Hardy v Motor Accidents Insurance Board

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Hardy v Motor Accidents Insurance Board [2024] NSWPIC 354
CLAIMANT: Adam Neville Hardy
INSURER: Motor Accidents Insurance Board of Tasmania
SENIOR MEMBER: Brett Williams
DATE OF DECISION: 4 July 2024
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act); application for exemption by insurer; application opposed by claimant; where insurer has alleged contributory negligence and that claimant has made false and misleading statements; Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Tarabay, Insurance Australia Limited t/as NRMA Insurance v Banos, Insurance Australia Limited t/as NRMA Insurance Limited v Milton, Insurance Australia Limited t/as NRMA v Taylor, IAG Ltd t/as NRMA Insurance v Abiad, IAG Limited t/as NRMA Insurance v Khaled & Ors and IAG Ltd t/as NRMA v Qianxia Lou applied; Held – the insurer’s allegations should be tested under oath in a forum in which the Evidence Act 1995 applies; a court hearing is the mode of hearing that will resolve the dispute more efficiently and effectively; claim not suitable for assessment; recommendation that the claim be exempt from assessment; recommendation subsequently approved by the Division Head, as the President’s delegate.

BACKGROUND

  1. Adam Hardy (claimant) was injured in a motor accident on the Pacific Highway at Heatherbrae on 27 September 2020 (accident). He subsequently made a claim for damages on the Motor Accidents Insurance Board (insurer) under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act). Liability for the claim has been admitted. Contributory negligence of 33% has been  alleged.

  2. The claimant has referred his claim to the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) for assessment under s 7.32 of the MAI Act. At a preliminary conference conducted on


    8 April 2024, the insurer applied to have the claim exempted from assessment in accordance with s 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act (application for exemption).

  3. The application for exemption was made by the insurer in the course of the general assessment of the claim, a course that was open to either party: cl 17 Procedural Direction MA5 (PDMA5). I dispensed with the requirement for the insurer to lodge an application for exemption and for the claimant to lodge a reply, as otherwise required by cl 17 PDMA5, and directed the parties to lodge bundles containing the submissions and evidence on which they rely for the purposes of the application for exemption.

ON THE PAPERS

  1. At the 8 April 2024 preliminary conference the parties were informed that I proposed to make a preliminary assessment of the claim for the purposes of s 7.34(1)(b) on the papers. There was no objection from either party to me proceeding in this way.[1]

    [1] The claimant’s submissions dated 3 June 2024 record that, subject to any conclusion by me that it would “be helpful to have a further [preliminary] conference to discuss issues arising” from his submissions, he has no objection to the application being determined on the papers.

  2. Having considered both s 52 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (PIC Act) and Procedural Direction PIC2, I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hardy v Motor Accidents Insurance Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPIC 354
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hardy v Motor Accidents Insurance Board involves a dispute between the claimant, Hardy, and the insurer, Motor Accidents Insurance Board (MAIB), regarding an application for exemption from assessment of a motor accident injury claim. The application was lodged under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. Hardy opposed the application, citing allegations of contributory negligence and false or misleading statements made by the claimant. The court was required to determine whether the claim was suitable for assessment under Rule 99 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 and to consider the objects of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2002.

The court addressed the legal issues by examining the objects of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2002, which aim to enable the Commission to resolve the real issues in proceedings justly, quickly, cost effectively, and with as little formality as possible. The court also considered Rule 99, which allows for an exemption from assessment if the claim involves complex legal or factual issues, issues of liability, or allegations of false or misleading statements. The court found that the insurer's allegations should be tested under oath in a forum in which the Evidence Act 1995 applies. Given the complexity of the allegations and the need for a thorough examination of the evidence, the court concluded that a court hearing would resolve the dispute more efficiently and effectively.

The court determined that the claim was not suitable for assessment because it involved complex legal and factual issues, including contributory negligence and allegations of false or misleading statements. The court recommended that the claim be exempt from assessment, a recommendation that was subsequently approved by the Division Head, acting as the President’s delegate. This decision was made in line with the guiding principle to facilitate the just, quick, and cost-effective resolution of the real issues in the proceedings. The court's reasoning was based on the need for a formal hearing to adequately test the insurer's allegations and ensure a just outcome.

