Hartley v Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL PANEL
CITATION: Hartley v Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation [2023] NSWPICMP 354

APPELLANT:

Lynette Hartley

RESPONDENT: Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation
Appeal Panel
MEMBER: Richard Perrignon
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: John Baker
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Nicholas Glozier
DATE OF DECISION: 26 July 2023
CATCHWORDS: 

wORKERS cOMPENSATION - Appeal from assessment of whole person impairment (psychological); whether Medical Assessor erred in assessing concentration persistence and pace; Held – Medical Assessment Certificate confirmed.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO APPEAL

  1. The appellant worker appeals from the Medical Assessment Certificate of Medical Assessor Smith dated 2 February 2023.

  2. The Medical Assessor assessed a 7% whole person impairment (psychological) as a result of injury on 1 February 2018 (deemed date). In doing so, he assessed a class 2 impairment in respect of the psychiatric impairment rating scale, Concentration, persistence and pace.

  3. Ms Hartley alleges demonstrable error and the application of incorrect criteria with respect only to the assessment of Concentration, persistence and pace. She says that the evidence supported a class 3 impairment.

  4. She relies on a supplementary statement dated 2 March 2023, in which she gives evidence of what was said at examination on 17 January 2023, taking issue with the correctness or completeness of what the Medical Assessor recorded. The statement was prepared after the issue of the Medical Assessment Certificate on 2 February 2023. Leave to rely on it is opposed.

  5. The Appeal Panel conducted a preliminary review of the Medical Assessment Certificate in the absence of the parties and in accordance with the NSW Workers Compensation Guidelines for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (4th edition) (the Guidelines).

Submissions

  1. The parties made written submissions which have been taken into account. They are summarised below.

  2. The appellant worker submits as follows:

    (a)    the Medical Assessor failed to take into account that fact that she has to wake early on workdays to prepare herself mentally, as explained in her statement dated 15 September 2022 at [5];

    (b)    he failed to take into account the fact that she uses a notebook and pen at work to aid memory and that she forgets why she has gone into a classroom, as she explained to Dr Prior on 19 July 2022;

    (c)    the Medical Assessor correctly recorded that she may not read more than half a paragraph of a book. This is inconsistent with a class 2 impairment;

    (d)    when he recorded that there was nothing on television that she liked, he omitted her explanation for that, which was that ‘she could not follow the story line due to her inability to concentrate’. In doing so, he omitted to have regard to relevant evidence.

    (e)    the Medical Assessor failed to have regard to her explanation that she no longer knits due to difficulties in concentrating. Those difficulties, and her inability to follow storylines in TV shows, are consistent with a class 3 impairment;

    (f)    the Medical Assessor incorrectly recorded that the worker completed a Certificate III and Certificate IV course. In fact, she has only completed the latter, in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hartley v Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICMP 354
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Ms Hartley, appealed the decision of the respondent, the Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation, regarding the assessment of her whole person impairment (psychological) under the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The dispute was heard in the Dust Diseases Tribunal of New South Wales. The primary issue before the court was whether the Medical Assessor erred in assessing Ms Hartley's concentration, persistence, and pace. Specifically, the court needed to determine if the supplementary statement provided by Ms Hartley was admissible as fresh evidence and whether it demonstrated a demonstrable error in the Medical Assessment Certificate.

The court considered the statutory provisions under s 328(3) of the Act, which limit the admissibility of fresh evidence on appeal. The appellant's supplementary statement aimed to correct perceived inaccuracies in the Medical Assessor's report. However, the court found that this evidence was not fresh or unavailable before the assessment, as it relied on Ms Hartley's recollection of events that could not have been reasonably obtained beforehand. Additionally, the supplementary statement contradicted the Medical Assessment Certificate without independent support, failing to meet the criteria for substantial prima facie probative value or plausibility as outlined in Lukacevic v Coates Hire Operations Pty Limited. Consequently, the court determined that the supplementary statement did not demonstrate a demonstrable error in the assessment.

As a result, the court upheld the Medical Assessment Certificate and dismissed the appeal. The tribunal found that the supplementary statement did not satisfy the legal requirements for admissibility, and therefore, the grounds of appeal relying on it were not considered. The decision confirmed the assessment of Ms Hartley's whole person impairment as determined by the Medical Assessor.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

With respect to the evidence contained in her supplementary statement of 2 March 2023, the appellant’s submissions do not address the requirements of s 328(3) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. They are as follows:“Evidence that is fresh evidence or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the medical assessment appealed against may not be given on an appeal by a party to the appeal unless the evidence was not available to the party before that medical assessment and could not reasonably have been obtained by the party before that medical assessment.” Her supplementary statement purports to correct the history recorded by the Medical Assessor in four respects:(a) Ms Hartley did not complete both Certificate III and IV courses as recorded: she only completed a Certificate IV course over 6 months in the latter half of 2018;(b) she was not employed at TAFE for one day per week, but rather for 1.5 hours per week;(c) she told the Medical Assessor that there was nothing on television that interested her because she loses track and does not follow the story. She did not say there was nothing on television she liked, and(d) when asked about reading and knitting, she replied, “I used to knit but I can’t concentrate anymore. I don’t do any of the hobbies that I used to”. This response was not recorded in the Medical Assessment Certificate. Evidence as to what transpired at examination is not evidence that could reasonably have been obtained before examination. However, it is not evidence that is capable of proving demonstrable error, because it relies on evidence other than that contained in the Medical Assessment Certificate itself and the referral document: Merza v Registrar of the Workers Compensation Commission & Anor [2006] NSWSC 939. It is not relevant to the issue of demonstrable error. With respect to an allegation that incorrect criteria have been applied, it is relevant to consider whether the statement has substantial prima facie probative value, plausibility and/or independent support: Lukacevic v Coates Hire Operations Pty Limited [2011] NSWCA 112 per Hodgson JA [at 78]. There is no independent support for the evidence. The evidence contradicts the report of the Medical Assessor, and is therefore not supported by it. Accordingly, while we do not dismiss the evidence, we are not in a position to find that it has ‘substantial’ prima facie probative value or plausibility. It does not satisfy the test in Lukacevic. There is also a public interest in the finality of litigation, which admitting this evidence will not serve. In the absence of a reply from the Medical Assessor, there are issues of procedural fairness, which admitting the evidence will not satisfy: Lukacevic at [111]. In all the circumstances, we are not persuaded that it should be admitted. For those reasons, it is unnecessary to consider the grounds of appeal which rely on the supplementary statement. They are set out in [7(d)] to [7(g)] above.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.