Hasan and Inco Ships Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Hasan and Inco Ships Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2019] AATA 801 (7 May 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/4300

Re:Adeeb (Eddy) Hasan  

APPLICANT

Inco Ships Pty LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J W Constance

Date:7 May 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision under review, being the decision of Inco Ships Pty Ltd dated 20 September 2016 to refuse Mr Hasan’s request for an extension of time in which to seek a reconsideration of the determination made on 12 December 2007, is affirmed.

.............................[sgd]...........................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for review of decision to refuse extension of time in which to seek reconsideration of determination of liability – where delay in seeking reconsideration more than eight years after prescribed time in which to seek reconsideration expired – whether acceptable explanation of delay – whether prejudice to Respondent if extension granted – entirety of delay not satisfactorily explained – extension would unsettle established practices and generate uncertainty – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth)

CASES

Hunter Valley Developments Pty Ltd v Cohen (1984) 3 FCR 344

REASONS FOR DECISION IN INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION

Deputy President J W Constance

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Hasan claims that he was injured in 2007 in the course of his employment by the Respondent. Later that year he made a claim for compensation in respect of the injury under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth). In December 2007, the Respondent made a determination rejecting the claim.

  2. For reasons which I will set out later, Mr Hasan did not request the Respondent to reconsider its determination until April 2016. The Act requires that such a request be given to the employer within 30 days of the determination first coming to the notice of the claimant or within any such further period as the employer allows.

  3. On 20 September 2016, the Respondent refused Mr Hasan’s request for additional time in which to seek a reconsideration of the determination. For the purposes of this application, this refusal is the reviewable decision. Mr Hasan has applied to the Tribunal for review of the reviewable decision.

  4. For the reasons which follow, the reviewable decision will be affirmed. This means that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the determination denying liability to compensate Mr Hasan, in respect of the injury he claims to have suffered, as the Respondent has not conducted its own review of the determination.

    LEGISLATION

  5. Subsection 88(1) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) provides that:

    Application may be made to the [Tribunal] by a claimant for review of a reviewable decision.

    Reviewable decision is defined in section 76 to mean a decision made under section 78. Relevantly, a decision to refuse an extension of time in which to request that an initial determination of a claim be reconsidered is a decision made under section 78, and thus a reviewable decision.[1]

    [1] See my decision in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hasan and Inco Ships Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 801
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Hasan for review of a decision by Inco Ships Pty Ltd (the Respondent) to refuse an extension of time to seek reconsideration of a determination of liability. Mr Hasan claimed to have been injured in the Respondent's employ on 7 October 2007, and the Respondent issued a determination denying liability on 12 December 2007. Mr Hasan sought to have this determination reconsidered, but the Respondent maintained its position that it was not obliged to do so, effectively refusing the request for reconsideration. The application before the court was for a review of this refusal.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Respondent's solicitors' letter of 13 June 2017 constituted notification of a reviewable decision, and if not, whether the time for Mr Hasan to request a reconsideration of the original 2007 determination should be extended. The court was required to determine if the correspondence between the parties' solicitors amounted to a formal decision under the relevant legislation that could be reviewed by the Tribunal, or if the significant delay in seeking reconsideration warranted an extension of time.

The court reasoned that the Respondent's solicitors' letter of 13 June 2017, when read in its entirety, did not signify a change in the Respondent's position. Despite responding to the reasons provided by Mr Hasan's solicitors, the letter reiterated the Respondent's steadfast view that it had no obligation to reconsider the 2007 determination. Consequently, the court found that this letter did not constitute a reviewable decision made under section 78 of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth). The court noted that the Respondent had consistently refused to reconsider its determination, and the delay in seeking reconsideration, which extended over eight years beyond the prescribed time, was not satisfactorily explained. Granting an extension would have unsettled established practices and generated uncertainty.

