SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil)
HANSSEN v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA & ORS (No 2)
[2019] SASC 90
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley
3 June 2019
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS
Application for costs in relation to two interlocutory applications.
On 12 April 2019 this Court granted permission to the plaintiff to amend his second statement of claim. As a result, the Commonwealth discontinued its application pursuant to Supreme Court Rule (SCR) 211 seeking a preliminary hearing of the application for an extension of time within which to bring the proceedings.
The Commonwealth seeks that the plaintiff pay its costs thrown away by reason of the amendments, its costs of the application to amend and its application pursuant to SCR 211. The plaintiff does not oppose an order for costs thrown away but opposes the remaining orders sought. The plaintiff seeks that his costs of the application to amend, the SCR 211 application and the supporting affidavits filed by the Commonwealth be paid by the plaintiff.
Held:
1. The plaintiff is to pay the Commonwealth its costs thrown away by reason of the amendments to the plaintiff’s second statement of claim permitted by the orders of the Court on 12 April 2019.
2. The plaintiff is to pay the costs of and incidental to the plaintiff’s application to amend the second statement of claim.
3. The plaintiff is to pay the costs of the Commonwealth’s application pursuant to SCR 211 save and except half the costs of the supporting affidavit of Rodger James Prince affirmed 30 August 2018.
Supreme Court (Civil) Rules 1987 (SA) r 211, r 263(1), r 263(2); Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) s 48; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 40, referred to.
Raedel & Raedel v Shahin (No.2) [2018] SASC 119, applied.
HANSSEN v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA & ORS (No 2)
[2019] SASC 90Civil.
STANLEY J: The Commonwealth brought an application pursuant to Supreme Court Rule (SCR) 211 for a separate trial of the issue whether the plaintiff could establish that he had ascertained a material fact within the meaning of s 48 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) (LTA). The plaintiff brought an application to amend his statement of claim to replead the material facts alleged. On 12 April 2019 I granted permission to the plaintiff to make the amendment as sought. As a result, the Commonwealth no longer pressed the SCR 211 application. The Commonwealth now seeks an order that the plaintiff pay its costs thrown away by reason of the amendments to the second statement of claim. The plaintiff does not oppose such order.
The Commonwealth also seeks orders that the plaintiff pay its costs of the application to amend the second statement of claim and its application filed pursuant to SCR 211. The plaintiff opposes these orders. He seeks the costs of the application to amend, the SCR 211 application and the costs of the supporting affidavits filed by the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hanssen v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] SASC 90
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the relevance and necessity of the material contained in the Prince affidavit and the corresponding exhibits. It found that a significant portion of the affidavit and its exhibits was irrelevant and excluded half the costs associated with the Prince affidavit from the costs order. The court concluded that the plaintiff should bear the costs thrown away by the amendments to the second statement of claim, the costs of the application to amend the second statement of claim, and the Commonwealth's costs for the application under Supreme Court Rule 211, except for half the costs of the Prince affidavit.
The court's reasoning focused on the proportionality and relevance of the costs sought by the Commonwealth. By excluding half the costs of the Prince affidavit, the court demonstrated a careful consideration of the expenses incurred. The court's final orders reflect a balanced approach to the costs incurred due to the plaintiff's amendments and the Commonwealth's efforts to manage the proceedings. The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the Commonwealth's costs thrown away by reason of the amendments, the costs of the application to amend the second statement of claim, and the Commonwealth’s application under Supreme Court Rule 211, except for half the costs of the Prince affidavit.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Commonwealth submitted an affidavit from Rodger James Prince on 30 August 2018, detailing the costs and expenses incurred due to the amendments in the plaintiff's statement of claim. This affidavit included numerous exhibits, many of which the court found to be either irrelevant or not pertinent to the legal issues at hand. The court noted that approximately half of the affidavit's content and exhibits related to matters deemed irrelevant, leading to a significant portion of the costs being contested. The plaintiff's amendments and subsequent legal actions resulted in the Commonwealth filing applications to recover the costs incurred.
The court's decision to exclude half of the costs associated with the Prince affidavit stemmed from the belief that these parts were irrelevant to the proceedings. The judge concluded that Hanssen should bear the costs thrown away by reason of the amendments to the second statement of claim and the costs related to the plaintiff’s application to amend the second statement of claim. However, the Commonwealth's application under SCR 211 was partially successful, as the court ordered Hanssen to pay only half of the costs of the Prince affidavit, reflecting the judge's view on the relevance of the affidavit's contents.
The case of Hanssen v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) has undergone several procedural steps prior to reaching this stage. The matter originally arose as a first-instance hearing in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, where the plaintiff, Hanssen, filed a claim against the Commonwealth. Following initial filings, the plaintiff sought amendments to the second statement of claim, which were subsequently permitted by the Court on 12 April 2019. This led to the Commonwealth filing an application under Supreme Court Rule 211, seeking costs associated with the amendments. The plaintiff also filed an application related to the amendments, setting the stage for the procedural history that would ensue.
During the course of these proceedings, the Commonwealth filed a supporting affidavit by Rodger James Prince, which included extensive material, a portion of which was deemed irrelevant by the Court. The plaintiff's procedural efforts continued with applications and responses that necessitated detailed examination of costs and procedural fairness. Ultimately, the Court made interlocutory orders that shaped the financial and procedural landscape of the case. The matter was thus prepared for a final determination of costs, with specific rulings on the admissibility and relevance of the evidence presented, particularly focusing on the affidavit of Rodger James Prince.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced its analysis by determining the appropriate amount of costs to be awarded to the Commonwealth for the amendments to the plaintiff's second statement of claim. The court acknowledged the plaintiff's entitlement to amend their pleadings as a matter of right, subject to certain judicial controls. However, the court held that the amendments made were unnecessary and vexatious, leading to a waste of the Commonwealth's resources. Consequently, the court awarded costs to the Commonwealth for the amendments made to the plaintiff's second statement of claim.
The court then considered whether the plaintiff should be ordered to pay the costs of and incidental to their application to amend the second statement of claim. The court found that the plaintiff's application to amend the statement of claim was made without sufficient justification, and as such, the plaintiff should bear the costs of the application. The court relied on the principle that parties should not be permitted to make unnecessary amendments to their pleadings, and that the costs of such amendments should be borne by the party seeking to make them.
Next, the court addressed the issue of whether the plaintiff should be ordered to pay the full costs of the supporting affidavit of Rodger James Prince, or only half of those costs. The court noted that a significant portion of the material in the Prince affidavit was irrelevant to the proceedings, and as such, should not be considered in determining the appropriate costs to be awarded. The court estimated that approximately half of the material in the Prince affidavit was irrelevant, and accordingly, the plaintiff should only be ordered to pay half of the costs of the Prince affidavit.
Finally, the court considered how the relevance of the material exhibited to the Prince affidavit should be assessed in determining the appropriate costs to be awarded to the Commonwealth. The court held that the relevance of the material exhibited to the Prince affidavit should be assessed on a case-by-case basis, and that the party seeking to rely on such material must demonstrate its relevance to the proceedings. The court found that the plaintiff had not demonstrated the relevance of the material exhibited to the Prince affidavit, and as such, the Commonwealth was only entitled to half of the costs of the Prince affidavit.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that parties should not be permitted to make unnecessary amendments to their pleadings, and that the costs of such amendments should be borne by the party seeking to make them. Additionally, the court held that where a significant portion of the material in an affidavit is irrelevant, the party seeking to rely on such material should only be ordered to pay half of the costs associated with the affidavit. The court did not depart from prior authority in reaching its decision, but rather followed established principles of costs in civil proceedings.