Hazell Bros Pty Ltd v Adams, Rodney Colin

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

[1999] TASSC 37

PARTIES:  HAZELL BROS PTY LTD
  v
  ADAMS, Rodney Colin

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  APPELLATE
FILE NO/S:  LCA 70/1998
DELIVERED:  1 April 1999
HEARING DATE/S:  15 March 1999
JUDGMENT OF:  Crawford J

CATCHWORDS:

Workers Compensation - Proceedings to obtain compensation - Preliminary requirements - Notice of accident - Generally - Notice of injury - Whether notice given as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury - Notice given by fax forty hours after.

Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Tas), ss32(1)(a), 33(1)(b).
Aust Dig Workers Compensation [128]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Appellant:  G W Tremayne
             Respondent:  D J Porter QC
Solicitors:
             Appellant:  Griffits & Jackson
             Respondent:  Wallace, Wilkinson & Webster

Judgment category classification:
Judgment ID Number:  [1999] TASSC 37
Number of pages:  4

Serial No 37/1999
File No LCA 70/1998

HAZELL BROS PTY LTD v RODNEY COLIN ADAMS

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  CRAWFORD J

1 April 1999

  1. The appeal has been brought from a determination of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal in favour of the respondent worker.  The Tribunal found that the respondent gave notice of injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of his injury, which is a requirement of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the Act"), s32(1)(a). It is that finding which is attacked by the appeal. The grounds of the appeal are:

1The learned Commissioner erred in law in determining that the respondent did give notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury.

2The learned Commissioner erred in law in failing to give any reasons as to why he concluded that the worker gave notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury.

  1. It was agreed by the parties that ground 1 would be argued upon the basis asserted by the appellant, which was that no tribunal acting reasonably and properly instructed as to the law could have made that determination (see FAI General Insurance v Morrisson (1993) 3 Tas R 9 at 27).

  1. The Act, s32(1)(a), requires that a person shall not be entitled to compensation under the Act for an injury to a worker unless (inter alia) notice of the injury has, as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury, and before the worker has voluntarily left the employment in which he suffered the injury, been given to the employer of the worker or a person referred to in s33(1)(b). The categories of persons referred to in s33(1)(b) are:

"(i)the employer of the worker or, if there is more than one employer, to one of the employers of the worker; or

(ii)a person under whose supervision the worker is employed; or

(iii)a person designated for the purpose by the employer; or

(iv)a person having authority or apparently having authority to receive such a notice on behalf of the employer;"

  1. It was the respondent's evidence before the Tribunal that he suffered the material injury to his knee when working for Hobart Blue…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hazell Bros Pty Ltd v Adams, Rodney Colin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] TASSC 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Supreme Court of Tasmania involved a dispute between Hazell Bros Pty Ltd and Rodney Colin Adams over the claimant's entitlement to workers' compensation. Adams argued that he had notified his employer of his injury as soon as practicable, while Hazell Bros contended that Adams failed to provide notice within the required timeframe stipulated under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The primary legal issue was whether Adams had given notice of his injury to the employer as soon as practicable, which is a prerequisite for compensation under the Act.

The court examined the statutory requirement that notice of injury must be given "as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury." The evidence presented indicated that Adams suffered an injury on 18 March 1996 and completed an Accident Report Form on the night of 19 March. He then returned the form to his supervisor at HBMI's office on the morning of 20 March. A faxed copy of the form was received by Hazell Bros at 7.30 am on 20 March. The court found that although there were some inaccuracies in the Commissioner's findings, the essential conclusion that Adams gave notice of his injury as soon as practicable was supported by the evidence. The court determined that Adams's opportunity to report the injury was limited due to his work schedule, and thus, his actions were reasonable under the circumstances.

The court also rejected the argument that the Commissioner failed to provide adequate reasons for his decision. While the reasons did not explicitly address the timing of the notice, the court found that the Commissioner had sufficiently identified the material facts and exercised his judgment accordingly. The court concluded that the appeal should be dismissed, upholding the Tribunal's determination that Adams had given notice of his injury as soon as practicable.

Background

Background to the litigation

Rodney Colin Adams worked for Hazell Bros Pty Ltd, which operated under the section of Hobart Blue Metal Industries. On 18 March 1996, Adams suffered a knee injury while working at Pasminco's premises, not at the premises of Hazell Bros. Adams continued working despite the injury, and only reported it the next day by filling out an "Accident Report Form" obtained from HBMI's office at Leslie Vale. He submitted the completed form to HBMI's office in Leslie Vale and subsequently faxed a copy of the form to Hazell Bros' head office at 7.30am on 20 March 1996. The key issue in the case was whether Adams gave notice of his injury "as soon as practicable" after its occurrence, as required by the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

The Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal found in favour of Adams, concluding that he did give notice of his injury as soon as practicable. Hazell Bros appealed this decision, arguing that Adams did not provide the notice within the required timeframe. The Tribunal had based its decision on Adams' evidence that he filled out the accident report form on the night of 19 March and submitted it to HBMI's office on 20 March before travelling to work at Copping. While there was no direct evidence of who forwarded the faxed form to Hazell Bros' head office, the Tribunal accepted that the form was received and placed on Adams' personnel file, indicating that notice was effectively given.

