FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Haslam v Money for Living (Aust) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2008] FCA 1832
MARY ANN HASLAM, BERNARD DICKENS, PHYLLIS LESLIE DICKENS, DELIA LEMON, ESTELL SYLVIA SMITH, THE ESTATE OF ELAINE GAINSFORD, EDWARD JAMES GAINSFORD, ATHOL EASTERBROOK and YVONNE GRAY v MONEY FOR LIVING (AUST) PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 107 611 218), MFL PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 111 105 125), STEPHEN O'NEILL, GARY DENNIS O'NEILL, JOLANTA SIMONE OLSZEWSKI, PERMANENT MORTGAGES PTY LTD (ACN 097 176 362), PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED (ACN 000 001 007), LATROBE INVESTMENT SERVICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 416 211), CASH FLOW KING PTY LTD (ACN 108 343 853), PATRICK O'DONNELL, BILL KAFALTIS, JASON TALEB, KERRILI PTY LTD (ACN 097 980 222) (TRADING AS DIAKOU FAIGEN (A FIRM)), REGISTRAR OF TITLES, MKM CAPITAL PTY LTD (ACN 111 776 464), RECORDER OF TITLES, THE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF VICTORIA, THE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF TASMANIA and STABLE TECHNOLOGIES PTY LTD (ACN 062 528 545)
VID 1468 of 2005
MIDDLETON J
2 DECEMBER 2008
MELBOURNE
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
VID 1468 of 2005
BETWEEN: MARY ANN HASLAM
First ApplicantBERNARD DICKENS
Second ApplicantPHYLLIS LESLIE DICKENS
Third ApplicantDELIA LEMON
Fourth ApplicantESTELL SYLVIA SMITH
Fifth ApplicantTHE ESTATE OF ELAINE GAINSFORD
Sixth ApplicantEDWARD JAMES GAINSFORD
Seventh ApplicantATHOL EASTERBROOK
Eighth ApplicantYVONNE GRAY
Ninth ApplicantAND: MONEY FOR LIVING (AUST) PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 107 611 218)
First RespondentMFL PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 111 105 125)
Second RespondentSTEPHEN O'NEILL
Third RespondentGARY DENNIS O'NEILL
Fourth RespondentJOLANTA SIMONE OLSZEWSKI
Fifth RespondentPERMANENT MORTGAGES PTY LTD (ACN 097 176 362)
Sixth RespondentPERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED
(ACN 000 001 007)
Seventh RespondentLATROBE INVESTMENT SERVICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 416 211)
Eighth RespondentCASH FLOW KING PTY LTD (ACN 108 343 853)
Ninth RespondentPATRICK O'DONNELL
Tenth RespondentBILL KAFALTIS
Eleventh RespondentJASON TALEB
Twelfth RespondentKERRILI PTY LTD (ACN 097 980 222) (TRADING AS DIAKOU FAIGEN (A FIRM))
Thirteenth RespondentREGISTRAR OF TITLES
Fourteenth RespondentMKM CAPITAL PTY LTD (ACN 111 776 464)
Fifteenth RespondentRECORDER OF TITLES
Sixteenth RespondentTHE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF VICTORIA
Seventeenth RespondentTHE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF TASMANIA
Eighteenth RespondentSTABLE TECHNOLOGIES PTY LTD (ACN 062 528 545)
Nineteenth Respondent
JUDGE:
MIDDLETON J
DATE OF ORDER:
2 DECEMBER 2008
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.It is declared that the land situate and known as 32 Saywell Street, Geelong North in the Sate of Victoria being the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume 7027 Folio 383 (‘the Smith land’) is subject to the interest of the fifth applicant, Estell Sylvia Smith, as a tenant in possession pursuant to s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic), namely a lease for the life of Estell Sylvia Smith or until Estell Sylvia Smith vacates the Smith land for a period longer than six…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Haslam v Money for Living (Aust) Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] FCA 1832
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues were whether the applicants were entitled to declarations that they held tenancies in possession or had equitable vendor’s liens for unpaid purchase prices. The court examined the statutory provisions relevant to tenancies in possession under the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic) and the Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas), as well as the principles of equity concerning vendor’s liens. The court had to interpret these provisions and principles to determine if the applicants’ claims were valid and, if so, to what extent.
The court found that certain applicants held tenancies in possession in their respective properties for the duration of their lives or until they vacated the properties for more than six months. The court also found that the applicants who had sold their properties had equitable vendor’s liens in respect of the unpaid balances of the purchase prices. The court made specific declarations regarding the proprietary interests of the applicants in the properties and the extent of their vendor’s liens. Additionally, the court reserved costs for later determination and made directions for how the Affected Group Members could establish their entitlement to declarations concerning their interests in the properties.
The court's final orders included declarations of tenancy interests and vendor’s liens for specific applicants, directions for further proceedings concerning the Affected Group Members' entitlements, and a reservation of costs pending the outcome of further judgments. This comprehensive approach ensured that the court addressed the immediate interests of the applicants while also setting a procedural framework for future claims.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. It is declared that the land situate and known as 32 Saywell Street, Geelong North in the Sate of Victoria being the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume 7027 Folio 383 (‘the Smith land’) is subject to the interest of the fifth applicant, Estell Sylvia Smith, as a tenant in possession pursuant to s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic), namely a lease for the life of Estell Sylvia Smith or until Estell Sylvia Smith vacates the Smith land for a period longer than six months.
2. It is declared that the land situate and known as 83 Little John Road, Warranwood in the State of Victoria being the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume 10153 Folio 254 (‘the Gainsford land’) is subject to the interest of the seventh applicant, Edward James Gainsford, as a tenant in possession pursuant to s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic), namely a lease for the life of Edward James Gainsford or until Edward James Gainsford vacates the Gainsford land for a period longer than six months.
