Hassell v Adelaide Magistrates Court

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

HASSELL v ADELAIDE MAGISTRATES COURT

[2008] SASC 132

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kelly

16 May 2008

CRIMINAL LAW - PARTICULAR OFFENCES - DRIVING OFFENCES

Appeal against conviction and sentence - appellant appeared unrepresented at trial - appellant convicted for driving without a seatbelt properly fastened or adjusted contrary to Rule 264 of the Australian Road Rules - magistrate imposed fine of $180, prosecution costs and victims of crime levy, but waived court fees - whether the witnesses gave false evidence and colluded - whether the magistrate erred in favouring the prosecution - whether a miscarriage of justice occurred by the delay in listing the trial - whether the magistrate disrupted the giving of evidence by the appellant - whether the magistrate's judgment was made against the weight of the evidence.

Held:  evidence was sufficient to support a conviction - no substance to the appellant's complaints - magistrate's interventions were made to assist unrepresented litigant - no bias shown to prosecution - adjournments and delay in listing the trial did not cause a miscarriage of justice - appeal dismissed.

Australian Road Rules R 264; Magistrates Court Act s 42, referred to.

HASSELL v ADELAIDE MAGISTRATES COURT
[2008] SASC 132

Kelly J

Introduction

  1. On 19 October 2007 the appellant was convicted of one count of failing to wear a seatbelt properly adjusted and fastened contrary to Rule 264 of the Australian Road Rules.  The learned magistrate recorded a conviction and imposed a fine in the sum of $180 plus the Victim of Crime Levy of $70 and prosecution costs in the sum of $200.

  2. The appellant appeals against both the conviction and sentence on a number of grounds.  He alleges that the police gave false evidence, that the police colluded in their evidence, that the magistrate either colluded with or agreed with the police in their giving false evidence, that the magistrate disrupted the giving of evidence by the appellant, and showed favouritism towards the police.  He also complains that the matter was adjourned for a period of 2 years before the matter was finally listed for trial in October 2007.

    Background

  3. The prosecution case against the appellant was, that on 10 August 2005 at about 6.00 pm, police officers on routine uniform mobile patrol observed the appellant driving a motor vehicle on Sturt Road, Sturt.  Police observed that the driver was not wearing his seatbelt.  The police then activated their lights and siren and indicated that the appellant should pull over, which the appellant promptly did. 

  4. The matter was first listed on 22 December 2005 and then set for trial on 28 August 2006.  After an application by the prosecution to vacate that trial date the matter was re-listed for trial on 27 November 2006. 

  5. On 27 November 2006 no magistrate was available to hear the trial and the matter was re-listed for trial on 8 March 2007.  On that date the prosecution sought a further adjournment because a police witness was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hassell v Adelaide Magistrates Court and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, appearing unrepresented, appealed against both conviction and sentence for a driving offence. The conviction was for driving without a seatbelt properly fastened or adjusted, contrary to Rule 264 of the Australian Road Rules. The sentence imposed by the magistrate was a fine of $180, prosecution costs, and a victims of crime levy, with court fees waived. The appeal raised several issues, including allegations of false evidence from the police, collusion among witnesses, bias on the part of the magistrate, and procedural errors such as undue delay in listing the trial and disruption of the appellant's evidence. The court had to decide whether these allegations undermined the conviction and sentence.

The court reviewed the evidence and found it sufficient to support the conviction. The magistrate's interventions were considered to be aimed at assisting the unrepresented appellant. The court found no evidence of collusion or bias on the part of the magistrate. The delay in listing the trial did not cause a miscarriage of justice, and the magistrate's judgments were made based on the weight of the evidence. The appellant's complaints lacked substance, and the magistrate's imposition of a fine equivalent to the original expiation fee was deemed appropriate.

In conclusion, the appeal against conviction and sentence was dismissed. The magistrate's decision was upheld, and the evidence supported the conviction. The court found no merit in the appellant's claims of false evidence, collusion, bias, or procedural errors. The fine imposed was appropriate, and both appeals were dismissed. The magistrate's handling of the case, including the assistance provided to the unrepresented appellant, was deemed fair and proper.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant appeals against both the conviction and sentence on a number of grounds. He alleges that the police gave false evidence, that the police colluded in their evidence, that the magistrate either colluded with or agreed with the police in their giving false evidence, that the magistrate disrupted the giving of evidence by the appellant, and showed favouritism towards the police. He also complains that the matter was adjourned for a period of 2 years before the matter was finally listed for trial in October 2007.Background The prosecution case against the appellant was, that on 10 August 2005 at about 6.00 pm, police officers on routine uniform mobile patrol observed the appellant driving a motor vehicle on Sturt Road, Sturt. Police observed that the driver was not wearing his seatbelt. The police then activated their lights and siren and indicated that the appellant should pull over, which the appellant promptly did. The matter was first listed on 22 December 2005 and then set for trial on 28 August 2006. After an application by the prosecution to vacate that trial date the matter was re-listed for trial on 27 November 2006. On 27 November 2006 no magistrate was available to hear the trial and the matter was re-listed for trial on 8 March 2007. On that date the prosecution sought a further adjournment because a police witness was unable to attend. The matter was then listed for trial on 16 October 2007 and proceeded to trial on that date. Extension of Time The appellant’s notice of appeal was filed on 4 February 2008 well out of time. However, the prosecution has not opposed the appellant’s application for an extension of time within which to file the notice of appeal. In the light of that, and also the fact that the appellant has appeared both in the Magistrates Court and on this appeal unrepresented, I consider that an extension of time should be granted. Analysis I bear in mind that an appeal under Section 42 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 is by way of re-hearing. It is the obligation of this court, after reviewing all of the evidence and giving due weight to the advantage that the magistrate had in seeing and hearing the witnesses, to make an independent assessment of that evidence and make up its own mind as to whether the appellant was properly convicted. I have read the transcript and exhibits tendered at the trial in the Magistrates Court. I have also viewed the material placed before this court without objection by the respondent which includes, nineteen colour photographs (A), handed up by the appellant on the hearing of this appeal and two disks containing numerous photographs labelled (D1 and B). Those disks contain what appear to be numerous photographs of similar make and model vehicles to the appellant’s, taken from various angles and some further photographs of the appellant’s own vehicle taken from various angles. I will refer to these photographs again later. I bear in mind that on a charge contrary to Rule 64 of the Australian Road Rules, it is necessary for the prosecution to prove beyond reasonable doubt that:- the appellant was the driver of a vehicle- the vehicle was moving, or stationary, but not parked- the vehicle was fitted with a seatbelt in the driver’s position- the driver was not wearing a seatbelt properly adjusted and fastened.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Of course any delay can result in witnesses memories fading with the result that the evidence given about particular events may not be as clear or as accurate as when given closer to the time. Clearly the magistrate considered that the witness Collingridge’s evidence about the weather was an instance of poor memory. Nevertheless, the appellant has not pointed to any particular prejudice occasioned by virtue of the 2 year delay and I do not consider in the circumstances that the delay has caused any miscarriage of justice to occur.Conclusion After reviewing the evidence in the light of all of the appellant’s complaints, I can find nothing to cause me to have any misgivings about the conclusion of the magistrate. This was a straightforward matter and the evidence of each police witness was straightforward and clear. The police officers observed a relatively minor breach of the road rules in the course of a routine traffic patrol. None of the appellant’s complaints have been substantiated. In my view the appeal against conviction should be dismissed. The magistrate imposed a fine of $180 which is equivalent to the amount of the original expiation fee for the offence. In these circumstances both the appeal against conviction and the appeal against sentence are dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.