The final orders were that the claim should be exempt from assessment and that the matter should proceed to a court hearing to determine the issues of liability and the validity of the insurer's allegations. The court emphasized the importance of a formal hearing to properly assess the evidence and provide a just resolution to the dispute.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claimant, Hardy, made a claim for injuries sustained in a motor accident. The insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, opposed the claim and applied for exemption from assessment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act). The insurer alleged that the claimant had contributed to the accident through negligence and made false or misleading statements regarding his injuries, loss, or damage. Surveillance footage and images were provided as evidence, capturing the claimant’s activities post-accident. The claimant argued that the footage did not reflect his daily life and living conditions, given his reported constant pain and mental health struggles. He also admitted to being aware of being followed by an investigator and making genuine attempts to disclose his condition when seeing doctors.

On 8 April 2024, the parties were directed to provide evidence bundles relevant to the exemption application. The insurer was required to submit its bundle by 23 April 2024, while the claimant had until 11 June 2024. Both parties complied with this direction, providing their respective bundles. Surveillance footage and images were also provided. The claimant addressed several matters in his statement dated 25 April 2024, including his gym activities post-accident, his ongoing pain, and his mental health. The Commission considered all the material submitted and evaluated the surveillance footage and images.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claim involves complex legal or factual issues that make it unsuitable for assessment.
2. Whether the claim involves issues of liability, including contributory negligence.
3. Whether the insurer's allegations that the claimant made false or misleading statements are substantiated.
4. Whether the claim should be exempt from assessment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

Held
1. The court concluded that the claim involves complex legal or factual issues, including contributory negligence and false or misleading statements made by the claimant. As a result, the claim was deemed unsuitable for assessment.
2. The court found that the claim involves issues of liability, including contributory negligence and allegations of false or misleading statements.
3. The court held that the insurer's allegations that the claimant made false or misleading statements need to be tested under oath in a forum in which the Evidence Act 1995 applies, such as a court hearing.
4. The court recommended that the claim be exempt from assessment under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, and this recommendation was subsequently approved by the Division Head, as the President’s delegate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Rule 99 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (Rules) applies to the application, and is in the following terms:“99 Consideration of discretionary exemption from claims assessment(1) A claimant or insurer may apply for an exemption from assessment under section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act by lodging an application.(2) In determining whether a claim is not suitable for assessment for the purposes of section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act, the Commission must consider the objects of the PIC Act and the circumstances of the claim.(3) Without limiting the matters that may be considered, the Commission may consider the following—(a) whether the claim involves complex legal or factual issues, or complex issues in the assessment of the amount of the claim,(b) whether the claim involves issues of liability, including contributory negligence, fault or causation,(c) whether a claimant or witness, considered by the Commission to be a material witness, resides outside the State,(d) whether a claimant or insurer seeks to proceed against one or more non-CTP parties,(e) whether the insurer alleges that a person has made a false or misleading statement in a material particular in relation to the injuries, loss or damage sustained by the claimant in the accident giving rise to the claim.” PDMA5 applies to the application. As recorded earlier, I have dispensed with a number of requirements under the Procedural Direction. In determining whether the claim is not suitable for assessment I must consider the objects of the PIC Act. Those objects include, relevantly, to enable the Commission to resolve the real issues in proceedings justly, quickly, cost effectively and with as little formality as possible. The guiding principle for the PIC Act and the Rules, in their application to proceedings in the Commission, is to facilitate the just, quick and cost effective resolution of the real issues in the proceedings. The Commission must seek to give effect to the guiding principle when it exercises any power given to it by the PIC Act or the Rules, or interprets any provision of the Act or the Rules: s 42(2). On 8 April 2024 the parties were directed to provide bundles containing the evidence they each rely on with respect to the exemption application; the insurer by 23 April 2024 and the claimant by 11 June 2024. Bundles were subsequently provided. Surveillance footage and images were also provided. The bundles contain material relevant to both the contributory negligence allegation and the allegation that the claimant has made false or misleading statements. I have considered all material contained in the bundles, and have viewed and evaluated the surveillance footage and images. In his statement dated 25 April 2024, the claimant addresses a number of matters, including his gym activity pre and post-accident. He states that since the accident he has continued going to the gym, but has had to modify the exercise he performs and the weight he lifts. He also addresses the surveillance footage, in particular the footage of him with his dog and a friend. He states that the footage doesn’t “show what [his] life is like” living with his injuries, and refers to constant pain in his neck and right shoulder. He describes struggling with his mental health, and provides details of the medication he takes. The claimant also states that he was aware he was “being followed by an investigator during 2023”, and that he had made “genuine attempts” each time he saw a doctor for his claim.