Hargreaves and Telstra Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

[2013] AATA 579

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/3899, 2012/4454

Re

Dale Hargreaves

APPLICANT

And

Telstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance

Date 16 August 2013 
Place Melbourne

Application 2011/3899

The reviewable decision made by Telstra on 23 August 2011 that from 9 December 2007 it was not liable to pay compensation to Ms Hargreaves under sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), is set aside.

The matter is remitted to Telstra for reconsideration in accordance with the following directions:

(1)       during the whole of the period from 9 December 2007 to, and including, the date of this decision, Ms Hargreaves has been totally incapacitated for work as a result of the injury suffered by her on 14 December 2006;

(2) Telstra is liable to pay compensation to Ms Hargreaves in respect of the injury in accordance with section 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth);

(3) Telstra is liable to pay to Ms Hargreaves compensation in accordance with section 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) upon Ms Hargreaves providing proper evidence of the costs incurred by her.

Within 14 days of the date of this decision each party may apply to the Tribunal for further directions in relation to costs. Should such an application not be made, the respondent shall pay the costs of this application incurred by the applicant, such costs to be agreed or taxed in accordance with the Tribunal's Practice Direction.

Application 2012/4454

The reviewable decision made by Telstra on 28 September 2012 that it is not liable to pay to Ms Hargreaves  compensation in accordance with section 24 and section 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) is affirmed.

........................[sgd]................................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – adjustment disorder with depression and anxiety – whether applicant partially or totally incapacitated for work as a result of injury – whether applicant incurred costs for medical treatment – whether injury resulted in permanent impairment – decision under review in application 2011/3899 set aside – decision under review in application 2012/4454 affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4(1), 16, 19, 24, 27

CASES

Hargreaves and Telstra Corporation Limited [2011] AATA 417

REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Hargreaves commenced work with Telstra Corporation Limited in 1997. In late 2006 she developed an adjustment disorder following an earlier physical injury suffered by her while she was at work.  In these reasons I will refer to the adjustment disorder as “the injury”.

  2. Ms Hargreaves sought compensation for the injury in accordance with the provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). Telstra denied liability to pay compensation. It was not until 2011 that an application to review Telstra’s decision came before this Tribunal for hearing. The Tribunal decided that Telstra was liable to compensate Ms Hargreaves.

  3. Very shortly after the Tribunal’s decision, Telstra decided that Ms Hargreaves had recovered from the injury in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hargreaves and Telstra Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 579
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision concerns an appeal by Telstra Corporation Limited against decisions of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding Ms Hargreaves' claim for workers' compensation. Ms Hargreaves, who worked for Telstra from 1997 until October 2007, suffered a shoulder injury in August 2006, which subsequently led to an adjustment disorder with anxiety and depression. The Tribunal previously ruled that Telstra should pay Ms Hargreaves' medical expenses and compensation for periods where her ability to earn was less than her normal weekly earnings. The central issues in this case were whether Ms Hargreaves was partially or totally incapacitated for work from 9 December 2007 due to the injury and whether she incurred costs for medical treatment.

The Tribunal assessed multiple medical reports and testimonies to determine Ms Hargreaves' current incapacity and medical costs. Reports indicated varying opinions on her work capacity and the impact of her injury. While some reports suggested that her condition was due to work-related stressors, others attributed her incapacity to the initial shoulder injury and subsequent pain and disability. The Tribunal found that since 9 December 2007, Ms Hargreaves had been totally incapacitated for work due to the injury. It also concluded that Telstra should pay for her incurred medical costs, provided she submits proper evidence.

