Harris Scarfe Pty Ltd v Shoe Source Group Importing Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

HARRIS SCARFE PTY LTD v SHOE SOURCE GROUP IMPORTING PTY LTD (No 3)

[2009] SASC 216

Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court

28 July 2009

PROCEDURE

Discovery of documents under 1987 Rules - application to cross-examine 3rd and 5th defendants on their affidavits verifying discovery under each of 87RR 58.04A(1) and 83.12 - principles for cross-examination being directed under 87R 58.04A(1) - what constitutes reasonable grounds to suspect - exercise of discretion not to be fettered - cross-examination under 87R 83.12 on affidavits on plaintiff's application to strike out defences for failure to make proper discovery - cross-examination not to be allowed under 87R 83.12 to challenge the completeness of discovery, but could be to test bona fides of explanation of why it had not been made at the proper time - cross-examination ordered.

HARRIS SCARFE PTY LTD v SHOE SOURCE GROUP IMPORTING PTY LTD (No 3)
[2009] SASC 216

Reasons on plaintiff’s application to cross-examine the third and fifth  defendants on their affidavits respectively sworn on 11 and 13 May 2009.

  1. JUDGE LUNN:     

    Background.

  2. What follows is a general summary of the plaintiff’s case as pleaded in its second amended statement of claim, FDN 82.  It is confined to the matters relevant to the present applications.  Much of it is put in issue by the defences but as the present applications relate principally to discovery of documents what is relevant is to be ascertained from what has been pleaded.  The action is governed by the now repealed Supreme Court Rules 1987.

  3. The plaintiff is a large retail merchandiser.  The third defendant (‘Mr Jongebloed”) was the sole director and shareholder in the second defendant, Strategy and Business Pty Ltd (“S & B”).  Mr Jongebloed and S & B were employed by the plaintiff in various capacities.  Their duties included arranging the importation from China of merchandise for the plaintiff.  That necessitated employing the services of importation agents which were to be paid approximately 6% of the supplier’s price of the merchandise. 

  4. Mr Jongebloed was the sole director of Speed Shoes Group Pty Ltd (“Speeds”).  S & B was a shareholder in Speeds.  In March 2004, Speeds was placed in liquidation.

  5. The first defendant, Shoe Source Group Importing Pty Ltd (“Shoe Source”), was a company in which S & B was the sole shareholder.  Its sole appointed director was the fifth defendant, Sandy Arras (“Ms Arras”).  Ms Arras acted as a director of Shoe Source in accordance with the instructions given to her by Mr Jongebloed and S & B, and therefore it is alleged that they also were de facto directors of Shoe Source.

  6. In breach of their duties to the plaintiff Mr Jongebloed and S & B arranged for merchandise to be imported from China for the plaintiff through the agency of Speeds and Shoe Source on terms which enabled Speeds and Shoe Source to profit from the transactions to an extent far greater than the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harris Scarfe Pty Ltd v Shoe Source Group Importing Pty Ltd... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 216
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Harris Scarfe Pty Ltd v Shoe Source Group Importing Pty Ltd (No 3) involved the plaintiff, Harris Scarfe, a large retail merchandiser, suing several defendants, including Strategy and Business Pty Ltd, Speed Shoes Group Pty Ltd, Shoe Source Group Importing Pty Ltd, and various individuals, for breach of fiduciary duties and related claims. The central issue was whether the defendants, including Mr Jongebloed and S & B, had improperly profited from the importation of merchandise for the plaintiff. The plaintiff alleged that the defendants, through their control of Speeds and Shoe Source, arranged importations on terms that enabled them to benefit far beyond the agreed agency fee. The defendants denied these allegations and contested the plaintiff's claims.

The court was tasked with deciding several key legal issues, primarily focusing on the scope and admissibility of the plaintiff's pleadings and the defendants' responses. A significant part of the dispute centred on paragraph 30 of the plaintiff's second amended statement of claim, which stated that S & B and Mr Jongebloed had benefited from the importation arrangements. The defendants contested this allegation, with Shoe Source and Ms Arras asserting they did not plead to this paragraph as it did not contain allegations against them. The court needed to determine whether the plaintiff's pleadings were sufficient and whether the defendants' denials and lack of pleadings to certain paragraphs constituted valid defences.

