditions imposed by the courts.Evidence of Mr Newton, Psychologist Mr Newton is an experienced psychologist who has specialised in the assessment and treatment of offenders, including sex offenders. He assessed Mr B in November 2008, January 2009 and June 2012 at the request of his legal representatives. Mr Newton provided reports dated 16 January 2009[13] and 7 June 2012[14] and gave evidence.[13] Exhibit A14.[14] Exhibit A15. On 16 January 2009, Mr Newton reported, in part:…InsightIn his discussion with me, [Mr B] was able to demonstrate a developing understanding of the issues associated with his offending. For instance he could discuss how he failed to take account of the emotional and psychological immaturity of the victim and had instead focussed only on the fact that she was physically mature. He said that he recognised that this had been a significant failing on his part. Secondly, [Mr B] was able to discuss the issues regarding his violation of the victim’s trust and the power dynamic between them. He said that he recognised that his position as a teacher ought to have imposed particular responsibilities upon him and that he felt ashamed that he had not lived up to these responsibilities.…Risk AssessmentIn evaluating the risk for sexual recidivism it is important to have regard to both dynamic and stable risk factors. Dynamic risk factors represent factors germane to the individual’s context, psychological functioning or environment which increase the risk of sexual offending. They are typically a target of treatment or other intervention and tend to vary from one point in time to another. By contrast, ‘stable’ risk factors are based in either the personality of the offender or their developmental history, or are reflected in the characteristics of the offending itself. Stable risk factors tend not to change over time. The degree of risk can also be modified by the presence of ‘protective’ factors.In order to evaluate the stable risk factors in this case, I completed the STATIC-99 for [Mr B]. This is a brief actuarial instrument which allows the evaluator to calculate the level of risk posed by a sexual offender and the probability of recidivism to sexual offending. Its accuracy has been confirmed in multiple studies across diverse sexual offending populations in a range of countries and situations. It is among the more commonly used risk assessment instruments in the field of sexual offending and is routinely used in sex-offender assessment both in Australia and internationally.[Mr B’s] scores on this instrument place him in the ‘Low Risk’ category for recidivism. His offending against an unrelated victim was identified as the main ‘stable’ risk factor in this case. In contrast, his age, his participation in a long term adult relationship, the lack of any violence in his offending, his prior good character and the absence of any previous criminal offending on his part are all factors correlated with lower rather than higher risk of recidivism.The only dynamic risk factor identified in [Mr B’s] case are his poor social skills. In contrast, his cooperation with the authorities, his growing insight into the factors underpinning his offending and the absence of any significant psychological instability are all considered to be protective factors.On the basis of all the factors considered in this review, I concluded that [Mr B’s] overall risk of recidivism to sexual offending would be low.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider it necessary that this order continue to protect the witnesses and schools involved from any negative publicity. I also consider it is appropriate to restrict the publication of the name and address of Mr B and Ms B to give them the best chance of re-establishing their life together and to ensuring the risk of re-offending is kept as low as possible.CONCLUSION The reviewable decision, being the decision of the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship made 19 April 2012 to cancel the Applicant’s BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa, will be set aside. In substitution it will be decided that the Applicant’s BN Subclass 136 Skilled Independent (Migrant) Visa not be cancelled under subsection 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) by reason of the Applicant’s conviction of criminal offences in the County Court of Victoria on 18 February 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister has determined two types of considerations:(a)primary considerations, which must be considered;[5](b)other considerations, which may be relevant and, if so, must be considered.[6]The various considerations are set out in the Direction; I shall refer to the particular considerations relevant to this application later in these reasons. Generally, the other considerations should be given less weight than that given to the primary considerations.[7] [5] Direction [41] para.10.[6] Direction [41] para.11.[7] Direction [41] subpara.11(2).THE PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONSPrimary consideration 1: the protection of the Australian community from serious criminal or other harmful conduct, particularly crimes involving violence – paragraph 10(1)(a) Included in the factors relevant to assessing the level of risk of harm to the community are the seriousness and nature of the relevant conduct and the risk the conduct may be repeated.[8][8] Direction [41] para.10.1.The seriousness and nature of the conduct – paragraph 10.1.1 The Direction provides, as unquestionably is the case, that all offences perpetrated against a child (particularly sexually-based offences) are considered serious.[9] The sentence imposed is considered indicative of the seriousness of the offender’s conduct to the community.[10][9] Direction [41] subpara.10.1.1(2)(b).[10] Direction [41] subpara.10.1.1(3). In her Reasons for Sentence delivered in the County Court on 18 February 2009,[11] Her Honour Judge Hampel said, in part:…Sexual abuse of children and young people is always serious. There are some significant aggravating features in your case. A was your pupil and you were in a position of trust. It was clear that you knew that she was infatuated with you. Although, when you were interviewed with the police you said – and to some extent the language in the Crown summary suggests – that there was a “relationship” between the two of you it is abundantly clear, and I want to make it abundantly clear it is not a relationship of equals. It was you, and you alone, who had the responsibility of managing a situation where you, and you alone were confronted by an infatuated child who did not have the maturity of life experience to manage the situation. You, by contrast, are a mature man, sexually experienced, educated and resourceful. You had what appeared to be a stable relationship with your wife and were in a position to understand the inequality of power between the two of you and the utter inappropriateness of nurturing and developing that situation and allowing it to develop and continue in the way it did.…In addition, what you did was teach this young girl dishonesty and deceit in the development and maintenance of the relationship. She knew you were married and she characterised this as an affair. It was you who created the false MySpace account for her. It was you who fanned her feelings for you and you maintained a steady flow of communication with her, creating or engineering circumstances where you could be alone with her.You knew she was only 15. You had looked up her age on the school records, before the first act of sexual intercourse with her. You discussed with her the fact that you knew it was illegal to do so, because she was under age. Thus your conduct also engendered in her a sense that she was complicit in what is your wrongdoing and your wrongdoing alone. Although you admitted it only reluctantly, it was clear that the pornographic images you had of A were sent to you with active encouragement from you and that in exchange and as further encouragement you sent her a topless shot of yourself.[11] Exhibit A19, paras 18, 19 & 20.