The Tribunal set aside Telstra's decision that it was not liable to pay compensation to Ms Hargreaves from 9 December 2007, affirming that she has been totally incapacitated for work since that date and should receive compensation. Conversely, it affirmed Telstra's decision that it was not liable to pay compensation under sections 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The Tribunal directed Telstra to reconsider its liability for compensation in light of the new findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which follow this decision of Telstra will be affirmed.EVIDENCE AND FINDING OF FACTS Unless stated otherwise the following findings of fact are based on the evidence of Ms Hargreaves, including the evidence she gave to the Tribunal in the previous proceedings.[1][1] A transcript of evidence in the previous proceedings is Exhibits R25, R26 and R27. Ms Hargreaves worked continuously for Telstra from 1997 until October 2007. During 2006 she worked from home two days per week. In August 2006 and in October 2006 she injured her left shoulder while working at home. She subsequently suffered the injury to which I have referred and which has been described as an “adjustment disorder with anxiety and depression secondary to her left shoulder injury to which her employment contributed to a material degree …” [2] In the previous proceedings the Tribunal determined that the date of the injury was 14 December 2006. Further the Tribunal decided that Telstra pay to Ms Hargreaves all medical and related treatment expenses incurred in respect of the injury and weekly payments of compensation in respect of all periods in which her ability to earn was less than her normal weekly earnings.[2] This was the decision of this Tribunal in a previous application by Ms Hargreaves; see Exhibit R18, p.19. In October 2007 Ms Hargreaves’ employment was terminated by Telstra. In late December 2007 Ms Hargreaves met with several associates with whom she had dealings while employed by Telstra. Following this meeting Ms Hargreaves agreed to become a director of Global Software as a Service Pty Ltd which operated a business known as Global SaaS. Ms Hargreaves does not have a clear recollection of the events of this period. She does recall experiencing “an overwhelming sense of shame, guilt and embarrassment.”[3] At the time she was living in Queensland.[3] Exhibit A1 para.90. In about March 2007, Global SaaS opened an office. Ms Hargreaves attended monthly meetings by Skype, discussed strategies, reviewed commercial agreements and tested software. This was not regular work and she did not perform any meaningful work at this time. Ms Hargreaves tried to work to the best of her capacity. She suffered panic attacks and became easily overwhelmed and tearful during meetings. She was not paid for the work she did. In about November 2008, the board of the company offered Ms Hargreaves an operational role with the business. This role included the management of four staff, although not all of those staff came under Ms Hargreaves’ supervision until January 2009. Ms Hargreaves did not receive payment for this work.[4][4] Ms Hargreaves’ evidence that she was not paid is confirmed by a statement of the Mr Langford, a director of Global Software as a Service Pty Ltd – Exhibit A3. During this time Miss Hargreaves suffered acute anxiety attacks brought on by associations with her previous employment by Telstra. She became increasingly depressed, however she ceased seeing her psychiatrist, her psychologist and her general practitioner. She also ceased taking medication. She said that the reason for this was that she could not afford the expense. She was not receiving any compensation payments at this time.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

