CITATION: Hawkins v Barkley-Brown & Anor [No 2] [2010] NSWSC 395 HEARING DATE(S): 8 April 2010
JUDGMENT DATE :
4 May 2010JURISDICTION: Equity JUDGMENT OF: Slattery J at 1 DECISION: 1. Order that the orders made by registrar Haggett on 15 April 2009 be and are hereby confirmed, namely,
a. The first accounts of John Hawkins and Vicki Barkley-Brown, the Executors of the Will of Rhoda Brenda Farrell covering the period 17th December 2005 to 1 August 2007 be passed.
b. The Executor John Hawkins be allowed Commission at the rate of:-
-1% on the sum of $5,028,463 representing capital realisations
-2% on the sum $445,101 representing income collected and
- 0.5% on the sum $485,000 representing assets transferred in specie
c. The Costs of and incidental to the filing and passing of the said accounts and of the application before the registrar be assessed at the sum of $3,250 plus fees
2. Order that interest accrue on the sum of $64,861.65 (representing the sum of $61,611.65 for commission and $3,250.00 for costs as allowed by registrar Haggett) at the rates prescribed on judgments pursuant to s 101 Civil Procedure Act 2005 computed on and from 15 April 2009 to the date of payment and calculated on daily rests.
3. Order that any interest payable pursuant to order 2 be paid out of the Estate of Rhoda Brenda Farrell (‘the deceased”).
4. Order that the notice of motion filed 13 May 2009 be and is hereby dismissed.
5. Order that the applicant Vicki Barkley-Brown pay the costs of the respondent John Hawkins of the said notice of motion on the party/party basis and further that the respondent otherwise be indemnified in respect of her costs of the said notice of motion out of the Estate of Rhoda Brenda Farrell.
6. Order that without prejudice to any other rights that the respondent may have to recover the costs payable pursuant to order 5 he may deduct those costs as agreed or assessed from the applicant’s interest in the deceased’s estate.
7. Order that the applicant do all things and execute all documents necessary or convenient to enable the respondent to give effect to order 6 and the orders for payment to the respondent of commission out of the deceased’s estate.
8. Liberty is granted to either party to restore the matter on 3 days notice for further orders or directions for the implementation or working out of these orders.CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE - costs - review of registrar's decision to award commission to plaintiff/executor - first defendant's motion for review failed - costs should follow the event - not an appropriate case for the award of costs on an indemnity basis against first defendant - conduct not deliberately delinquent - to the extent that plaintiff's costs are not recovered on a party/party basis from first defendant he should be indemnified from the estate - no costs order made in favour of the first defendant - interest to accrue on the commission…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hawkins v Barkley-Brown [No 2] and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2010] NSWSC 395
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of Hawkins v Barkley-Brown [No 2] was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute arose from a review of a registrar's decision to award a commission to the plaintiff, who was the executor of a deceased estate. The first defendant, Barkley-Brown, sought to challenge the registrar's decision on the grounds of costs. The case required the court to determine whether the first defendant's motion for review of the registrar's decision should be upheld and, if so, what the appropriate costs order should be.
The legal issues before the court included whether the first defendant's conduct warranted an indemnity costs order and whether the principle of costs following the event should apply. The court also had to consider the fairness of allowing the first defendant's late application for commission to proceed. The court found that the first defendant's motion for review failed because their conduct was not deliberately delinquent. The court emphasised that costs should generally follow the event, and in this case, it was not appropriate to award costs on an indemnity basis against the first defendant. The plaintiff, as the executor, was entitled to recover costs from the estate unless the first defendant was able to pay them directly.
The court ruled that the first defendant should not be granted costs against the plaintiff to the extent that the plaintiff's costs are not recovered on a party/party basis from the first defendant. Instead, the plaintiff should be indemnified from the estate for any costs not recovered from the first defendant. The court also determined that no costs order should be made in favour of the first defendant. Interest on the commission awarded would accrue from the time of the registrar's orders on 15 April 2009. The plaintiff was entitled to deduct from any estate distributions to the first defendant the amount of any assessed costs award in favour of the estate. The court concluded that it would be unfair to allow the first defendant's late application for commission to proceed.
The legal issues before the court included whether the first defendant's conduct warranted an indemnity costs order and whether the principle of costs following the event should apply. The court also had to consider the fairness of allowing the first defendant's late application for commission to proceed. The court found that the first defendant's motion for review failed because their conduct was not deliberately delinquent. The court emphasised that costs should generally follow the event, and in this case, it was not appropriate to award costs on an indemnity basis against the first defendant. The plaintiff, as the executor, was entitled to recover costs from the estate unless the first defendant was able to pay them directly.
The court ruled that the first defendant should not be granted costs against the plaintiff to the extent that the plaintiff's costs are not recovered on a party/party basis from the first defendant. Instead, the plaintiff should be indemnified from the estate for any costs not recovered from the first defendant. The court also determined that no costs order should be made in favour of the first defendant. Interest on the commission awarded would accrue from the time of the registrar's orders on 15 April 2009. The plaintiff was entitled to deduct from any estate distributions to the first defendant the amount of any assessed costs award in favour of the estate. The court concluded that it would be unfair to allow the first defendant's late application for commission to proceed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.