Hanson v the Motor Accidents Insurance Board

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Serial No 58/1987
List “A”

COURT:                 SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:HANSON v THE MOTOR ACCIDENTS INSURANCE BOARD [1987] TASSC 61; A58/1987

PARTIES:  HANSON, Leonie Pamela
  v
  THE MOTOR ACCIDENTS INSURANCE BOARD

FILE NO/S:  112/1984
DELIVERED ON:  18 November 1987
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
JUDGMENT OF:  Cosgrove J

Judgment Number:  A58/1987
Number of paragraphs:  16

Serial No 58/1987
File No 112/1984
List "A"

LEONIE PAMELA HANSON v THE MOTOR ACCIDENTS INSURANCE BOARD

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  COSGROVE J

18 November 1987

  1. This is an action under the Fatal Accidents Act 1934 brought by the plaintiff as administratrix of the estate of Rex Michael Hanson who died on the 20 January 1984. The action is brought against the defendant Board because of its statutory liability to indemnify Lewis James Edwards who also died on the 20 January 1984. I find the following facts.

  1. At about 10.30am on the 20 January 1984, Mr Anthony Stephen Randall and his 4 year old son, called to see Mr Randall's sister, who was Mrs Henry Stafford and who resided at 86 Paine Street, Burnie. When Mr Randall arrived he found Mr Edwards and Mr Stafford playing cards and Mr Edwards was drinking beer. Mr Stafford was not drinking at the time, but Mr Randall joined with Mr Edwards in consuming some alcoholic liquor. Mr Randall had no means of transport and it was arranged that Mr Edwards would drive him and his son back to his home town of Smithton. On the way, they called into Mr Hanson's residence at Somerset. After some discussion, the particular circumstances of which caused a great deal of debate, but which are in my view mainly irrelevant, Mr Hanson, Mr Stafford and Mr Randall and his 4 year old son left in the car driven by Mr Edwards. Their joint purpose was to take Mr Randall and his son to Smithton and return to Burnie that evening. They stopped at the Seabrook Hotel and purchased some bottles of beer, stopped again at Rocky Cape and again at the tavern just past Rocky Cape. There they purchased some more bottles and went to Smithton. On arrival at Smithton, Mr Randall and his son left the vehicle. When he last saw Mr Stafford, Mr Hanson and Mr Edwards, they were all sitting in the front seat of Edwards' vehicle. At about 6.30 that evening, on a straight stretch of road at Edgecombe Beach which is slightly east of Port Latta, the vehicle left the road and collided with a pole. All three occupants of the vehicle were killed. An eye witness, Mr Atkins, said that prior to the collision he saw the vehicle move into the loose gravel on the northern side of the road on four or five occasions and was pulled back onto the bitumen surface fairly violently. He estimated the speed of the vehicle to be in excess of 110 kilometres per hour and said that after the last of the corrections, the vehicle completed a 180 degree turn so…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hanson v the Motor Accidents Insurance Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1987] TASSC 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hanson v the Motor Accidents Insurance Board, decided by Cosgrove J in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, involved a claim brought by Leonie Pamela Hanson as the administratrix of the estate of Rex Michael Hanson, who died in a car accident on 20 January 1984. Hanson's claim was against the Motor Accidents Insurance Board for its statutory liability to indemnify Lewis James Edwards, who also died in the accident. The core of the dispute centred on the relationship between the deceased parties, their actions leading up to the accident, and whether Edwards' duty of care to Hanson was affected by their conduct. The court had to determine if Edwards' duty of care was diminished due to the special relationship between the deceased as passenger and driver, the applicability of the volenti non fit injuria defence, and whether Hanson's actions constituted contributory negligence.

The court examined the evidence and found that Hanson and Edwards were heavily intoxicated and had been drinking while the vehicle was in motion. The court concluded that Edwards' manner of driving fell below the standard of reasonable care, but the defences raised by the defendant Board necessitated an exploration of the legal principles involved. Cosgrove J explored the concept of duty of care in the context of illegal or anti-social conduct, referencing several cases to understand the evolution of the law in this area. The court held that the special relationship between Hanson and Edwards transformed the nature of the duty of care, such that Edwards did not owe Hanson a duty that he was incapable of fulfilling due to his intoxication. Furthermore, the court found that Hanson had failed to take steps to mitigate the risk when he had the opportunity to do so, thus contributing to his own demise.

In dismissing the plaintiff's claim, Cosgrove J assessed damages for the dependents of the deceased. The court determined that dependency for the children would cease at or about age 16, and it considered the prospect of future support for the widow from a re-marriage or a permanent extra-marital relationship. The final orders reflected the court's assessment of damages, taking into account various factors such as loss of income, future support, and the benefit from the estate.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established