When he gave evidence Dr Strauss confirmed the opinion set out above. He agreed that Ms Hargreaves was “overwhelmed by legal matters.”Evidence of Associate Professor Mendelson, Consultant Psychiatrist and Consultant in Pain Medicine Professor Mendelson assessed Ms Hargreaves in 2012 at the request of the solicitor for Telstra. He provided a report dated 14 May 2012[25] and gave evidence.[25] Exhibit R1. In his report Professor Mendelson stated:I agree with Dr Reddan that Miss Hargreaves probably did have clinically significant depressive and anxiety symptoms during the early part of 2007, and that the diagnosis of an Adjustment Disorder With Mixed Anxiety and Depressed Mood would have been appropriate at that time. It would appear that once Miss Hargreaves’s employment with Telstra was terminated in October 2007 and she received a redundancy package there was a gradual improvement in her emotional state, so that by the time she was assessed by Dr Reddan in early December 2008 she was working full time and no longer had the symptoms of a diagnosable mental disorder.…It would appear that due to a subsequent disappointment in relation to the company that she was involved in setting up there had been a recurrence of emotional symptoms, and Miss Hargreaves decided to move to Victoria and to live on the property owned by her mother and stepfather.In my opinion at present Miss Hargreaves shows the characteristics of what has been termed “chronic embitterment”, the features of which have been described as anger, rumination, helplessness and appraisals of injustice. Chronic embitterment is not a diagnosis, but rather a specific type of an emotional response to a particular type of an adverse life experience.…While I do not have adequate information on which I could base a definitive opinion concerning Miss Hargreaves’s work capacity as at 9 December 2007, the information available to me strongly suggests that at this time she did have the capacity to perform her usual work duties for between 20 and 35 hours per week.[26]In his oral evidence Professor Mendelson said that the condition from which Ms Hargreaves now suffers would qualify as a diagnosis of an Adjustment Disorder with Anxiety.[27][26] Exhibit R1 pp 17-19.[27] Transcript 25/06/13 p.8. When he gave evidence Professor Mendelson confirmed the opinions he had expressed in his report. Whilst he maintained his view that Ms Hargreaves did have capacity to work in December 2007, he was also of the opinion that “because the venture in which he was involved apparently had not been successful this had caused a recurrence or aggravation of the emotional difficulty she was experiencing and that really had continued up until the time that [he] saw her.”[28][28] Transcript 25/06/13 p.6. Counsel for Telstra argued that I should accept the opinions of Professor Mendelson and Dr Varghese that factors such as the failure of Global SaaS and Ms Hargreaves' sense of loss of “family” when she ceased working for Telstra, caused her incapacity for work after 9 December 2007. It was put further that Ms Hargreaves' dissatisfaction with the method by which her claim for compensation has been dealt with contributed to her present condition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This issue does not arise for determination.CONCLUSION IN RESPECT OF EACH APPLICATIONApplication 2011/3899 The reviewable decision made by Telstra on 23 August 2011 that from 9 December 2007 it was not liable to pay compensation to Ms Hargreaves under sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), will be set aside. The matter will be remitted to Telstra for reconsideration in accordance with the following directions:(1)during the whole of the period from 9 December 2007 to, and including, the date of this decision, Ms Hargreaves has been totally incapacitated for work as a result of the injury suffered by her on 14 December 2006;(2)Telstra is liable to pay compensation to Ms Hargreaves in respect of the injury in accordance with section 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth);(3)Telstra is liable to pay to Ms Hargreaves compensation in accordance with section 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) upon Ms Hargreaves providing proper evidence of the costs incurred by her. Within 14 days of the date of this decision each party may apply to the Tribunal for further directions in relation to costs. Should such an application not be made, the respondent shall pay the costs of this application incurred by the applicant, such costs to be agreed or taxed in accordance with the Tribunal's Practice Direction.Application 2012/4454 The reviewable decision made by Telstra on 28 September 2012 that it is not liable to pay to Ms Hargreaves compensation in accordance with section 24 and section 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) will be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The following issues arise for determination.(1)Since 9 December 2007, has Ms Hargreaves been partially or totally incapacitated for work as a result of the injury, and if so, for what period or periods?(2)Since 9 December 2007, has Ms Hargreaves incurred any costs for medical treatment in relation to the injury that was reasonable for her to obtain in the circumstances?CONSIDERATION OF THE ISSUESIssue 1: Since 9 December 2007, has Ms Hargreaves been partially or totally incapacitated for work as a result of the injury, and if so, for what period or periods? Telstra concedes that Ms Hargreaves is incapacitated for work at present and that this situation is unlikely to change unless she receives further treatment. However Telstra says that such incapacity as she has suffered since 9 December 2007 has been caused by factors which are not the result of her injury. Telstra does not concede that Ms Hargreaves has been totally incapacitated for work during the whole of this time.Report of Dr Cross, Registrar Ms Hargreaves commenced consulting Dr Cross in January 2007. In a report dated 13 June 2007, Dr Cross stated her opinion that the deterioration in Ms Hargreaves’ mental health was “due largely to stressors in the workplace environment.”[13][13] Exhibit R10.Report of Dr Varghese, Psychiatrist Dr Varghese assessed Ms Hargreaves on behalf of Telstra in August 2007, at which time she was living in Queensland. In his opinion, at that time Ms Hargreaves was suffering from Adjustment Disorder with mixed Anxiety and Depressed Mood to which “work related factors” contributed.[14][14] Exhibit R11.Report of Dr Apel, Psychiatrist Ms Hargreaves was assessed by Dr Apel in February 2008 at the request of her solicitors. He provided a report dated 23 June 2008.[15][15] Exhibit R14. At the time of the assessment Dr Apel diagnosed Ms Hargreaves as suffering Adjustment Disorder with Depressed and Anxious Mood. As to the cause of the development of Ms Hargreaves' condition, Dr Apel reported that “I would see her pre-existing personality vulnerabilities as being one-third responsible for developing her psychiatric condition. The other two thirds are the shoulder injury itself, and her subsequent pain and disability, and the management response to this.”[16][16] Exhibit R14 p.9.Report of Dr Reddan, Consultant Psychiatrist Dr Reddan assessed Ms Hargreaves in December 2008 at the request of the solicitors for Telstra. He provided a report dated 15 February 2009.[17][17] Exhibit R16. In the opinion of Dr Reddan, it was likely that in the early part of 2007 Ms Hargreaves had developed an Adjustment Disorder with Mixed Anxiety and Depressed Mood to which work-related factors made a major contribution. However it was his view that at the time of the assessment Ms Hargreaves was not suffering from a diagnosable condition and the effects of any work-related condition had ceased.[18] [18] Exhibit R16 p.12.Reports of Dr Uebergang, Forensic & Counselling Psychologist