Hazelhurst and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

Hazelhurst and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Migration) [2017] AATA 2711 (19 December 2017)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2017/5757

Re:Luke Hazelhurst

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member T. Tavoularis

Date:19 December 2017

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is set aside and substituted such that the discretion in section 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) to refuse the Applicant’s visa should not be exercised.

........................[sgd]........................

Senior Member T. Tavoularis

MIGRATION – visa refusal – Applicant failed character test under s 501(6)(d)(i) – that if allowed to remain in Australia risk he would engage in criminal conduct – delegate subsequently exercised discretion to refuse visa under s 501(1) – whether Applicant fails character test in s 501(6) – Tribunal found Applicant fails character test under s 501(6)(c) - whether discretion to refuse Applicant’s visa should have been exercised – Considerations weigh in favour of Applicant being allowed into Australia – discretion to refuse should not be exercised – decision under review set aside and substituted.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), s 43
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Schedule 2 – Australian Consumer Law

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 499, 500, 501,

Cases

Allan and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 1077
ETWK and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 228
Godley v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 83 ALD 411; [2004] FCA 774
Waits and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] AATA 1336
Wang and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] AATA 586

Secondary Materials

Direction No. 65 – Migration Act 1958 – Direction under section 499 – Visa refusal and cancellation under s 501 and revocation of mandatory cancellation of a visa under s 501CA (the “Direction”)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member T. Tavoularis

19 December 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application for review of the decision by a delegate of the Minister of Immigration and Border Protection (the “Minister” or “Respondent”) to refuse Luke John Hazelhurst (“the Applicant”) a Partner (Residence) (Class BS) visa, pursuant to s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).

  2. Under s 500(1)(b) of the Act, this Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision made by the Minister’s delegate.

    BACKGROUND

  3. The Applicant is a 28 year old citizen of the United Kingdom. He was born and raised in England, where the majority of his family still reside. He first visited Australia on 19 August 1990 when he was less than a year old.  He has since been in Australia about eight times.[1] 

    [1] See Exhibit 11, G documents, G3, pp 84 – 85.

  4. The Applicant met his now wife, Laura Smith, in 2007 and they were married on


    20 October 2011. Ms Smith was also born in the United Kingdom but was granted Australian citizenship by conferral on 10 February 2011.[2]

    [2] Ibid, p 51.

