Hawker v McLeod and Dickinson

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read
10 CLR 628

HENRY HAWKER

JAMES McLEOD AND JOHN DICKINSON

DEFENDANTS, Crown Lands Act 1884 (N.S.W.) (48 Vict. No. 18), secs, 121,* 122-Agreement to

lease conditionally purchased and conditionally leased land-Option of purchase --Agreement made prior to issue of certificate of conformity-Illegral agreement reserves Meaning of " applicant."

Sec. 121 of the Crown Lands Act of 1884 provides that every devise, con- April 12, 13,

tract, lease, &., made before, at, or after the date of any application for a con- ditional purchase or conditional lease, with the intent or having the effect of enabling any person other than the applicant to acquire the land applied for, shall be illegal.

The respondent D. in 1902 applied for an original conditional purchase of Crown lands, and his application was confirmed in the same year. In September 1906 he agreed to lease these lands to the appellant for three years, with an option of purchase at any time during that period. In February 1908 the appellant gave notice to the respondent that he in- tended to exercise the option of purchase. In June 1908 a certificate of conformity was issued to the respondent. *Sec. 121 is as follows: " Every

with the intent or having the effect of devise contract lease agreement or

enabling any person other than the security made entered into or given

applicant to acquire by purchase or before at or after the date of any appli-

otherwise the land applied for shall be cation to make a conditional purchase

illegal and absolutely void both at law and in equity.'

10 CLR 629

Held, that a person ceases to be an applicant within the meaning of sec. 121 upon confirmation of his application, and that the agreement of September 1906, so far as it related to the option of purchase, was therefore valid.

Semble, the provisions of sec. 122 are complementary to sec. 121. Decision of A. H. Simpson, Ch. J., in Eq.: (Hawker v. McLeod, 9 S.R. (N.S.W.), 582 26 W.N., 125), reversed.

APPEAL by special leave from the decision of A. H. Simpson, Chief Judge in Equity, dismissing the plaintiff's suit for specific performance of an option to purchase dated 17th September 1906.

On 23rd January 1902 the defendant Dickinson applied for an original conditional purchase of 100 acres and a conditional lease of 300 acres. The application was confirmed in the same year. On 17th September 1906 Dickinson leased the land to the plaintiff for three years with an option of purchase at any time during the three years. On 4th February 1908 the plaintiff gave notice to Dickinson that he intended to exercise the option of purchase. In June 1908 a certificate of conformity was issued to Diekinson. On 10th July 1908 Dickinson offered the land for sale to the defendant McLeod. The offer was accepted and on 30th July 1908 Dickinson executed a transfer to McLeod, which had not yet been registered. The plaintiff's suit for specific performance of the option to purchase contained…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hawker v McLeod and Dickinson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1910] HCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from a decision of the Chief Judge in Equity of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appellant sought specific performance of an option to purchase land, which was contained within a lease agreement. The respondent, Dickinson, had applied for a conditional purchase and conditional lease of Crown lands in 1902, with his application confirmed in the same year. In September 1906, Dickinson leased the land to the appellant for three years, granting the appellant an option to purchase during that period. The appellant sought to exercise this option in February 1908, after a certificate of conformity had been issued to Dickinson in June 1908. Dickinson subsequently offered the land for sale to the other respondent, McLeod, and executed a transfer. The appellant's suit for specific performance was dismissed by the primary judge on the grounds that the agreement was illegal under section 121 of the Crown Lands Act 1884 (N.S.W.).

The central legal issue before the court was the interpretation of section 121 of the Crown Lands Act 1884. This section rendered illegal and void any devise, contract, lease, agreement, or security made or entered into before, at, or after the date of an application for a conditional purchase or conditional lease, with the intent or effect of enabling any person other than the applicant to acquire the land. The court had to determine whether the term "applicant" in section 121 referred only to the period before the confirmation of the application, or if it extended to the entire period until the land was transferable, including after the issue of a certificate of conformity.

The High Court of Australia, in allowing the appeal, reasoned that a person ceases to be an "applicant" within the meaning of section 121 upon the confirmation of their application by the Land Board. The Court found that the scheme of the Crown Lands Act 1884 indicated that section 121 was primarily directed at the initial stage of the application process, before confirmation, to prevent "dummying." The Court noted that after confirmation, the individual is typically referred to as a "holder" or "conditional purchaser," not an "applicant." Furthermore, the Court considered that the legislative history and the structure of the Act, particularly the introduction of Land Boards with supervisory powers, suggested a relaxation of the strict prohibitions found in earlier legislation. The Court concluded that the agreement of September 1906, relating to the option of purchase, was valid because it was made after Dickinson's application had been confirmed.

The Court ordered that the appeal be allowed and that the judgment of the Chief Judge in Equity be reversed. The appellant was entitled to specific performance of the option to purchase contained in the agreement of 17th September 1906.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.