Hancox and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

[2012] AATA  836

Division Taxation Appeals Division

File Number

2011/3484

Re

Andrew Hancox

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member R W Dunne

Date 27  November 2012
Place Adelaide

The Tribunal affirms the objection decision under review.

..........................[Sgd]..............................................

Senior Member R W Dunne

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION - income tax - living-away-from-home allowance - travel allowance - fly-in fly-out worker - claims for work-related travel expenses - substantiation - whether assessment excessive - administrative penalty - recklessness - objection decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 23L(1)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 8-1, 15-2, Division 900
Fringe Benefits Tax Assessment Act 1986 (Cth) ss 30(1), 136(1)

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 14ZZK(b), Schedule 1, ss 284-25, 284-75(1), 284-80(1), 284-90(1), 298-20(1)

CASES

Atwood Oceanics Australia Pty Ltd v FC of T 89 ATC 4808

FC of T v Cooper 90 ATC 4396
BRK (Bris) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2001] FCA 164

Roads and Traffic Authority of New South Wales v Commissioner of Taxation (1993) 43 FCR 223

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Miscellaneous Taxation Ruling MT 2030

Downer EDI Engineering Power Pty Ltd Industrial Sector Collective Agreement 2009

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member R W Dunne

27 November 2012

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Andrew Hancox is the applicant in this case.  The objection decision under review is dated 28 June 2011, in terms of which the respondent disallowed, in part, an objection by the applicant against an amended assessment in respect of the 2009/2010 tax year.

  2. According to a statement made by Mr Hancox dated 8 May 2012, from July 2009 to June 2010 he was employed by Port Hedland BHP Ironore to leave his home and stay at a work camp for 16 weeks and temporary accommodation for 36 weeks.  His employer flew him out of Port Hedland, every four weeks, mainly to Perth, and Port Hedland was never his home.  For the 2009/2010 tax year, he filed a taxation return disclosing wages of $129,930 plus allowances of $21,785 paid to him by his employer.

  3. At the hearing, Mr Hancox was represented by Mr N Birdseye and the respondent was represented by Mr S Cole (of counsel).  I received into evidence the T documents (Exhibit R1), the supplementary T documents (Exhibit R2) and the further supplementary T documents (Exhibit R3) lodged pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, together with the following exhibits:

    ·applicant’s further supplementary documents (Exhibit A1); and

    ·email from Mr S McCormack, Group Taxation Manager at Downer EDI, dated 3 September 2012 (Exhibit A2).

    ISSUES FOR THE TRIBUNAL

  4. The following are the issues before me:

    (a)Whether the applicant was in receipt of a living-away-from-home allowance pursuant to s 30(1) of the Fringe Benefits Tax Assessment Act 1986 (“FBTAA”) in the 2009/2010 tax year?

    (b)Whether the applicant was in receipt of a bone fide travel allowance of $18,000 which is to be included as assessable income pursuant to s 15-2 of the Income Tax…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hancox and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 836
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Hancox and Commissioner of Taxation, the applicant contested the Commissioner of Taxation's decision to impose an administrative penalty for underpayment of income tax. The primary issue was whether the weekly payment of $500 received by Mr. Hancox during the 2009/2010 tax year was appropriately classified as a living-away-from-home allowance (LAFHA) rather than a travel allowance. This classification was pivotal as it determined the taxability of the payments and the validity of Mr. Hancox's claims for work-related travel expenses. The tribunal had to decide if the weekly payment was properly characterised as a LAFHA under the relevant tax laws and whether the applicant's claims for travel expenses were allowable deductions.

The tribunal found that the weekly payment of $500 was indeed a LAFHA, considering the employer's characterization of the payment, the collective agreements in place, and the circumstances of Mr. Hancox's employment. This characterization led to the conclusion that deductions for work-related travel expenses were not allowable under section 8-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. Furthermore, the tribunal addressed the issue of the administrative penalty imposed on Mr. Hancox, concluding that the penalty was appropriate given the recklessness exhibited by the applicant's tax agent in disregarding the clear evidence that the weekly payment was a LAFHA. The tribunal found no basis to remit the penalty as the evidence indicated a disregard of a foreseeable risk.