  5. On 25 October 2011, shortly after their wedding the couple…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hazelhurst and Minister for Immigration and Border Protectio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2711
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision made by the Minister’s delegate regarding a Subclass 820 Partner visa. The applicant, a citizen of the United Kingdom, had resided in Australia with his Australian citizen wife since 2011. The dispute arose from the applicant’s failure to disclose certain criminal convictions, including a juvenile assault in the UK and offences committed in Australia involving deception against an elderly consumer and roofing work.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the applicant met the character requirements for the visa, specifically considering the protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct. This involved assessing the nature and seriousness of the applicant's past conduct, as well as the risk to the Australian community should he engage in further criminal or serious conduct. The Tribunal also had to consider other non-exhaustive factors, such as the impact on family members and victims.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal found that the applicant's juvenile assault conviction, occurring at age 13, was not serious, arising from a response to bullying. While acknowledging the seriousness of the deception offences committed in 2013 against an elderly consumer, the Tribunal noted mitigating factors, including the applicant's lack of knowledge of the victim's Alzheimer's diagnosis and his prompt restitution. The Tribunal also found that the applicant did not deliberately target an elderly person for the roofing work offence. Ultimately, the Tribunal concluded that while the applicant's offending history was not entirely insignificant, it was not so serious as to mandate a refusal of the visa. The Tribunal considered the risk of future harm, noting that the applicant's past offending did not suggest a high magnitude of harm if he were to reoffend, and that his most serious offending did not result in actual imprisonment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Under s 500(1)(b) of the Act, this Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the decision made by the Minister’s delegate. BACKGROUND The Applicant is a 28 year old citizen of the United Kingdom. He was born and raised in England, where the majority of his family still reside. He first visited Australia on 19 August 1990 when he was less than a year old. He has since been in Australia about eight times.[1] [1] See Exhibit 11, G documents, G3, pp 84 – 85. The Applicant met his now wife, Laura Smith, in 2007 and they were married on 20 October 2011. Ms Smith was also born in the United Kingdom but was granted Australian citizenship by conferral on 10 February 2011.[2] [2] Ibid, p 51. On 25 October 2011, shortly after their wedding the couple arrived in Australia with the intention of starting a new life together. The Applicant entered the country on a Subclass 417 Working Holiday visa. The Applicant says he had previously spent time in Australia with his family on holidays and knew how beautiful a country Australia was. He and his wife had planned to spend some time living in Australia from a young age because she was a dual Australian citizen. The Applicant was also personally motivated to get away from family difficulties in the United Kingdom, such as his sister passing away while travelling in Greece and his brother’s issues with schizophrenia.[3] [3] See Exhibit 11, G3, pp 98 – 99. On 22 October 2012 the Applicant lodged an application for a Subclass 820 and 801 Partner visa,[4] which was sponsored by his wife, Laura. In that application, he did not disclose his UK assault conviction because it had been committed while he was a 13 year old juvenile and he did not think it would still appear in his police records.[5] Be that as it may, on 13 February 2014, he was granted the Subclass 820 Partner visa. [4] Also known as: a Partner (Temporary) (Class UK) visa and a Partner (Residence) (Class BS) visa.[5] See Exhibit 1, Applicant’s SFIC, at [23]. The Applicant returned to visit family in the UK on a number of occasions since relocating to Australia. Upon re-entry into Australia on 16 January 2015, the Applicant declared criminal convictions on his incoming passenger card. He declared that he had been convicted for “obtain property by deception” offences but again did not declare the abovementioned assault conviction from when he was a juvenile in 2003. On 23 June 2015 the Applicant left Australia for approximately 15 months. The Applicant said in addition to visiting his family, there had been some illness issues in his wife’s family. So they (the Applicant and his wife) remained in the UK to care for them. The Applicant returned to Australia on 12 September 2016, but his wife remained in the UK to help care for her then pregnant sister. Upon re-entry at Melbourne Airport the Applicant failed to declare his criminal history. He was counselled in this regard and permitted to re-enter on his Subclass 820 Partner visa. I will particularise the totality of the Applicant’s criminal and other conduct in Australia and the UK later in these reasons.