Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd [2024] FCA 639

File number(s): ACD 1 of 2023
Judgment of: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 12 June 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where applicant previously worked for respondent and had access to respondent’s confidential information / intellectual property – where applicant seeks redactions to discovered documents – where parties are competing trade rivals – where some evidence applicant used respondent’s confidential information – where redacted documents necessary for respondent to prosecute cross-claim – balancing of competing interests – order for unredacted documents to be provided to respondent’s legal advisors and independent expert only, with liberty for the respondent to apply in the event it is contended that disclosure of some of the redacted material is necessary
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 37M(1)(b)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 20.32

Cases cited:

Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Lundbeck Australia Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1358

AstraZeneca AB v Medis Pharma Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 549

Division: General Division
Registry: Australian Capital Territory
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 27
Date of hearing: 12 June 2024
Counsel for the Applicant / First and Second Cross-Respondents: Dr A Greinke
Solicitor for the Applicant / First and Second Cross-Respondents: Mills Oakley
Counsel for the Respondent / Cross-Claimant: Mr D Robens
Solicitor for the Respondent / Cross-Claimant: Joseph Tallarita

ORDERS

ACD 1 of 2023
BETWEEN:

HARLECH ENTERPRISES PTY LTD

Applicant / First Cross-Respondent

BENJAMIN PETER MOSELEY
Second Cross-Respondent

AND:

BENO EXCAVATIONS PTY LTD

Respondent / Cross-Claimant

ORDER MADE BY:

THAWLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 JUNE 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory application lodged on 8 March 2024 be dismissed.

2.The cross-respondents pay the cross-claimant’s costs.

3.The cross-respondents produce for inspection, in electronic form if required by the cross-claimants, the documents in Part 1 of the list of documents dated 19 December 2023 by 14 June 2024 in two forms:

a.unredacted form for inspection only by the cross-claimant’s legal advisors and independent expert(s); and

b.redacted form for inspection by the cross-claimants.

4.The respondent / cross-claimant file and serve its evidence on the cross-claim and the principal claim by 26 July 2024.

5.The applicant / cross-respondents file and serve their evidence in response on the cross-claim and any evidence in reply in the principal claim by 30 August 2024.

6.Reserve liberty to the cross-claimant to apply in the event that the cross-claimant contends it requires disclosure of parts of the documents produced for inspection under order 3(a) hereof to its clients to obtain proper instructions.

7.The matter be listed for a case management hearing at 9:30am on 2 September 2024.


8.These orders be entered forthwith.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(Revised from transcript)

THAWLEY J

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 23 December 2022, the applicant (Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd) commenced this proceeding against the respondent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 639
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Harlech Enterprises Pty Ltd v Beno Excavations Pty Ltd, the Federal Court was tasked with resolving a dispute between two competing companies. Harlech Enterprises, the applicant, had previously employed an individual who had access to Beno Excavations' confidential information and intellectual property. Beno Excavations, the respondent, sought redactions to the discovered documents due to concerns that Harlech might use the confidential information for their own benefit, particularly in winning tenders for projects. The court was required to balance the competing interests of both parties, considering the necessity for Beno to access unredacted documents to effectively prosecute its cross-claim against Harlech.

The court considered the principles of confidentiality in commercial litigation and the implied undertaking that parties must only use discovered documents for the purposes of the proceedings. Given the competitive nature of the parties, the court recognised the potential for misuse of sensitive information. The onus was on Beno to establish the confidentiality of the information and the necessity for redactions or non-disclosure. The court noted that the discovered documents were essential for Beno to obtain instructions from its client and properly prosecute its claim. After considering the arguments, the court determined that a balanced approach was necessary, which involved allowing Beno to inspect unredacted documents but only through their legal advisors and an independent expert, while reserving the right for Beno to apply for further disclosure if necessary.

The court ordered that the interlocutory application be dismissed, and the cross-respondents were required to produce the documents in two forms: unredacted for inspection by the cross-claimant’s legal advisors and independent expert, and redacted for inspection by the cross-claimants. Beno was also granted liberty to apply for disclosure of parts of the unredacted documents if needed to obtain proper instructions. The court set specific deadlines for filing evidence and scheduled a case management hearing to further manage the proceedings.

