Administrative Appeals Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2010] AATA 733
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No 2009/1834
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re ADAM HARVEY Applicant
And
CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Miss E A Shanahan, Member Date27 September 2010
PlaceMelbourne
Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decisions under review and substitutes its decision that the applicant does not and never has suffered from epilepsy. He has had one provoked episode of neurocardiogenic syncope. He is to undergo a tilt test for vasodepressor neurocardiogenic syncope. If this test is negative a Class 1 and/or 2 medical certificate is to be issued to enable him to pursue licencing as a pilot. If the test is positive, medical certification must be denied. .................[signed]...................
Member
CIVIL AVIATION – Civil Aviation Regulations – denied medical certification at Class 1 or Class 2 – medical history of episodes of loss of consciousness – recent syncopal attack – expert opinion precludes a diagnosis of epilepsy and cardiac cause for syncope – decision varied
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 37, 42D
Civil Aviation Safety Act 1988 (Cth) ss 9A, 11
Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) regs 67.015, 67.150, 67.155, 67.190
Associated Provincial Picture Houses v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223
Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for Civil Service [1985] AC 374
Re Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21
Re Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2006] AATA 452; [2007] AATA 1952; [2009] AATA 171
Re Window and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [1999] AATA 525
REASONS FOR DECISION
27 September 2010 Miss E A Shanahan, Member 1. This matter was heard on 10 December 2009 and remitted to the Respondent under s 42D of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act) with the directions that the Respondent obtain the Applicant’s entire medical records from the three hospitals in which he had been treated and having examined these records reconsider its decision in light of the content of these records. These records were eventually received. In one instance a hospital administrator had provided only those parts of the records she thought relevant. At the Tribunal’s instruction the entire record was forwarded. Further delay was experienced by the unavailability of Dr Fitzgerald and Dr Navathe in March 2010. The resumed hearing took place on 5 July 2010.
2. Mr Harvey has been denied medical Class 1 and/or Class 2 certification by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) based on three medical events over an eight and a half year period wherein he was observed to have transient lowering of his conscious state. He has been extensively investigated and the opinions of three Neurologists, one Neurosurgeon and a Cardiologist obtained. With one exception the specialist opinions are that Mr Harvey is fit to hold a Class 1 and 2 certificate.
3. CASA’s prime role in the medical certification of pilots is to protect the public and air navigation as a whole. The criteria for certification…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read HARVEY and CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] AATA 733
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal examined whether the applicant's medical history warranted the denial of a medical certificate. This involved assessing the nature of the episodes of loss of consciousness, the recent syncopal attack, and whether these events precluded a diagnosis of epilepsy or a cardiac cause for syncope. The Tribunal also considered the recommendations of expert medical opinions, which did not support a diagnosis of epilepsy or a cardiac cause for the syncope.
The Tribunal found that the applicant did not and never had suffered from epilepsy, and that he had experienced a provoked episode of neurocardiogenic syncope. Given the uncertainty surrounding the vasodepressor type of syncope, the Tribunal ordered a tilt test to be conducted. If the test is negative, a Class 1 and/or 2 medical certificate is to be issued, allowing the applicant to pursue licencing as a pilot. If the test is positive, medical certification must be denied.
The Tribunal set aside the decisions under review and substituted its decision regarding the applicant's medical certification. The applicant is to undergo a tilt test for vasodepressor neurocardiogenic syncope, with outcomes determining the issuance of a Class 1 and/or 2 medical certificate.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal sets aside the decisions under review and substitutes its decision that the applicant does not and never has suffered from epilepsy. He has had one provoked episode of neurocardiogenic syncope. He is to undergo a tilt test for vasodepressor neurocardiogenic syncope. If this test is negative a Class 1 and/or 2 medical certificate is to be issued to enable him to pursue licencing as a pilot. If the test is positive, medical certification must be denied.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as an appeal against the decisions of CASA. The Tribunal reviewed CASA's decision to deny the applicant's medical certification. The Tribunal's review was based on evidence presented by both parties, including expert medical opinions and the applicant's medical history. The Tribunal considered whether the applicant had suffered from epilepsy, whether the syncopal episode had a cardiac cause, and what medical tests were required to determine the applicant's fitness to hold a Class 1 or Class 2 medical certificate.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the applicant has suffered from epilepsy.
2. Whether the syncopal episode experienced by the applicant was caused by a cardiac condition.
3. What medical tests are necessary to determine the applicant's eligibility for a Class 1 and/or Class 2 medical certificate.
Held
1. The court concluded that the applicant does not and never has suffered from epilepsy.
2. The court found that the syncopal episode experienced by the applicant was caused by a provoked episode of neurocardiogenic syncope.
3. The court ordered that the applicant must undergo a tilt test for vasodepressor neurocardiogenic syncope. If the test is negative, a Class 1 and/or 2 medical certificate is to be issued. If the test is positive, medical certification must be denied.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including expert opinions and medical reports. The court accepted the expert opinion that the applicant does not and never has suffered from epilepsy, as there was no evidence to support this diagnosis. The Tribunal noted that the syncopal episode was not attributable to a cardiac condition, but rather to neurocardiogenic syncope. The decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority to deny the medical certification was varied based on these findings. The court applied the principle that medical certification decisions should be based on the most current and accurate medical evidence available. The ratio decidendi is that an applicant’s medical history and recent episodes of loss of consciousness need to be thoroughly evaluated, and decisions must be made based on the latest medical findings. The Tribunal departed from the prior decisions by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority, which had not adequately considered the most recent medical evidence and expert opinions.