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As mentioned earlier, the Applicant was charged with assault in the UK as a juvenile, when he was 13 years old. He was also randomly apprehended for attempting to dispose of illegal waste in the UK and fined. Although these matters may be classified as offences in Australia, having regard to his age and the circumstances of the juvenile assault offence as well as the circumstances of the waste offence, surely neither of them can be regarded as serious. Conclusion as to Nature and Seriousness of Conduct It is not correct to say that the Applicant’s offending history from 2011 to 2015 is not at all serious. To an extent, it is, but I do not think it is so serious such as to cause a decision maker to have no option but to exercise the discretion to refuse the visa. (b) The Risk to the Australian Community Should the Applicant Continue to Commit further Offences or Engage in Other Serious Conduct Paragraph 11.1.2(3) of the Direction provides two of the factors the Tribunal must have regard to in determining the risk to the Australian community. Stated briefly they are:(a)The nature of the harm to individuals or the Australian community should the non-citizen engage in further criminal or other serious conduct; and(b)The likelihood of the non-citizen engaging in further criminal or other serious conduct, taking into account available information and evidence on the risk of the non-citizen re-offending; and evidence of rehabilitation achieved by the time of the decision, and the duration of the intended stay in Australia. The Nature of Potential Future Harm Criminal or other serious conduct inherently has a negative effect on individuals and the Australian community at large. The essential question for the Tribunal is what level or magnitude of harm would the Applicant cause to individuals in the Australian community if he continued offending? The magnitude of his past offending, does not lead one to a presumption that if he were to reoffend, the harm would be great. It is clear that the Applicant’s most serious episode of offending comprises the Melbourne matters from 2013 for which he received a custodial term of five months which was wholly suspended for an operational period of 12 months. The maximum penalties applicable to this conduct are not inconsiderable: (1) for the offence of “obtain property by deception” the maximum custodial term is ten years imprisonment; and (2) for the offence of “attempting to obtain property” the maximum custodial term is five years imprisonment.[33][33] See Exhibit 1: Applicant’s SFIC, p 12 at [60], verified by reference to section 81 of Crimes Act 1958 (Vic). It should be noted that his 2013 Melbourne offending did not result in a sentence requiring him to serve an actual term of imprisonment. None of the balance of his offending has resulted in the imposition of a custodial term. I therefore think the Applicant’s following contention is fairly made: having regard to the maximum possible sentences, it is reasonable to accept that the Queensland and Victorian Courts assessed his offending at the low end (for Victoria) and the very low end (for Queensland).[34] [34] See Exhibit 1: Applicant’s SFIC, p12, para [61].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The other considerations which must be taken into account for visa refusal matters are provided in a non-exhaustive list in paragraph 12 of the Direction. These considerations are:(a)International non-refoulement obligations;(b)Impact on family members;(c)Impact on victims; and(d)Impact on Australian business interests.Primary Consideration A: Protection of the Australian Community from Criminal or Other Serious Conduct The Tribunal must have regard to the protection of the Australian community from criminal activity or other serious conduct. Paragraph 11.1 of the Direction further provides that decision-makers should also give consideration to:(a)The nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date; and(b)The risk to the Australian community should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct. (a) The Nature and Seriousness of the Applicant’s Conduct to Date Paragraph 11.1.1 of the Direction provides a list of factors to be considered in determining the nature and seriousness of a non-citizen’s criminal offending or other serious conduct. I will briefly consider the relevant factors in turn. A – Violent (and/or sexual) crimes are viewed seriously The only crime of violence recorded against the Applicant arises some 15 years ago, when the Applicant was a 13 year old juvenile. The circumstances of the offence are surely not serious, involving as they did retaliation against school yard bullying arising from the Applicant being subjected to adolescent and puerile taunts about his then physical appearance. In my respectful view, it is a matter that should have remained within and been resolved by the responsible schooling authority. There are no further offences involving the infliction of violence anywhere in the Applicant’s history since that time. For the sake of completeness, I note that there are no sexual crimes in his history. B - Crimes committed against vulnerable members of the community are serious The most telling offence in this category relates to the 2013 offences committed against the 89 year old consumer in Melbourne. In the Applicant’s favour is the evidence that the inflated price for the work was the brainchild of the “leader” of the three man group. There is no evidence to suggest the Applicant conceived of the idea to cause the lady to sign five blank cheques. Although the Respondent contends the victim was suffering from Alzheimer’s disease at the time of the offending, I am inclined to accept the Applicant’s evidence that this diagnosis was not known to him and his two colleagues at the time of the offence. Also in the Applicant’s favour is the promptness with which he recognised the wrongfulness of what had been done and his immediate repatriation of the duly ordered portion of restitution in the amount of $6,000 to the lady. The Respondent also sought to ground a contention of the Applicant taking advantage of another elderly person via his 2014 roofing work in the Glass House Mountains. I do not accept that the Applicant deliberately targeted an elderly person with the intention of committing this offence upon such a person. I am prepared to accept the Applicant’s evidence which is to this effect: “In about November 2014, one day after I finished giving a quote to an Italian farmer in the Glass House Mountains I stopped at a nearby house and introduced myself to the owner, Mr Yourell, I told Mr Yourell I had just given a quote up the road and asked if he wanted me to do his roof for him. I do not remember how I introduced myself to Mr Yourell because I have a lot of different customers….”[31][31] See Exhibit 11, G3, p 103 at [47] – [48].