Hardy & Hardy v Barberien No. DCCIV-00-614

Link copied
Case Copied 67 min read

Susan Francis Hardy & Matthew Rohan Hardy
v John Barberien
[2003] SADC 51

Civil
Judge David Smith

Introduction

  1. In this action the first named plaintiff claims damages against the defendant for personal injuries and consequential losses caused by a motor vehicle collision which occurred near Gladstone on the 24th May 1997.  The second plaintiff, who is the husband of the first, claims damages for the loss of consortium of his wife.  Both liability and quantum are in issue.  The action is subject to the constraints of s35A of the Wrongs Act, 1936.  Section 35A was repealed by s4 of the Wrongs (Liability and Damages for Personal Injury) Amendment Act 2002, which came into operation on 1st December 2002. However s35A still applies in this action because the accident, the subject of this claim, occurred before the commencement of the new provisions (see ss6 and 7 of the said repealing Act.)

    Issues – contentions

  2. The predominant question in the trial was who was responsible for the collision?  It took place on Main North Road on the southern outskirts of Gladstone.  The first plaintiff turned her Sigma sedan to the left onto Main North Road from a side road, proceeded north a short distance and then having indicated, commenced turning to the right onto another side road.  The defendant, who was driving a Camry sedan, drove up behind her and was in the process of overtaking when the Sigma commenced turning right and so the collision occurred.  The plaintiffs contend that the collision was wholly the responsibility of the defendant whose vehicle approached the scene at an excessive speed and overtook when it was dangerous to do so.  The defendant’s response is that the first plaintiff failed to obey the give way sign and that the overtaking manoeuvre was undertaken in an effort to avoid a collision.  There is an alternative plea of contributory negligence in the defence.

  3. As to quantum, the first plaintiff alleges that she suffered soft tissue injuries to the cervical and lumbar spine and a right shoulder injury.  Further, she alleges a number of psychological detriments, including a post-traumatic stress disorder.  She contends that the injuries have caused persisting pain and discomfort, have diminished her earning capacity and have impaired her relationship with her husband.  In response, the defendant contends that the first plaintiff’s claimed injuries and disabilities are not as severe as contended for and that some of the complaints pre-date the collision.  The defendant also denies that the second plaintiff has suffered a loss of his wife’s consortium.

  4. I will deal first of all with liability.  I set out the applicable legal principles.

    Legal principles

  5. It is trite law that a breach of statutory provisions such as the now repealed but then applicable s63 of the Road Traffic Act is not “the be all and end all” of civil responsibility.  In the case of Sibley v Kais (1967) 118 CLR 424 the High Court said at 427:

    “Therefore, it is, in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hardy & Hardy v Barberien No. DCCIV-00-614 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SADC 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties in this case were Susan Francis Hardy and Matthew Rohan Hardy, who were seeking damages against John Barberien for a motor vehicle collision that occurred on 24 May 1997 near Gladstone. The first plaintiff claimed damages for personal injuries and consequential losses, while the second plaintiff claimed damages for the loss of consortium of his wife. Both liability and quantum were in issue. The action was subject to the constraints of s35A of the Wrongs Act, 1936, which was repealed by s4 of the Wrongs (Liability and Damages for Personal Injury) Amendment Act 2002 but still applied to this action because the accident occurred before the commencement of the new provisions. The predominant issue in the trial was who was responsible for the collision, with the plaintiffs contending that the collision was wholly the responsibility of the defendant, who was driving at an excessive speed and overtook when it was dangerous to do so. The defendant's response was that the first plaintiff failed to obey the give way sign, and that the overtaking manoeuvre was undertaken in an effort to avoid a collision. There was also an alternative plea of contributory negligence in the defence. The court found that the defendant was 80% at fault and the first plaintiff was 20% at fault. The court also found that the first plaintiff suffered soft tissue injuries to the cervical and lumbar spine and a right shoulder injury, as well as psychological detriments, including a post-traumatic stress disorder. The defendant denied that the first plaintiff's claimed injuries and disabilities were as severe as contended for and that some of the complaints pre-dated the collision. The defendant also denied that the second plaintiff had suffered a loss of his wife's consortium. The court found that the first plaintiff was entitled to damages for non-economic loss, past loss of earnings, future loss of earnings, special damages, and future medical expenses. The court also found that the second plaintiff was entitled to damages for past loss of consortium and future loss of wife's consortium. The court awarded the first plaintiff $139,704.40, which included interest, and the second plaintiff $7,534.00, which also included interest. The court will hear the parties as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.