The court affirmed the reviewable decision, which was the Respondent's refusal on 20 September 2016 to grant Mr Hasan additional time to seek reconsideration of the original determination. As a result, the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to review the initial determination denying liability to compensate Mr Hasan, as the Respondent had not conducted its own review of that determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 78(3) deals with the time in which an application for reconsideration of a determination is to be made. It reads as follows:(3) A request for reconsideration of a determination must:(a)set out the reasons for the request; and(b)be given to the employer within 30 days after the day on which the determination first came to the notice of the claimant, or within such further period (if any) as the employer, either before or after the end of that 30 day period, allows.BACKGROUNDMr Hasan’s claim and the Respondent’s response Mr Hasan claims that he was injured in the employ of the Respondent on board a merchant ship as it was docking in the Port of Melbourne on 7 October 2007. He reported the incident to the First Mate a short time later. On 18 October 2007, Mr Hasan lodged with the Respondent a claim for workers’ compensation in respect of the alleged injury. On 12 December 2007, the Respondent made a determination denying liability in respect of the claim. A notice of determination, which included a statement of reasons, was sent to Mr Hasan by email, courier and express post on 14 December 2007. There is a dispute between the parties as to whether Mr Hasan received any of these communications. For reasons set out later, I am satisfied that Mr Hasan received at least one of them.[2][2] Exhibit R1 at 6-7. Mr Hasan acknowledges that he did receive a copy of the notice of determination in 2012, when it was given to him by the solicitor acting for him at the time. At various times since 2012, Mr Hasan has instructed a number of solicitors to act for him in respect of his compensation claim. Correspondence between the parties’ solicitors On 6 April 2016, Mr Hasan’s solicitors wrote to the Respondent. This letter included the following paragraph:The purpose of this letter is to request that the time for reconsideration of the previous determination be extended for a further 30 days in order that we can obtain an up to date report of our client’s injury and for submissions to be made for reconsideration of your previous determination.[3]A medical report dated 18 November 2014 relating to Mr Hasan’s worsening medical condition, said to have arisen from the 2007 injury, was enclosed.[4][3] Exhibit R1 at 93.[4] Exhibit R1 at 95. On 17 May 2016, Mr Hasan’s solicitors wrote to the Respondent as follows:We act for Eddy Hasan.We refer to previous correspondence, a copy of which is enclosed should it had [sic] gone astray.We refer to our letter dated 6 April 2016 and we would be pleased to have a reply.[5] (Original emphasis.) [5] Exhibit R1 at 104. On 14 September 2016, Mr Hasan’s solicitors wrote to the Respondent, in part, as follows:We refer to the telephone conversation between Cassandra and Mr Peter Ives of this office on 13 September 2016 and confirm that we act for the abovenamed employee.We note that we sent a letter to you on 6 April 2016 and a follow up letter of 16 May 2016 and we note your comment that these were not received and that the last letter you received from a solicitor acting for Mr Hasan was from his previous solicitors, Brydens.…The purpose of this letter is to request that the time for reconsideration of the previous determination be extended, in order that the present medical condition of Mr Hasan be considered and that the terms of the determination be favourable to Mr Hasan in order that weeklies be paid, medical expenses be paid and that he be entitled for lump sum assessment.[6]Additional medical reports relating to Mr Hasan’s condition were enclosed. [6] Exhibit R1 at 113.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 20 September 2016, the Respondent refused Mr Hasan’s request for additional time in which to seek a reconsideration of the determination. For the purposes of this application, this refusal is the reviewable decision. Mr Hasan has applied to the Tribunal for review of the reviewable decision. For the reasons which follow, the reviewable decision will be affirmed. This means that the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to review the determination denying liability to compensate Mr Hasan, in respect of the injury he claims to have suffered, as the Respondent has not conducted its own review of the determination.LEGISLATION Subsection 88(1) of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) provides that:Application may be made to the [Tribunal] by a claimant for review of a reviewable decision.Reviewable decision is defined in section 76 to mean a decision made under section 78. Relevantly, a decision to refuse an extension of time in which to request that an initial determination of a claim be reconsidered is a decision made under section 78, and thus a reviewable decision.