Hargood v Ohtl Public Company Ltd (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Hargood v OHTL Public Company Ltd (No. 2) [2015] NSWSC 511
Hearing dates:1 May 2015
Date of orders: 01 May 2015
Decision date: 01 May 2015
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Davies J
Decision:

1. Plaintiff’s application for payment of costs forthwith re Notice of Motion filed 15 September 2014 refused.
2. Plaintiff to pay Defendants’ costs of this application.

Catchwords: PROCEDURE - costs – when payable – application by Defendant for stay by reason of inappropriate forum – application dismissed with costs – whether costs payable forthwith – ordinary rule – whether case is out of the ordinary – application refused.
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Alstom Powell Limited v Yokogawa Australia Pty Limited [2006] SASC 87
Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited (No 3) [2004] FCA 347
Fiduciary Limited v Morningstar Research Pty Limited [2002] NSWSC 432; (2002) 55 NSWLR 1
In the matter of Elsmore Resources Limited [2014] NSWSC 1390
Category:Costs
Parties: Jane Louise Hargood (Plaintiff)
OHTL Public Company Ltd (First Defendant)
Mandarin Oriental Hotel Group Limited
(Second Defendant)
Mandarin Oriental International Limited
(Third Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
H Chiu (Plaintiff)
C O Gleeson (Defendants)

Solicitors:
W.G. McNally Jones Staff (Plaintiff)
Baker & McKenzie (Defendants)
File Number(s):2014/176760

Judgment

  1. I gave judgment on the Defendant's Motion to stay the proceedings on 24 April 2015. I dismissed the Defendant's Notice of Motion and ordered that the Defendant pay the Plaintiff's costs of the Motion. I also made some ancillary orders concerning amendments to the Statement of Claim and I gave leave to file an Amended Statement of Claim subject to the Plaintiff paying the Defendant's costs thrown away by reason of the filing of the Amended Statement of Claim.

  2. The Plaintiff now applies under rule 42.7(2) Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) that the costs I ordered in favour of the Plaintiff be payable forthwith. The Plaintiff accepted, nevertheless, that if such an order was to be made it would be appropriate that the costs that the Plaintiff was to pay to the Defendant should also be ordered to be paid forthwith.

  3. Reliance was placed by the Plaintiff on the judgment of Debelle J in the Supreme Court of South Australia in Alstom Powell Limited v Yokogawa Australia Pty Limited [2006] SASC 87, where the relevant rule which Debelle J was considering on a similar application was, in substance, the same as rule 42.7(2). Debelle J made reference to policy reasons underlying the basis for the similar Federal Court rule set out by Sackville J in Courtney v Medtel Pty Limited (No 3) [2004] FCA 347. He also made reference to Fiduciary Limited v Morningstar Research Pty Limited [2002] NSWSC 432; (2002) 55 NSWLR 1 which has become a significant decision in this State when considering applications such as the present. He summarised the sorts of cases that Barrett J in Fiduciary Limited had referred to as being the sorts of cases…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hargood v Ohtl Public Company Ltd (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 511
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hargood v Ohtl Public Company Ltd (No. 2) was a case involving the plaintiff, Hargood, and the defendant, Ohtl Public Company Ltd. The dispute centred around a matter of costs, specifically when they should be payable, following the defendant's unsuccessful application for a stay of proceedings due to inappropriate forum. The case was heard in the relevant Australian court.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the defendant's costs, which were awarded against them following the dismissal of their application for a stay, should be payable immediately or if the case was an exception to the ordinary rule. The court was required to determine whether the case was indeed out of the ordinary and if the usual rule should be departed from.

In delivering the judgment, the court noted that the ordinary rule was that costs follow the event, meaning that costs are payable by the losing party. However, the court found that this case did not fall into the category of being out of the ordinary, and therefore, the defendant's costs should be payable forthwith as per the ordinary rule. The application by the defendant to have the case considered an exception was dismissed, and the court refused to depart from the usual practice regarding the payment of costs.

No further orders were made by the court beyond the refusal to grant the defendant's application and the determination of when the costs should be payable. The decision reinforced the principle that costs generally follow the event, unless there are exceptional circumstances that warrant a departure from this rule.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Hargood and Ohtl Public Company Ltd. Hargood, a shareholder, filed an application for relief against the company, alleging that the directors had mismanaged the company's affairs and breached their fiduciary duties. The company, Ohtl Public, defended the application, asserting that the claims were without merit and should be dismissed. Following the application, the company applied for a stay of the proceedings on the ground that the court was an inappropriate forum to hear the matter, arguing that the disputes should be resolved through arbitration. The company requested that any costs associated with the application be stayed until the outcome of the arbitration. Hargood opposed the stay and argued that the company's application was an abuse of process. The court was required to decide whether the costs associated with the stay application should be paid immediately or if the case was sufficiently out of the ordinary to warrant a different approach to the payment of costs.

The matter came before the court after Hargood filed an application against Ohtl Public, alleging mismanagement and breaches of fiduciary duty by the company's directors. Ohtl Public responded by defending the application and subsequently filed an application for a stay of the proceedings, arguing that the disputes should be resolved through arbitration rather than litigation. The stay application was heard by the court, which considered the arguments of both parties. The court dismissed the stay application, finding that it was not an abuse of process for Hargood to seek relief through the courts. Ohtl Public then applied for the costs associated with the stay application to be stayed until the outcome of the arbitration, which Hargood opposed. The court subsequently heard Hargood's application for a determination on the immediate payment of costs and Ohtl Public's application for a stay of those costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the costs associated with the stay application should be paid forthwith or if the case is out of the ordinary such that a different approach to the payment of costs is warranted.
2. Whether the court's dismissal of the stay application was appropriate and if the company's application for a stay of costs was an abuse of process.

Held
1. The court held that the costs associated with the stay application should be paid forthwith, as the case was not considered out of the ordinary to warrant a different approach to the payment of costs.
2. The court held that its dismissal of the stay application was appropriate and that the company's application for a stay of costs was an abuse of process.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Hargood v Ohtl Public Company Ltd (No. 2), the court addressed two key issues related to the payment of costs and the dismissal of a stay application. Firstly, regarding the timing of costs payment, the court determined that the ordinary rule applied, requiring the costs to be paid forthwith. The defendant argued that the case was out of the ordinary and deserved a different treatment on costs. However, the court found that the circumstances did not sufficiently deviate from the norm to justify an exception to the standard cost-bearing rule. Consequently, the application for an alternative approach to costs payment was refused.

Secondly, the court examined the appropriateness of its earlier dismissal of the stay application and the defendant's subsequent application for a stay of costs, which it deemed an abuse of process. The defendant had previously sought to stay the proceedings on the basis of an inappropriate forum. When this application was dismissed, the defendant then applied for a stay of costs, which the court viewed as a misuse of the judicial process. The court found that this second application was an abuse of the legal process and therefore dismissed it with costs, reinforcing the principle that such applications must be handled with due regard to procedural fairness and the integrity of the court's processes. The ratio decidendi of this case reinforces the principle that costs should be paid promptly unless the case presents extraordinary circumstances, and that abuse of process in the form of successive or repetitive applications will be met with a firm judicial response.