The appeal hinged on whether the Tribunal's finding that Adams provided notice as soon as practicable was reasonable and supported by the evidence. The court noted that Adams had a limited opportunity to report the injury immediately after it occurred due to his work schedule and location. The Tribunal's conclusion that Adams gave notice as soon as practicable was based on the circumstances of his work and the timing of when he could reasonably have reported the injury. The appeal was ultimately dismissed as the Tribunal's determination was considered reasonable and appropriately supported by the evidence.

The matter before the Supreme Court of Tasmania is an appeal from a decision of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal, which found in favour of the respondent worker in a compensation claim. The appeal was brought by Hazell Bros Pty Ltd, the employer, who contested the Tribunal's finding that the respondent, Rodney Colin Adams, gave notice of his injury as soon as practicable after its occurrence, as required by the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The employer appealed on two grounds: firstly, that the Tribunal erred in law in determining that the respondent gave notice of his injury as soon as practicable, and secondly, that the Tribunal erred in law by not providing reasons for its conclusion that the respondent gave such notice. The appeal was heard on 15 March 1999, and judgment was delivered by Crawford J on 1 April 1999. The appeal was dismissed, with the Court finding that the Tribunal's determination was supported by the evidence and appropriate in the circumstances.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the learned Commissioner err in law in determining that the respondent did give notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury?
2. Did the learned Commissioner err in law in failing to give any reasons as to why he concluded that the worker gave notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury?

Held
1. Did the learned Commissioner err in law in determining that the respondent did give notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury?
The court concluded that the Commissioner did not err in law in determining that the respondent gave notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury; appeal dismissed.

2. Did the learned Commissioner err in law in failing to give any reasons as to why he concluded that the worker gave notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury?
The court concluded that the Commissioner did not err in law in failing to give any reasons for concluding that the respondent gave notice of the injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury; appeal dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal by Hazell Bros Pty Ltd against the determination of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal in favor of the respondent worker, Rodney Colin Adams, was grounded on two primary issues. The first issue contested whether the learned Commissioner erred in law by determining that Adams gave notice of his injury as soon as practicable after its occurrence. The second issue was whether the learned Commissioner erred in law by failing to provide reasons for concluding that Adams gave notice of his injury as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury.

Regarding the first issue, the court examined the statutory requirement under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Tas), s32(1)(a), that notice of injury must be given "as soon as practicable after the occurrence of the injury." The court analyzed whether the notice given by Adams via a faxed accident report form at 7.30am on 20 March 1996 was indeed "as soon as practicable" after the injury, which occurred on 18 March 1996. The court found that Adams had limited opportunities to give notice due to his work schedule and locations, which restricted his ability to report the injury immediately. Despite this, the court concluded that the timing of the faxed notice, considering the circumstances, was appropriate and complied with the statutory requirement.

The court also considered the legal principle that notice to a company, such as the appellant, could be deemed sufficient if received by any person with authority or apparent authority to receive it on behalf of the employer, as per s33(1)(b)(iv) of the Act. This principle was supported by the concession from the appellant's counsel that receipt of the notice by the company via mail or fax would suffice. The court noted that the notice was received by the appellant at their head office, and thus, the requirement of the Act was satisfied.

Addressing the second issue, the court scrutinized whether the learned Commissioner provided adequate reasons for concluding that Adams gave notice of his injury as soon as practicable. The court held that the Commissioner's reasons, although not explicitly detailing the timing aspect, sufficiently addressed the material facts and the question of whether notice was given. The court found that the Commissioner's focus was on establishing the fact of notice rather than its timing, which was not contested by the appellant. Therefore, the court determined that the Commissioner's reasons were adequate and that the appeal on this ground should also fail.

In summary, the court upheld the Tribunal's determination that Adams gave notice of his injury as soon as practicable and found no legal error in the Commissioner's reasons. The ratio decidendi of this case is that notice to a company employer under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Tas) can be deemed sufficient if received by any person with authority or apparent authority to receive it on behalf of the employer, and that the timing of such notice must be assessed in the context of the circumstances preventing the worker from reporting the injury immediately.