These orders aimed to protect Beno's confidential information while ensuring that it could adequately pursue its cross-claim against Harlech. The court's decision highlighted the need to balance the interests of commercial competitors in litigation, particularly when sensitive information is at stake.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application lodged on 8 March 2024 be dismissed.

2. The cross-respondents pay the cross-claimant’s costs.

3. The cross-respondents produce for inspection, in electronic form if required by the cross-claimants, the documents in Part 1 of the list of documents dated 19 December 2023 by 14 June 2024 in two forms:

a. unredacted form for inspection only by the cross-claimant’s legal advisors and independent expert(s); and

b. redacted form for inspection by the cross-claimants.

4. The respondent / cross-claimant file and serve its evidence on the cross-claim and the principal claim by 26 July 2024.

5. The applicant / cross-respondents file and serve their evidence in response on the cross-claim and any evidence in reply in the principal claim by 30 August 2024.

6. Reserve liberty to the cross-claimant to apply in the event that the cross-claimant contends it requires disclosure of parts of the documents produced for inspection under order 3(a) hereof to its clients to obtain proper instructions.

7. The matter be listed for a case management hearing at 9:30am on 2 September 2024.

8. These orders be entered forthwith.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Bencic stated she had a concern that Mr Moseley had used Beno’s “documents to win tenders for projects”. She stated that Beno relies on work from the councils surrounding the ACT in regional areas and that, over the last few years, Beno had undertaken pipework in Wagga Wagga, Albury, Wingecarribee Shire and other places in and outside of the ACT. She stated:[10]I have the details of the tender documents and contract prices that Benex was using when Mr Moseley left and took that information. Benjamin Moseley had access to that pricing information and our QA documents when he was working for Benex. Without knowing the prices that he used to tender for the projects, and the prices that were included in the contracts, I will not be able to effectively compare the projects to see where he used our information, and our pricing, for his own benefit.[11]I understand that the documents produced in court proceedings should not be used for any other reason. I have no intention to use the pricing information for any reason but to compare what has occurred. Our current projects are priced based on the costs that we know are within our business plus a competitive margin.CONSIDERATION Parties to proceedings are subject to an implied undertaking only to use documents obtained on discovery for the purposes of the proceedings – see: Harman v Secretary of State for the Home Department [1983] 1 AC 280 and Hearne v Street [2008] HCA 36; 235 CLR 125 at [1]. In the majority of situations, this implied undertaking provides a party required to produce documents on discovery with sufficient protection from misuse of the documents. However, that is not always the case. Where parties to litigation are commercial competitors, for example, the producing party may legitimately be concerned about the damage to its commercial interests by the disclosure of sensitive business information which, once disclosed, cannot realistically be forgotten by a trade competitor. There is a risk that such information might be used, even subconsciously. The onus of establishing confidentiality, and the necessity or desirability of the making of an order for redactions or non-disclosure, is on the party making the claim: Alphapharm Pty Ltd v Lundbeck Australia Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1358 at [17] (Lindgren J); AstraZeneca AB v Medis Pharma Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 549 at [10] (Besanko J). The question of whether a claim for confidentiality should be upheld or refused involves a balancing of the competing interests of the parties. Some of the relevant considerations were referred to in AstraZeneca at [10]. Harlech’s principal case was that production of the discovered documents should not occur until after the affidavit evidence was complete. Harlech also proposed an alternative regime whereby the documents be provided in unredacted form to an independent expert, conceding that the documents will at least be required to allow Beno to commission expert evidence regarding damages. Beno’s solicitors opposed production only after affidavit evidence was filed and submitted that the discovered documents, including those in respect of which redactions were sought, were required to obtain instructions from their client as to each of the contracts for which Harlech successfully tendered. During argument at the hearing, however, counsel for Beno accepted that a permissible way forward would be for unredacted versions of the documents to be provided in the first instance to Beno’s legal representatives and the independent expert or experts, reserving liberty to apply in the event that some form of disclosure was required in order for Beno to obtain instructions or otherwise properly to prosecute its claim.