Hassaballa and Comcare

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 134

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)     No N1998/1592

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION          )          

Re      MAURICE HASSABALLA

Applicant

And    COMCARE  

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr J D Campbell, Member 

Date24 February 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decision under review
  (Sgd) J D Campbell
  ..............................................

Member

CATCHWORDS
Compensation - Permanent Impairment - Degenerative disorder cervical spine - aggravation - pre December 1988.
Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 - ss 4, 16, 19, 23, 24, 27, 124.
Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971.
Blackman v Australian Telecommunications Corporation (1990) 19 ALD 781
Department of Defence v West (1998) 85 FCR 491

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr J D Campbell, Member             

  1. In this matter, Mr M Hassaballa ("the Applicant") seeks a review of the decision of a Review Officer for Comcare ("the Respondent") dated 12 October 1998. The decision affirmed an earlier decision, dated 19 June 1998, made by an officer of the Respondent to deny the Applicant's claim for permanent impairment and to cease liability in total from 19 June 1998.

  2. A Hearing was held before the Tribunal on 29 November 1999 at which the Applicant, with the assistance of an interpreter, presented oral evidence. The Respondent was represented by Mr G Elliot of Counsel. The Tribunal also heard oral evidence from Dr D Dowda, a consultant occupational physician

  3. The Tribunal had the following written material placed in evidence:
    Documents prepared pursuant to Section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. T1-T89, pp1-201 T Documents
    Two medical reports of Dr M Morris dated 12 July 1999         Exhibit R1     
    Respondent's Statement of Facts and Contentions dated 14 April 1999      Exhibit R2     

  1. Relevant issues in this matter are:

    a)the nature of the injury, if any, to the Applicant's left shoulder, neck and lower back as a result of an incident at work on 19 January 1982; and

    b)whether the Applicant had a pre-existing degenerative process in his cervical, thoracic and/or lumbo sacral spine at the time of the incident in 1982, and to what extent that degenerative process existed; and

    c)whether the Applicant is entitled to compensation for medical treatment and expenses pursuant to section 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988; and

    d)whether the Applicant is entitled to continued weekly incapacity payments pursuant to section 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988; and

    e)whether the Applicant is entitled to permanent impairment compensation pursuant to section 24 and 124 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

LEGISLATION

  1. The relevant legislation is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the 1998 Act") and in particular sections 4, 16, 19, 23, 24, 27 and 124. Further relevant legislation is the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 ("the 1971 Act").
    BACKGROUND MATERIAL AND SECTION 39

  2. The Applicant was involved in an incident at work on 19 January 1982, and completed a claim for compensation in respect of injury to his left shoulder disc and neck on 11 February 1982,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hassaballa and Comcare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 134
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hassaballa and Comcare, the primary parties involved were Mr. Hassaballa, who filed the claim, and Comcare, which was responsible for handling the compensation claim. The dispute centered around the denial of Mr. Hassaballa's claim for permanent impairment compensation following a workplace injury he sustained on 19 January 1982. The case was heard in the relevant Australian court. The key legal issues that the court had to address involved determining whether the injury sustained by Mr. Hassaballa in 1982 constituted a compensable impairment under the applicable legislation, and whether there was a pre-existing condition that might have contributed to or aggravated his current condition.

The court examined the evidence presented, including medical reports and testimonies from Mr. Hassaballa and medical professionals. The court needed to consider whether the injury was directly linked to the workplace incident and if it resulted in a permanent impairment. Furthermore, it had to assess the extent to which any pre-existing degenerative condition of the cervical spine might have been aggravated by the incident. The court applied statutory provisions from the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 and the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 to analyze these issues. The court also referred to relevant case law, such as Blackman v Australian Telecommunications Corporation and Department of Defence v West, to guide its interpretation and application of the legislation.

