JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM: COMMERCIAL & CIVIL
ACT: STRATA TITLES ACT 1985
CITATION: HAROLD & GLADYS VERRYT and ANN WILLIAMS [2005] WASAT 101
MEMBER: MR C RAYMOND (SENIOR MEMBER)
HEARD: 17 MARCH 2005
DELIVERED : 11 MAY 2005
FILE NO/S: CC 19 of 2005
BETWEEN: HAROLD & GLADYS VERRYT
Applicant
AND
ANN WILLIAMS
Respondent
Catchwords:
Real property - Strata titles - Alteration of lot without notice to strata company - Whether alternations in keeping with rest of the building - Meaning of "in keeping with"
Legislation:
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 39(e)
Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA), s 3AB, s 7, s 21, s 83, s 103G
Result:
Application successful in part
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Applicant: Mr D Verryt
Respondent: Mr R Griffiths
Solicitors:
Applicant:
Respondent: Griffiths & Godecke
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Strata Plan No 464 v Oborn NSW Strata Titles Cases 1979-90
Case(s) also cited:
Nil
MR C RAYMOND (SENIOR MEMBER):
REASONS FOR DECISION
Issue
The issue for determination is whether alterations made to the respondent's property are in breach of the strata company's rules and whether an order should be made that the property be reinstated by the respondent to its former condition.
Strata Plan and Parcel
The applicants and respondent are proprietors of Lot 1 and Lot 2 respectively shown on Strata Plan 17152.
The Strata Plan was registered on 20 March 1989. There is no notification on the register of any amendment, repeal or additional bylaws and pursuant to s 42 of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) ("the Act") the provisions set out in Sch 1 and Sch 2 of the Act are deemed to be the bylaws of the strata company.
The parcel comprises only of the said Lots 1 and 2. Each lot comprises of the buildings shown on the plan and external areas as shown.
By virtue of the operation of s 21I and s 21M of the Act, no notice of resolution having been registered under s 21H nor any objection having been lodged under s 21O, s 3AB of the Act operates to determine the boundaries of the lots. The boundaries thereunder are the external surfaces of the buildings and in relation to any common or party wall, the centre plane of the wall. As noted on the Strata Plan except where covered, the stratum of Lot 1 and Lot 2 external to the buildings extends between 5m below and 10m above the floor surface level of the building on Lot 1.
The Application and Hearing
The applicants made application to the State Administrative Tribunal ("the Tribunal") on 7 January 2005 seeking an order: "to reinstate the premises to as they were before the unauthorised and nonsanctioned works were carried out". The grounds stated for the order were:
"In breach of Sch 2 bylaws 13 and 14."
On the same date an interim application was lodged signed by Mr D Verryt, the applicants' son, on behalf of the applicants. On 12…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Harold & Gladys Verryt and Ann Williams and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] WASAT 101
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal considered whether the respondent's alterations constituted a structural change to the property, which would require prior notice to the strata company. The applicants argued that the external side door and security door constituted a structural alteration, while the respondent claimed the sliding security door was fitted in the same opening as the previous external window/sliding door. However, the applicants conceded that the alterations did not cause any significant inconvenience or detriment, rendering the issue of structural alteration moot. The Tribunal then turned to whether the changes breached the requirement to obtain written consent from the strata company if the changes were visible from outside the lot and not in keeping with the rest of the building.
The Tribunal found that no written consent was obtained from the strata company, and the work was visible from outside the lot. The term "in keeping with" was interpreted to mean "in harmony with" and not "not to clash," as argued by the respondent. The Tribunal emphasised that the extent of similarity required in a strata unit development is subjective and should be determined by the body corporate. The photographic evidence provided by the parties was sufficient for the Tribunal to determine that the respondent's alterations did not comply with the requirement to be in keeping with the rest of the building.
The Tribunal found that the respondent's alterations breached the strata bylaws and ordered the respondent to remove the alterations and pay the applicants' costs. The Tribunal exercised its power under section 83 of the Strata Titles Act to make an order for the settlement of the dispute. The final orders included the removal of the alterations and the payment of costs by the respondent to the applicants.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
At Schedule 2:"13. Notice of alteration to lotA proprietor of a lot shall not alter the structure of the lot except as may be permitted and provided for under the Act and the bylaws and in any event shall not alter the structure of the lot without giving to the strata company, not later than 14 days before commencement of the alteration, written notice describing the proposed alteration.14. Appearance of lotA proprietor, occupier or other resident of a lot shall not, without the written consent of the strata company, maintain within the lot anything visible from outside the lot that, viewed from outside the lot, is not in keeping with the rest of the building." The only part of the works which the applicants contended constituted a structural alteration to the respondent's lot was the external side door and security door (issues 5 and 6). Mr Griffiths for the respondent disputed that the work constituted structural works. The respondent's evidence was that the sliding security door was fitted in the same opening as the previous external window/sliding door. It is not necessary to make any determination in respect of this because, during closing submissions, Mr D Verryt conceded that the alteration did not result in any significant inconvenience or detriment to the applicants. The effect of this concession was that it was also not necessary to consider whether there had been a breach of r 13 because the relief sought is that the works be restored to their original condition, and that order cannot be made by virtue of s 103G(4)(b). The concession made is patently correct and I am satisfied the work done will not cause any significant inconvenience or detriment to the applicants. The only remaining issue was whether or not the changes made were a breach of r 14 and whether in consequence of the dispute relating thereto, the Tribunal should exercise its power under s 83 to make an order for the settlement of the dispute. It is common cause that no written consent was obtained from the strata company in accordance with r 14. Thus, if the work undertaken by the respondent is visible from outside of the lot and is not in keeping with the rest of the building, a breach of that rule has occurred. I am satisfied that a consideration of the photographic evidence provided by the parties is sufficient to enable me to come to the correct and preferable decision without the need of a view or other evidence. The Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, 5th ed., 2002 defines "in keeping with" as meaning … "in harmony with". Harmony, in turn, is defined to mean "Combination or adoption of parts, elements or related things so as to form a consistent and orderly whole." Mr Griffiths for the respondent contended that "in keeping with" should be taken to mean "not to clash". In my view, that is too wide a definition, and the words should be given their ordinary grammatical meaning as set out above. Nevertheless, the judgement of whether there exists a consistent and orderly combination of elements as a whole is subjective. In the context of a strata unit development, it does not mean that every unit must be identical. The extent to which similarity in appearance is required will vary from one development to the next. This is for the body corporate, acting within its powers, to decide.