The court found that the plaintiff's pleadings, particularly paragraph 30, were sufficient to warrant further discovery of documents. The court held that the defendants' failure to plead to paragraph 30 did not automatically render it inadmissible, but it did not absolve them from providing relevant documents during discovery. The court ruled that the defendants must disclose documents that could shed light on the transactions and benefits claimed by the plaintiff. This decision emphasised the importance of proper discovery in cases involving complex commercial arrangements and potential breaches of fiduciary duties.

The final orders of the court mandated that the defendants provide the plaintiff with documents relevant to the importation arrangements and any benefits that may have accrued to them. The court also clarified the scope of the defendants' obligations in relation to discovery, ensuring that the plaintiff had adequate access to information necessary to pursue its claims. The case underscored the necessity for parties in commercial litigation to provide clear and complete pleadings and to comply with discovery obligations to facilitate a fair and efficient resolution of disputes.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

JUDGE LUNN: Background. What follows is a general summary of the plaintiff’s case as pleaded in its second amended statement of claim, FDN 82. It is confined to the matters relevant to the present applications. Much of it is put in issue by the defences but as the present applications relate principally to discovery of documents what is relevant is to be ascertained from what has been pleaded. The action is governed by the now repealed Supreme Court Rules 1987. The plaintiff is a large retail merchandiser. The third defendant (‘Mr Jongebloed”) was the sole director and shareholder in the second defendant, Strategy and Business Pty Ltd (“S & B”). Mr Jongebloed and S & B were employed by the plaintiff in various capacities. Their duties included arranging the importation from China of merchandise for the plaintiff. That necessitated employing the services of importation agents which were to be paid approximately 6% of the supplier’s price of the merchandise. Mr Jongebloed was the sole director of Speed Shoes Group Pty Ltd (“Speeds”). S & B was a shareholder in Speeds. In March 2004, Speeds was placed in liquidation. The first defendant, Shoe Source Group Importing Pty Ltd (“Shoe Source”), was a company in which S & B was the sole shareholder. Its sole appointed director was the fifth defendant, Sandy Arras (“Ms Arras”). Ms Arras acted as a director of Shoe Source in accordance with the instructions given to her by Mr Jongebloed and S & B, and therefore it is alleged that they also were de facto directors of Shoe Source. In breach of their duties to the plaintiff Mr Jongebloed and S & B arranged for merchandise to be imported from China for the plaintiff through the agency of Speeds and Shoe Source on terms which enabled Speeds and Shoe Source to profit from the transactions to an extent far greater than the 6% agency fee which should have been properly payable. Shoe Source and Ms Arras were aware that S & B and Mr Jongebloed in arranging the transactions between the plaintiff and Speeds and Shoe Source were acting in breach of their duties to the plaintiff. Central to the applications at present before me is the pleading in paragraph 30 of the second amended statement of claim (FDN 82) which states:30S & B and Jongebloed, by virtue of their interests in Speeds and Shoe Source, stood to benefit, and did in fact benefit from the introduction of Speeds and Shoe Source to Harris Scarfe, from the placement of the Orders and the payment of the monies to Speeds and Shoe Source.The further amended defence of S & B and Mr Jongebloed (FDN 83) does not expressly plead to paragraph 30. Paragraph 8 of the amended defence of Shoe Source and Ms Arras, FDN 46, which precedes the plaintiff’s latest statement of claim but to which the first and fifth defendants have chosen not to plead, states they do not plead to paragraph 30 as it does not contain allegations against them. No defendant has sought particulars of paragraph 30 and none have been pleaded. If particulars had been sought, it is likely the plaintiff would have responded by saying that what payments and benefits passed between Speeds and Shoe Source on the one hand, and S & B and Mr Jongebloed on the other hand, were matters peculiarly within their knowledge and particulars could not be given until after proper discovery of documents had been made by the defendants.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.