Hand v Alcan Gove Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

CITATION: Hand v Alcan Gove Pty Ltd [2007] NTMC 041

PARTIES: JASON RICHARD HAND

v

ALCAN GOVE PTY LIMITED

TITLE OF COURT: Work Health Court

JURISDICTION: Work Health Court

FILE NO(s): 20614894

DELIVERED ON: 29 June 2007

DELIVERED AT: Darwin

HEARING DATE(s): 16 & 17 April 2007

JUDGMENT OF: Dr J Lowndes SM

CATCHWORDS:

PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT COMPENSATION – WHETHER SURGERY IS AN INJURY – CONSTRUCTION OF THE PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT PROVISIONS OF THE Work Health Act – WHOLE PERSON PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT – THE APPLICATION OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION GUIDES TO THE EVALUATION OF PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT

Work Health Act sections 3, 70, 71 and 72

Pengilly v NTA [2006] NTSC 19 applied
NTA v Pengilly [2004] NTCA 4 applied
D & W Livestock Transport v Smith No 264/1992 distinguished
D & W Livestock Transport v Smith (1994) 4 NTLR 160 applied
Canute v Comcare (2006) 229 ALR 445 distinguished

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr McDonald QC
Defendant: Mr Grant QC

Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Ward Keller
Defendant: Morgan Buckley

Judgment category classification: A
Judgment ID number: [2007] NTMC 041
Number of paragraphs: 326


IN THE WORK HEALTH COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 20614894
[2007] NTMC 041

BETWEEN:

JASON RICHARD HAND
Plaintiff

AND:

ALCAN GOVE PTY LIMITED
Defendant

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 29 June 2007)

Dr LOWNDES SM:

THE NATURE OF THE PROCEEDINGS AND ORDERS SOUGHT

1. The present proceedings give rise to some interesting and important issues of law. Basically, the worker seeks a number of rulings, referable to lump sum entitlements pursuant to section 71(1) of the Work Health Act:

(i) A ruling that any one, or some, or all of certain surgical procedures performed on the worker in January and September 1992, February 1993, July 1995, May 2000, May and August 2001 and February 2004 were injuries within the meaning of the definition in section 3 of the Work Health Act;

(ii) A ruling that lump sum payments made to the worker pursuant to s 71(1) of the Act in 1995 and 2002 on account of his percentage permanent impairment of the whole person arising from the injury should have been calculated at 208 x the appropriate weekly earnings rather than 104 x the appropriate average weekly earnings;

(iii) A ruling that the 20% permanent impairment of the whole person assessed in respect of the worker’s knee dysfunction set out in the report of Dr Colin G Mills dated 18 December 2005, relates to the worker’s replaced knee, which constitutes a different injury from the knee injury assessed and compensated for in 1995 and 2002, although one arising from the injury;

(iv) A ruling that each of the assessments made by Dr Mills in his report dated 18 December 2005 of 7% permanent impairment of the whole person for pain and 5% of the whole person for scarring and cosmetic defects in respect of the worker arising from the injury, are assessments in respect of permanent impairment aspects of the worker arising from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hand v Alcan Gove Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NTMC 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hand v Alcan Gove Pty Ltd [2007] NTMC 041 involved the plaintiff, Jason Richard Hand, seeking a number of rulings and orders from the Work Health Court in relation to lump sum entitlements pursuant to section 71 of the Work Health Act. Hand sought rulings on whether certain surgeries he underwent were injuries, whether his permanent impairment payments were calculated correctly, and whether new assessments of his permanent impairment should entitle him to further payments. The court was asked to determine these issues based on the definition of "injury" and the provisions of the Work Health Act and the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment. After considering the evidence and submissions, the court dismissed Hand's claims. It found that the surgeries did not constitute new injuries, the previous permanent impairment payments were calculated correctly, and the new assessments did not entitle Hand to further payments. The court held that the Work Health Act adopts a "whole person" approach to compensation for permanent impairment, and that Hand had not demonstrated a causal nexus between the surgeries and the assessed level of impairment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established