3. It is declared that the land situate and known as 17 Harley Parade, Prospect Vale in the State of Tasmania being the land more particularly described in Certificate of Title Volume 33675 Folio 75 (‘the Easterbrook land’) is subject to the interest of the eighth applicant, Athol Easterbrook, and the ninth applicant, Yvonne Gray, as tenants under s 40(3)(d) of the Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas), namely a lease until their demise.
4. It is declared that Estell Sylvia Smith has an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price (together with interest thereon) under the contract of sale for the Smith land between Estell Sylvia Smith and the second respondent dated 9 December 2004.
5. It is declared that the sixth applicant, the estate of Elaine Mavis Gainsford, and Edward James Gainsford have an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price (together with interest thereon) under the contract of sale for the Gainsford land between Elaine Mavis Gainsford and Edward James Gainsford and the second respondent dated 18 November 2004.
6. It is declared that Yvonne Gray and Athol Easterbrook have an equitable vendor’s lien to the extent of the unpaid balance of the purchase price in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price (together with any interest thereon) under the undated Agreement for Sale of Real Estate for the Easterbrook land between Yvonne Gray and Athol Easterbrook and the second respondent.
7. Costs be reserved for determination after judgment has been handed down concerning the entitlement of the group members represented by the fifth to ninth applicants, namely William Burton and Annette Burton, Albert Walter Dally and Lorraine Joy Dally, Shirlee Davey, Raymond John Debenham, Anna Rose Kocsis and Leslie Luspia Kocsis and Joyce Doris Orchard (‘the Affected Group Members’) to obtain declarations regarding their proprietary interests in their relevant properties.
8. In accordance with s 33ZB(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), I declare that the judgment given in this proceeding affects the Affected Group Members.
9. Pursuant to s 33Z(1)(g) and s 33Q(1) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), I make the following directions in relation to the manner in which an Affected Group Member may establish his, her or their entitlement to declarations that:
a. the land of which he, she or they were registered proprietors and which was subsequently sold by him, her or them to the second respondent and mortgaged by the second respondent to the seventh respondent is subject to his, her or their interest as a tenant in possession pursuant to s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic), namely a lease for his, her or their life or until he, she or they vacate the said land for a period longer than six months;
b. he, she or they have an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price (together with interest thereon) under his, her or their contract of sale of the said land to the second respondent:-
(i) Each of the Affected Group Members file and serve an affidavit in support of his, her or their alleged entitlement to the declarations on or before 4:00 pm on 22 January 2009.
(ii) The seventh respondent file and serve any affidavits in opposition to the declarations being made on or before 4:00 pm on 22 February 2009.
(iii) The solicitors for the Affected Group Members and the seventh respondent file and serve by way of exchange any written submissions by 4:00 pm on 14 March 2009.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was brought before the court as an application for various declarations concerning the proprietary interests of the applicants in the properties mentioned. The applicants sought declarations regarding their interests as tenants in possession and their equitable vendor’s liens. The proceedings involved the filing of affidavits by the applicants and opposition affidavits by the seventh respondent. Written submissions were exchanged between the parties before the matter was heard.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Estell Sylvia Smith is a tenant in possession of the Smith land under s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic).
2. Whether Edward James Gainsford is a tenant in possession of the Gainsford land under s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic).
3. Whether Athol Easterbrook and Yvonne Gray are tenants of the Easterbrook land under s 40(3)(d) of the Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas).
4. Whether Estell Sylvia Smith has an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price of the Smith land.
5. Whether the estate of Elaine Mavis Gainsford and Edward James Gainsford have an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price of the Gainsford land.
6. Whether Yvonne Gray and Athol Easterbrook have an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price of the Easterbrook land.
Held
1. The court declared that Estell Sylvia Smith is a tenant in possession of the Smith land under s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic).
2. The court declared that Edward James Gainsford is a tenant in possession of the Gainsford land under s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic).
3. The court declared that Athol Easterbrook and Yvonne Gray are tenants of the Easterbrook land under s 40(3)(d) of the Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas).
4. The court declared that Estell Sylvia Smith has an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price of the Smith land.
5. The court declared that the estate of Elaine Mavis Gainsford and Edward James Gainsford have an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price of the Gainsford land.
6. The court declared that Yvonne Gray and Athol Easterbrook have an equitable vendor’s lien in respect of the unpaid balance of the purchase price of the Easterbrook land.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MIDDLETON J
The court held that Estell Sylvia Smith is a tenant in possession of the Smith land under s 42(2)(e) of the Transfer of Land Act 1958 (Vic), as she held a lease for her life or until she vacated the land for more than six months. The court applied the definition of a tenant in possession and found that Smith met the criteria. Similarly, Edward James Gainsford was held to be a tenant in possession of the Gainsford land under the same provision, as he held a lease for his life or until he vacated the land for more than six months. The court applied the same reasoning as for Smith. Regarding the Easterbrook land, the court found that Athol Easterbrook and Yvonne Gray were tenants under s 40(3)(d) of the Land Titles Act 1980 (Tas), as they held a lease until their demise. The court applied the definition of a tenant under the Tasmanian statute and found that the applicants met the criteria. Concerning the equitable vendor’s liens, the court held that Estell Sylvia Smith had a lien over the Smith land, the estate of Elaine Mavis Gainsford and Edward James Gainsford had a lien over the Gainsford land, and Yvonne Gray and Athol Easterbrook had a lien over the Easterbrook land. The court applied the principles of equitable vendor’s liens, finding that each party had an enforceable interest in the unpaid purchase price under their respective contracts. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that a person in possession of land under a lease, as defined by the relevant statute, is a tenant in possession, and they hold an equitable vendor’s lien over the purchase price of the land under their contract of sale.