CITATION: Haywood v Collaroy Services Beach Club [2004] NSWSC 356 HEARING DATE(S): 29 April 2004 JUDGMENT DATE:
30 April 2004JURISDICTION:
Common Law DivisionJUDGMENT OF: Master Malpass DECISION: The Notice of Motion is dismissed. The plaintiff is to pay the costs of the Notice of Motion. CATCHWORDS: Subpoena for production and interrogatories - fishing expedition - relevance and necessary order. LEGISLATION CITED: Supreme Court Rules 1970, Pt 24 r 5, r 5 (1) and (2). CASES CITED: Haywood v Collaroy Services Beach Club [2002] NSWSC 991.
Markovic v Northern Sydney Area Health Service & Anor [2001]NSWSC 252.PARTIES :
Anthony Neville Haywood (Plaintiff)
v
Collaroy Services Beach Club Limited
(Defendant)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20252 of 2001 COUNSEL: Mr R Scruby (Plaintiff)
Mr G Gemmell (Defendant)SOLICITORS: TD Kelly & Co (Plaintiff)
Hunt & Hunt (Defendant)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONMaster Malpass
Friday 30 April 2004
JUDGMENT20252 of 2001 Anthony Neville Haywood v Collaroy Services Beach Club Limited
1 MASTER: The proceedings have had a lengthy interlocutory history. The present application further adds to that history.
2 The plaintiff served a subpoena for production upon the secretary of the defendant. The defendant produced documents in response to paragraphs 1 – 5 of the schedule thereto. On 7 November 2003, the defendant filed a Notice of Motion seeking orders that paragraphs 6 – 8 of the schedule to the subpoena be struck out or set aside. On 13 November 2003, the plaintiff filed his own Notice of Motion. It sought orders in relation to the subpoena, leave to administer interrogatories and discovery of certain security camera footage.
3 Both Notices of Motion came before Assistant Registrar Howe. On 2 February 2004, he delivered his reasons for decision. He granted the relief sought by the defendant. He dismissed the plaintiff’s Notice of Motion.
4 On 23 February 2004, the plaintiff filed a further Notice of Motion. It seeks a review of what was done by the Registrar and the setting aside of his orders.
5 There is no issue between the parties as to the review process. The task of the court is to have a look at what was done by the Registrar.
6 Before proceeding further, I should mention that the order sought for discovery was not pressed.
7 The nature of the claim has been set forth in other decisions of the court (including the written reasons provided by the Registrar and Haywood v Collaroy Services Beach Club [2002] NSWSC 991). The plaintiff’s legal advisers do not know how the accident happened. All that is known is that he may have fallen backwards over a railing on a stairway in the Club premises.
8 The plaintiff relies on an affidavit sworn by Grant Watson. The defendant relies on an affidavit sworn by David Robert Grant.
9 The affidavit of Mr Watson annexes various documents (including a copy of the subpoena). The proposed interrogatories are Annexure A to the plaintiff’s…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Haywood v Collaroy Services Beach Club and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWSC 356
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to determine if the subpoena's requests were overly broad or not sufficiently linked to the proceeding's subject matter. It also had to assess whether the information sought was necessary and relevant to the case. The court examined the principles surrounding the necessity and proportionality of the requests to ensure they were not overly burdensome or irrelevant. The respondent argued that the information was crucial to their case, while the applicant contended that the requests were excessive and not pertinent to the issues at hand.
The court found that the subpoena contained requests that were not narrowly tailored to the specific issues in dispute and thus had the potential to be considered a fishing expedition. It determined that the requests were not strictly necessary or relevant, given the nature of the proceeding and the specific issues at stake. The court ruled that the subpoena did not meet the standard for compelling compliance and dismissed the application to compel. Consequently, the court ordered that the subpoena be quashed.
The court's decision was based on the need for subpoenas to be narrowly tailored to the issues in dispute and to avoid being overly burdensome or irrelevant. The court emphasised the importance of proportionality in legal proceedings, ensuring that discovery processes do not exceed what is necessary for the case. The final order was that the subpoena for production and interrogatories was quashed, and the respondent was not compelled to comply with the subpoena.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi