Hawkins and Hawkins (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

HAWKINS & HAWKINS (NO. 2) [2014] FamCA 1128
FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Interim – Where Reasons for Judgment recently delivered on a range of interim issues and orders sought – Where the Wife has filed several Applications in a Case seeking interim orders with respect to use of the parties’ real property and disclosure – Where orders are made for the Husband to vacate the parties’ real property and for the Wife to take over mortgage repayments – Where orders are made with respect to disclosure of documents and for the parties to file and serve affidavits detailing how much they have each spent on legal fees and the sources of those funds
Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth)
APPLICANT: Mr Hawkins
RESPONDENT: Ms Hawkins
FILE NUMBER: BRC 6561 of 2007
DATE DELIVERED: 9 December 2014
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Brisbane
JUDGMENT OF: Kent J
HEARING DATE: 9 December 2014

REPRESENTATION

FOR THE APPLICANT: Wrightway Legal
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Self-represented

Orders

It is ordered until further order that:

14 B Street, Suburb C (“the B Street property”)

  1. The Husband shall forthwith make payment of any outstanding monthly mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for the property at B Street, Suburb C (“the B Street property”) which he has not paid in respect of the period between the Orders of 24 March 2014 and the date of these Orders.

  1. On or before 10 January 2015, the Husband is to vacate the B Street property, with the Husband to be responsible for payment of the mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia up to and including the 10 January 2015.

  1. Upon the Husband vacating the B Street property and on and from 11 January 2015, and conditional upon the Wife maintaining repayments of the mortgage as referred to in these Orders, the Wife is to have the sole use and occupation of the said property with the Wife from the time of such occupation to be responsible for payment of mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia in respect of the mortgage debt secured on the property.

  1. Commencing from 11 January 2015 the Wife is to provide on a monthly basis to the Husband documentary evidence from the Commonwealth Bank of Australia evidencing her payment of the monthly mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for the B Street property as and when each such monthly payment is due.

  1. If the Wife is unable or fails to meet any monthly mortgage repayment to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for the B Street property when such payment is due, the said property is to be sold in the following manner:

a.   by the Husband and Wife doing all acts and things necessary and executing all such documents necessary to market the said property for sale by private treaty for a period of two (2) months at the agreed sale price of $800,000, and for the purpose of listing and marketing the property…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hawkins and Hawkins (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FamCA 1128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned orders made by Kent J in the Family Court of Australia regarding property and spousal maintenance between a husband and wife. The central dispute revolved around the matrimonial home, the B Street property, and the financial arrangements concerning its occupation and potential sale.

The court was required to determine a series of issues relating to the interim occupation of the B Street property, including the husband's obligation to vacate, the wife's sole use and occupation thereafter, and the responsibility for mortgage repayments. Further issues included the process for the sale of the property by private treaty or public auction if the wife failed to meet her mortgage obligations, the valuation of furniture and chattels within the property, and the disclosure of documents by both parties. The court also addressed interim spousal maintenance and the parties' legal costs.

Kent J ordered that the husband must pay any outstanding mortgage repayments for the B Street property and vacate the premises by 10 January 2015, remaining responsible for mortgage payments up to that date. From 11 January 2015, the wife was granted sole use and occupation, conditional on her maintaining mortgage repayments. The orders stipulated detailed procedures for the sale of the property by private treaty or auction should the wife default on her mortgage obligations, including agent selection and cooperation requirements. The court also ordered the husband to permit inspections for the wife to secure a tenancy, and specified which furniture and chattels were to remain at the property. Provisions were made for expert valuations of chattels and for the disclosure of financial documents related to legal fees and mortgage payments. Finally, interim spousal maintenance of $500 per week was ordered for the wife from 11 January 2015, and certain applications were dismissed or adjourned.

Orders

Orders of the court

It is ordered until further order that:

14 B Street, Suburb C (“the B Street property”)

1.

The Husband shall forthwith make payment of any outstanding monthly mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for the property at B Street, Suburb C (“the B Street property”) which he has not paid in respect of the period between the Orders of 24 March 2014 and the date of these Orders.

2.

On or before 10 January 2015, the Husband is to vacate the B Street property, with the Husband to be responsible for payment of the mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia up to and including the 10 January 2015.

3.

Upon the Husband vacating the B Street property and on and from 11 January 2015, and conditional upon the Wife maintaining repayments of the mortgage as referred to in these Orders, the Wife is to have the sole use and occupation of the said property with the Wife from the time of such occupation to be responsible for payment of mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia in respect of the mortgage debt secured on the property.

4.

Commencing from 11 January 2015 the Wife is to provide on a monthly basis to the Husband documentary evidence from the Commonwealth Bank of Australia evidencing her payment of the monthly mortgage repayments to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for the B Street property as and when each such monthly payment is due.

5.

If the Wife is unable or fails to meet any monthly mortgage repayment to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for the B Street property when such payment is due, the said property is to be sold in the following manner:

a. by the Husband and Wife doing all acts and things necessary and executing all such documents necessary to market the said property for sale by private treaty for a period of two (2) months at the agreed sale price of $800,000, and for the purpose of listing and marketing the property for sale the Wife shall nominate and provide to the Husband the names of three (3) real estate agents to effect such sale, with the Husband to select and nominate from that list the real estate agent to market and list the property for sale; and

b. with the Wife to cooperate in every way with the nominated real estate agent and without limiting the generality of such cooperation it shall include:

i. making the keys to the property available for the agent;

ii. allowing inspection of the said property at all reasonable times requested by the agent;

iii. doing or saying nothing to hinder or prevent the sale being effected;

iv. ensuring that the property, including the grounds, are in a neat and clean condition at the time of inspection by the agent and prospective purchasers; and

v. signing all documents by the agent in relation to the listing for sale by private treaty of the said property except a contract or agreement for sale which has not been authorised by the parties.

6.

If the B Street property is not sold by private treaty within two (2) months of being listed for sale by private treaty then the said property is to be sold by public auction in the following manner:

a. by the Husband and Wife doing all acts and things necessary and executing all such documents necessary to sell the said property by public auction with the Wife to nominate and provide to the Husband the names of three (3) real estate agents to effect such auction and with the Husband to select and nominate the real estate agent to carry out the auction (“the auctioning agent”); and

b. with the Wife to cooperate in every way with the auctioning agent and without limiting the generality of such cooperation it shall include:

i. making the keys to the property available for the auctioning agent;

ii. allowing inspection of the said property at all reasonable times requested by the auctioning agent;

iii. doing or saying nothing to hinder or prevent the sale being effected;

iv. ensuring that the property, including the grounds, are in a neat and clean condition at the time of inspection by the auctioning agent and prospective purchasers; and

v. signing all documents by the auctioning agent in relation to the listing for auction of the said property except a contract or agreement for sale which has not been authorised by the parties.

7.

Commencing from 1 January 2015, the Husband shall permit inspections (of no more than three (3) per week) by the nominated real estate agent for the purpose of the Wife securing a tenancy of the B Street property on a furnished basis, with the Husband to be given reasonable advance notice of such inspections and the Wife not to be present at such inspections.

8.

Whatever furniture and chattels the parties owned as at July 2006 and which remains in situ at the B Street property, is to remain at the B Street property, with the Husband to be permitted to remove only his own personal possessions when he vacates the said property.

9.

U Auctions is appointed as the single expert within the meaning of the Family Law Rules 2004 for the purpose of carrying out a valuation of the furniture and chattels at the B Street property, upon a letter of instruction in the usual terms by the Husband’s legal representative with a copy to be provided to the Wife.

10.

The Husband, in the first instance, is to be responsible for payment of the fees for such valuation, with the determination of ultimate responsibility for such payment to be reserved to the trial of these proceedings.

It is ordered that:

Disclosure

11.

Within fourteen (14) days of the date of these Orders, the Wife is to provide to the Husband’s legal representative a list identifying all of the documents the Wife contends have not been disclosed by the Husband to the Wife, but ought to have been, pursuant to the orders for disclosure made on 19 June 2014.

12.

Within fourteen (14) days thereafter, the Husband is to file and serve an affidavit disclosing any documents in his possession, power or control identified in the list supplied by the Wife, that have not been earlier disclosed.

Mr S

13.

Both parties shall forthwith instruct Mr S Chartered Accountants, the single expert, to complete and make available their report as soon as practicable on the material currently available to Mr S.

Spousal maintenance

14.

UNTIL FURTHER ORDER By way of interim spousal maintenance on and from 11 January 2015, the Husband shall pay to the Wife the amount of $500 per week.

It is further ordered that:

15.

Within fourteen (14) days of the date of these Orders, the Wife is to file and serve an affidavit detailing:

a. the total amount she has spent on legal fees and outlays for the Supreme Court (trial and appeal) proceedings and shall annexe to that affidavit all invoices for any such legal fees and outlays; and

b. the source or sources of funds used by her or on her account to meet payment of any such legal fees and outlays.

16.

Within fourteen (14) days of the date of these Orders, the Husband is to file and serve an affidavit:

a. annexing relevant trust account records, statements and receipts evidencing the payment by him or on his account of any legal fees and outlays with respect to the Supreme Court (trial and appeal) proceedings and the current proceedings in the Family Court of Australia being file number BRC6561/2007;

b. detailing the evidence of repayments he has made towards the mortgage to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for the B Street property between the Orders of 24 March 2014 and to date; and

c. providing particulars of the taxation incurred including the specific amount or amounts, and by whom or which entity or entities such taxation is incurred as a consequence of the monthly payments received from F (or any associated entity) by the Husband (or any associated entity).

17.

Pursuant to section 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) the Wife have leave to publish this Order to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia.

18.

Paragraphs 5.1, 9 and 10 of the Wife’s Amended Application in a Case filed on 8 September 2014 be dismissed.

19.

Paragraph 4 of the Wife’s Amended Application in a Case filed on 8 September 2014 be adjourned to the trial of these proceedings.

20.

All other outstanding orders sought not otherwise dealt with contained in the Wife’s Amended Application in a Case filed on 8 September 2014 be adjourned for further hearing at 10.00 am on 16 February 2015 at the Family Court of Australia, Brisbane Registry.

21.

Save for the orders sought in applications as specifically identified in these Orders and adjourned for further hearing, all other outstanding interim applications be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.