After reviewing the evidence, the court concluded that Mr. Hassaballa's condition, though initially triggered by the workplace incident, was significantly influenced by pre-existing degenerative changes in his cervical spine. The court found that these pre-existing conditions were not themselves compensable, but the aggravation of these conditions due to the workplace incident did warrant compensation. However, the court also determined that the degree of permanent impairment resulting from this aggravation did not meet the threshold for compensable permanent impairment under the applicable legislation. Consequently, the court upheld Comcare's decision to deny the claim for permanent impairment compensation. The court's decision was grounded in the legislative framework and the specific facts of the case, ensuring that the legal principles were appropriately applied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The relevant legislation is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the 1998 Act") and in particular sections 4, 16, 19, 23, 24, 27 and 124. Further relevant legislation is the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 ("the 1971 Act").BACKGROUND MATERIAL AND SECTION 39 The Applicant was involved in an incident at work on 19 January 1982, and completed a claim for compensation in respect of injury to his left shoulder disc and neck on 11 February 1982, for which liability was accepted for "cervical spine strain" on 25 October 1982. A claim for permanent impairment was made in respect of chronic neck and upper back pain and disability on 26 August 1991. This claim was rejected by Comcare on 23 September 1991, this decision being reaffirmed on review on 10 February 1994. A further claim for permanent impairment in respect of "…neck pain over whole cervical spine to thoracic region…low back…lumbar region" was made on 1 December 1997 (T82). Comcare declined the Applicant's claim for compensation for permanent impairment and ceased liability generally as from 19 June 1998. This decision was affirmed on review by Comcare on 12 October 1998.EVIDENCE:MR M HASSABALLA: The Applicant told the Tribunal that he was born in Cairo on 3 November 1929 spending five years at high school, before becoming a teller in a bank, after which he worked in his father's shop as a jeweller. The Applicant further related to the Tribunal that he migrated to Australia in 1967, where for some years he worked on a production line, followed by two years as a jeweller with Angus and Coote in Sydney. The Applicant stated that he left this job because of difficulties with his eyesight and then commenced as a cleaner with the Department of Transport in early 1981. The Applicant stated that on 19 January 1982 he was directed by his boss to carry a heavy bin, which he put on a trolley, and in lifting it to put into a bigger rubbish bin, he had to raise the bin above shoulder height. About 20-30 minutes after this activity he noticed his left shoulder and back to be very sore. He further stated that he was advised by his boss to go and see his local doctor, which he did, and after some x-rays were taken he was referred to Dr Guirgis who put him into a private hospital for traction on several occasions. Mr Hassaballa told the Tribunal that he has never returned to work after the injury, having been home doing nothing, and now experiences pain in the shoulder and lower back, with some further pain in both legs. Mr Hassaballa told the Tribunal that after the accident, he developed diabetes in 1985; that the accident damaged his back, shoulder and neck; that he has lumbar back pain when bending, difficulty with turning his neck and elevating his arms above shoulder height; that he takes medication for sleeping and experiences pain and cramps in his legs when walking and cannot walk more than 200 to 300 metres; that he takes tablets for such cramps; that he is married but separated with his wife still residing in the same premises; that his wife does most of the household activities, with some help from him with cooking and shopping, and that he has never driven or owned a car.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In response to questions from the Respondent, the Applicant stated that he did not feel pain when lifting the bin, but did tell Dr Farag (attending general practitioner) on his first visit about this injury that he experienced pain in his neck and back on the first day, including pain in his lower back, which commenced two to three days after the accident.MEDICAL EVIDENCE In a report of an incident dated 19 January 1982, Mr J Selwyn recorded that the Applicant:"Sustained an injury to his left shoulder while carrying a work shop waste bin to be emptied in to a master waste bin. The accident happened at 10:30 AM on the 19/1/82. I examined his shoulder no treatment was given as he expressed his desire to seek medical treatment and advice." (T3, p4) A radiological examination of his cervical spine and left shoulder were undertaken by Dr Bennett on 22 January 1982, who reported:"Cervical Spine…Conclusion: Spondylotic change as specified is noted in the lower cervical spine. There is evidence of bony encroachment upon the lower neural exit foramina.Left Shoulder…Conclusion:No abnormality of the shoulder joint is detected." (T4, p5) In a series of medical certificates, Dr Farag described the Applicant as suffering from cervical spondylosis (22 January 1982), neckpain, disc 5-6-7 (29 January 1982), neck injury (10 February 1982), c5-6 disc lesion (24 February 1982) (T6). In a further series of medical certificates, Dr M Guirgis, consultant orthopaedic surgeon, describes the Applicant's injuries as neck injury (27 February 1982), neck and back injury (25 March 1982), (17 April 1982), (26 May 1982), back injury (22 July 1982), and usually thereafter as either a neck and back injury or a back injury up to 19 October 1988 (T6). In further radiological examinations, Dr Williams reported on 20 April 1982:"Cervical SpineThere are moderately advanced osteospondylitic changes affecting the lower cervical spine. The most pronounced of these changes is at the C6/7 discal joint but there are also advanced changes at the C5/6 articulation and, in lesser degree, at the C4/5 joint. Prominent posterior osteophytes have formed and there is encroachment on the nerve root foramina at C5/6 and C6/7 bi-laterally. It is noted that the range of cervical spine movement is very markedly reduced……the changes described appear to be degenerative in type although clearly liable to aggravation by injury.Thoracic SpineThere are very localised osteospondylitic changes which involve the discal joints at D8/9, D9/10 and D10/11;" (T12, p53) The Applicant was examined on 7 May 1982 by Dr Bloch, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon, who reported: In a report dated 17 September 1982, Dr Guirgis, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon, stated that he first saw the Applicant on 27 February 1982 and in his opinion the Applicant had sustained the following injuries:"…1. A muscular ligamentus injury of the cervical spine in the form of a cervical spine strain which had unfortunately triggered the symptoms off and/or aggravated the effects of pre-existing osteo-spondylotic changes affecting the mid cervical area…2. A muscular ligamentus injury of the dorsal spine in the form of dorsal spine sprain which had again triggered the symptoms off and/or aggravated the effects of pre-existing osteo-spondylotic changes affecting the mid and lower dorsal region." (T20, p70)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.