The tribunal upheld the objection decision under review, affirming the Commissioner's imposition of the administrative penalty. The tribunal's decision was grounded in the clear characterization of the weekly payment as a LAFHA, the disallowance of travel expense deductions, and the appropriateness of the penalty imposed due to the reckless conduct of the tax agent. The tribunal's decision was a comprehensive review of the evidence and legal arguments presented, ultimately reaffirming the Commissioner's position on the tax liability and penalty.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In cross-examination by Mr Cole, Mr Hancox was referred to the document in Exhibit R1, page 64, which he acknowledged was a copy of his pay slip dated 13 May 2010. When referred to a line in the pay slip which showed “LAFHA $500, Year to Date $19,785.71”, he accepted that these amounts represented his weekly living-away-from-home allowance of $500 and the amount of the allowance he had received to 13 May 2010. He accepted that the amount of $19,785.71 included an overpayment of living-away-from-home allowance which he had to repay. When asked about the total receipts for work related travel deductions of $39,099.47, Mr Hancox acknowledged that he had some receipts for flights undertaken. However, he said he did not have all the receipts for food, but had some receipts for the accommodation. In relation to his claim for stationery purchases, he said he had a diary that recorded the purchases and when they were made. However, he was unable to produce the diary to the Tribunal.Evidence of Mr McCormack Mr McCormack stated that he had been Group Taxation Manager at Downer EDI since January 2006. He acknowledged that the allowances paid to Mr Hancox during the 2009/2010 tax year were living-away-from-home allowance payments. He said Mr Hancox was employed by Downer EDI under Enterprise Bargaining Agreements, both of which refer to distant work employees. Under the agreements, employees were entitled to be provided with board and lodging at no cost to the employee. He said he had prepared a spread sheet showing the payments that had been made to Mr Hancox during the 2009/2010 tax year. He confirmed that the spread sheet had a taxable value column totalling $1,956 and that Downer EDI had paid tax on that component of the allowance. In cross-examination by Mr Birdseye, Mr McCormack confirmed that the taxable value referred to the taxable food component, and that the $500 paid weekly was made up of accommodation and food. When asked by Mr Birdseye how Downer EDI determined whether to pay an employee a travel allowance or a living-away-from-home allowance under the FBTAA, Mr McCormack said Downer EDI made the decisions by reference to ATO guidance. Under this guidance, which was found in Miscellaneous Taxation Ruling MT 2030 at paragraph 41, where an employee is away from his or her home base for a period not exceeding 21 days, the amount of the allowance paid was treated as a travel allowance, rather than a living-away-from-home allowance. In relation to the $500 paid weekly, he said this was specifically referred to under the Downer EDI Collective Agreement 2009 (“Collective Agreement”) for distant travellers to cover the food and lodging in relation to those travellers. In the case of a travel allowance, this would be paid to an employee and it would effectively be subject to PAYG withholding. A living-away-from-home allowance was effectively a tax-free allowance to the individual, whereas a travel allowance would be taxable in the individual’s hands.SUBMISSIONS FOR THE APPLICANT

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present case, the base penalty amount of 50 % was applied, correctly in my view, to the shortfall amount for the 2009/2010 tax year pursuant to Item 2 of the table in s 284-90(1) of Schedule 1 to the TAA. Under s 298-20(1) of Schedule 1 to the TAA, the respondent (and the Tribunal, upon review) has the discretion to remit all or part of the administrative penalty that has been imposed in the applicant’s case. Having regard to what occurred and the fact that the shortfall amount resulted from the disregard of, or the indifference to, a risk that was foreseeable by the applicant’s tax agent as a reasonable person, it is appropriate that an administrative penalty should be imposed and no remission is warranted. In the applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, it was asserted that the respondent imposed the tax shortfall penalty of 50 % because the applicant had Mr Birdseye as his tax agent. I do not accept this proposition. In my view and for the reasons already given, the tax shortfall penalty of 50 % was clearly appropriate.DECISION For the reasons outlined above, the Tribunal affirms the objection decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The following submissions, in brief terms, were made by Mr Cole:(a)On all the evidence, the weekly payment of $500 made to the applicant was properly characterised as a living-away-from-home allowance, both in terms of how the employer characterised it and paid it and having regard to the circumstances of the applicant (see Exhibit R2, p 238-239 and Exhibit R3, p 263).(b)Once characterised as a living-away-from-home allowance, the deductions claimed by the applicant for work related travel expenses are not allowable under s 8-1 of the ITAA 1997.(c)Taxation Determination TD 2009/15 does not assist the applicant because it applies to a travel allowance and deductions for travel expenses.(d)The decision in Roads and Traffic Authority (supra) is distinguishable and is not mirrored in the applicant’s case.(e)On the evidence that the air fares between Perth and Port Hedland were reimbursed by Downer EDI in accordance with the Collective Agreement, the expenditure related to private travel and the applicant has been properly reimbursed for that expenditure.(f)In relation to the carriage of his laptop and work tools, there is no evidence as to the nature of the tools or their use in relation to the applicant’s employment. The carriage of the tools and the laptop was incidental to his private travel and the airline expenses are hence private in nature.(g)As to the issue of penalty, the material put before the respondent by the applicant in his 2009/2010 taxation return was misleading. Evidence was available to show that the $500 weekly payment was a living-away-from-home allowance. To ignore the evidence that was available to the applicant’s tax agent was a reckless approach to the preparation of the applicant’s 2009/2010 taxation return. Recklessness is a proper approach to penalty in the applicant’s case and there is no basis to remit it in the circumstances.CONSIDERATIONWas the applicant in receipt of a living-away-from-home allowance pursuant to s 30(1) of the FBTAA in the 2009/2010 tax year? Mr Birdseye submitted that the weekly amount of $500 received by the applicant should have been treated as a travel allowance in accordance with Taxation Determination TD 2009/15 (see Exhibit R1, p 86-95). In my view Taxation Determination TD 2009/15 is not relevant in the applicant’s case. The Determination only deals with what are reasonable travel and meal allowance expenses. As I have found that the weekly allowance received by the applicant is properly characterised as a living-away-from-home allowance (see paragraph 22 below), the issue relating to reasonable travel and meal allowance expenses does not arise. Mr Birdseye also submitted that, under Miscellaneous Taxation Ruling MT 2030, the weekly amount of $500 should more appropriately be treated as a travel allowance. He said that the period spent by the applicant away from his home base was “very close” to the 21 days referred to in paragraph 41 of the Ruling, and that the weekly allowance should be treated as a travel allowance, rather than a living-away-from-home allowance. On the evidence before me, I am unable to accept Mr Birdseye’s submission. The period spent by the applicant away from his home base and the circumstances in which he was away do not allow for the application of MT 2030 in his case.