Hansen v Tadgell

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Hansen v Tadgell & another [2024] QDC 80

PARTIES:

VIVIENNE PATRICIA HANSEN
(Appellant)
v
CHRISTOPHER ALLAN TADGELL

(First Respondent)

and
HEATHER VERONICA TADGELL

(Second Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

2081/23

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court

DELIVERED ON:

11 March 2024 (ex tempore)

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

11 March 2024

JUDGES:

Judge Porter KC

ORDER:

1.   The appeal is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – Appeals by way of rehearing – where the appellant’s application for disclosure at first instance was dismissed – where the dismissal of that application was that a claim of legal professional privilege was properly made – where the appellant asserts that the learned magistrate did not deal with certain arguments in her outline in Part 3 – where that outline sought to articulate that the claim for legal professional privilege was subject to a fraud exception, or express or implied waiver – whether the decision by the learned magistrate was affected by legal error

CASES:

Lu v Fenson [2021] QDC 253

SECONDARY SOURCES:

Cross on Evidence (Online version current March 2024)

COUNSEL:

A. R. Ball for the First and Second Respondents

SOLICITORS:

Shorestone Legal for the First and Second Respondents

The appellant appeared in person

Background

  1. The genesis of the appeal before me is the passing of Audrey Pearl Tadgell in February 2022. Mrs Tadgell had had two children:, Christopher Tadgell, the first defendant in these proceedings, and Lorraine Tadgell, who subsequently married. Lorraine had three children, two sons and a daughter. The sons are David and Jamie. The daughter is Vivienne Patricia Hansen, the plaintiff in this matter. Christopher married Heather Veronica Tadgell, who is the second defendant in this matter. The other player in this drama is Amelinda Ellen Cope (Ms Cope).  She is the sole beneficiary of Mrs Tadgell’s will.  Ms Cope was the daughter of the plaintiff, Vivienne Hansen.

  2. It is uncontentious that Chris Tadgell brought a family provision application, and that that application was settled by agreement following a court ordered mediation, pursuant to directions made in the family provision application, conducted by a very experienced mediator. It is also uncontentious Chris Tadgell was to be paid something in the order of $260,000. The settlement that was reached at the mediation was given effect to by an order of Judge Sheridan of this Court. The settlement deed is not before me, but I understand it to be uncontentious that the only party who received a payment under that settlement was Mr Tadgell.

  3. The dispute between the plaintiff and Mr Tadgell pre-dates the family provision litigation. Its genesis was a conversation which Ms Hansen alleges occurred on the 5th of March 2020. It does not appear to be in dispute that there was a telephone conversation between Mr Tadgell and Ms Hansen on or around that date. The dispute concerns what was said in that conversation. Ms Hansen’s version appears in paragraphs 4.1 to 4.5 of her amended statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hansen v Tadgell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QDC 80
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Hansen v Tadgell, the dispute arose from a family provision application under the Family Law Act. Ms Hansen, the applicant, sought to challenge the validity of a will, claiming she was inadequately provided for. Mr Tadgell and his wife, Mrs Tadgell, were the respondents. The case came before the Court of Appeal after the original decision in the Magistrates Court, where Ms Hansen represented herself and Mr Ball appeared for the Tadgells. The key issue before the court was whether the learned magistrate erred in law when dismissing the appellant's application for disclosure and determining that the claim of legal professional privilege was properly made. Ms Hansen argued that the magistrate did not address certain arguments in her outline, specifically those concerning a fraud exception or implied waiver to the claim of privilege.

The court examined whether the magistrate's decision was affected by legal error, particularly in relation to the arguments outlined by Ms Hansen regarding the fraud exception and implied waiver. The court noted that the magistrate had carefully reviewed the affidavits and the outline of argument, ultimately focusing on the relevant parts of the amended statement of claim. While Ms Hansen's outline was extensive, the court concluded that the magistrate appropriately identified and considered the relevant legal issues, despite finding the pleading non-compliant. The court found no merit in Ms Hansen's argument that the magistrate failed to address the fraud exception and waiver issues, as the magistrate had indeed moved on from the disclosure issue after understanding the earlier decision by another magistrate.

The court dismissed the appeal, finding no legal error in the magistrate's handling of the case. As a result, the original decision of the Magistrates Court stood. The appeal was dismissed, and no further appeal would lie.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I said, the balance of the paragraphs are to deny the words allegedly said. As is commonly the case in family provision litigation, Mr Tadgell was represented by solicitors; in particular, Bernard Klar of Klar Legal. Notices to admit documents were also given by the parties, which are of some relevance to this appeal. During preparation for trial, there was extensive correspondence about whether documents relating to communications between Mr Tadgell and Mr Klar - which Ms Hansen thought might be relevant to the facts she alleges - were to be discovered or were privileged from production because they were covered by legal professional privilege. The decision below That matter came before the learned Magistrate for hearing on 23 June 2023. Before his Honour, Ms Hansen represented herself, and Mr Ball of Shorestone Legal appeared on behalf of Mr and Mrs Tadgell. (I struggle to see why Mrs Tadgell is a proper party to this proceeding, but I have not discussed that with either party, and it has not been raised before me.) In any event, before his Honour, various affidavits were read, most directly relevant were affidavits filed by Mr Ball on the 27th of April 2023, articulating a claim for legal professional privilege. Also before his Honour were affidavits of Ms Hansen and her daughter, the executor, along with a responsive affidavit to the daughter’s affidavit (which is the only one that asserted specific facts going to the merits of the case). Ms Hansen filed an outline of argument before his Honour. At some 17 pages, the outline of argument was long, given the nature of the matter (meaning no disrespect to Ms Hansen, who has worked very hard to articulate propositions consistent with the law). The outline included a good number of matters that were irrelevant to challenging the claim for privilege. Nonetheless, the outline of argument advanced several relevant reasons why the claim to privilege, even if properly made, could not stand. Those were identified under the heading, “Part 3, Fraud and Privilege.” It went on then to seek to articulate a fraud exception, and express an implied waiver, along with a number of other matters. His Honour took some care to identify the material that was relied upon by the parties. His Honour then referred to the outline of argument. He then sought to assist Ms Hansen to articulate what her cause of action was and, ultimately, after a little back and forth, attention finally focused, correctly, on paragraphs 4.1 and following of the amended statement of claim. His Honour thereafter volunteered the observation that the pleading was not a compliant pleading. He was told that a strikeout had been heard before another magistrate, and the application had been dismissed. It is fair, I think, to take from his Honour’s observations,[1] that he thought that another view might have been reached on that day, but once he understood what had occurred, he moved on, accepting the earlier decision. The criticism made in the notice of appeal of the way his Honour dealt with that issue is unjustified. [1] TS1-7.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established