[1][1] See my decision in the previous interlocutory application in this matter: Hasan and Inco Ships Pty Ltd [2018] AATA 15. Section 78(3) deals with the time in which an application for reconsideration of a determination is to be made. It reads as follows:(3) A request for reconsideration of a determination must:(a)set out the reasons for the request; and(b)be given to the employer within 30 days after the day on which the determination first came to the notice of the claimant, or within such further period (if any) as the employer, either before or after the end of that 30 day period, allows.BACKGROUNDMr Hasan’s claim and the Respondent’s response Mr Hasan claims that he was injured in the employ of the Respondent on board a merchant ship as it was docking in the Port of Melbourne on 7 October 2007. He reported the incident to the First Mate a short time later. On 18 October 2007, Mr Hasan lodged with the Respondent a claim for workers’ compensation in respect of the alleged injury. On 12 December 2007, the Respondent made a determination denying liability in respect of the claim. A notice of determination, which included a statement of reasons, was sent to Mr Hasan by email, courier and express post on 14 December 2007. There is a dispute between the parties as to whether Mr Hasan received any of these communications. For reasons set out later, I am satisfied that Mr Hasan received at least one of them.[2][2] Exhibit R1 at 6-7. Mr Hasan acknowledges that he did receive a copy of the notice of determination in 2012, when it was given to him by the solicitor acting for him at the time. At various times since 2012, Mr Hasan has instructed a number of solicitors to act for him in respect of his compensation claim. Correspondence between the parties’ solicitors On 6 April 2016, Mr Hasan’s solicitors wrote to the Respondent. This letter included the following paragraph:The purpose of this letter is to request that the time for reconsideration of the previous determination be extended for a further 30 days in order that we can obtain an up to date report of our client’s injury and for submissions to be made for reconsideration of your previous determination.[3]A medical report dated 18 November 2014 relating to Mr Hasan’s worsening medical condition, said to have arisen from the 2007 injury, was enclosed.[4][3] Exhibit R1 at 93.[4] Exhibit R1 at 95.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The following issues arise for determination:(1) Did the letter dated 13 June 2017 from the Respondent’s solicitors notify Mr Hasan of a decision which is reviewable by the Tribunal? a. If it did, it is not in dispute that the application for review of this decision was made within time and the matter can proceed to be determined by the Tribunal in the normal manner.(2) If it did not, should the time in which Mr Hasan may request a reconsideration of the decision of 12 December 2007 be extended?CONSIDERATIONIssue 1: Did the letter dated 13 June 2017 from the Respondent’s solicitors notify Mr Hasan of a decision which is reviewable by the Tribunal?Mr Hasan’s argument It was argued on behalf of Mr Hasan that:·his solicitors’ letter of 19 May 2017 was a request under subsection 78(2) of the Act for a reconsideration of the determination of 12 December 2007;·this request set out the reasons for the request as required by subsection 78(3)(a);·in responding to the reasons advanced, by their letter of 13 June 2017 the Respondent’s solicitors notified Mr Hasan of a decision, affirming the determination, made under subsection 78(6);[12]·as the decision notified in the letter of 13 June 2017 was made under section 78, it is a reviewable decision as defined in subsection 76(1);·an application may be made to this Tribunal for review of a reviewable decision under subsection 88(1) of the Act; ·the application for review was lodged in the Tribunal on 20 July 2017, within the time required by section 29 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) as modified by subsection 89(3) the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act.[13][12] Pursuant to section 87of the Act.[13] The time in which the application to the Tribunal was to be made was within 60 days of Mr Hasan receiving notification of the reviewable decision.Discussion In their letter of 20 September 2016 the Respondent’s solicitors stated clearly the Respondent’s position that it had no obligation to reconsider the 2007 determination made almost nine years prior. Notwithstanding this clear statement of the Respondent’s position, Mr Hasan’s solicitors repeated the request for reconsideration eight months later on 19 May 2017. The Respondent’s solicitors’ reply of 13 June 2017 did respond to the reasons for reconsideration put forward on behalf of Mr Hasan. However, this response must be read in the context of the letter in its entirety. It is clear from the responses given that the Respondent’s solicitors remained steadfast in their view that the matter should proceed no further. Then, in the penultimate paragraph they repeated the statement that their client had no obligation to reconsider the determination. The Respondent has consistently maintained the view that it is not obliged to reconsider its determination, and a fair reading of the letter of 13 June 2017 leads only to the conclusion that the Respondent had not changed its position and that it maintained its refusal to reconsider the determination.