HANCOCK v SOUTH AUSTRALIAN TOURISM COMMISSION
[2000] SASC 172
Appeal from a Master
DUGGAN J. This is an appeal from orders made by a master of this court on an application for further and better discovery pursuant to R 58.04(e) of the Supreme Court Rules. This rule provides that, where there are grounds for belief that some document or class of documents relating to any matter in question in proceedings may be or may have been, in the possession, custody or power of a party, the court may order that the party file and deliver to any other party an affidavit stating whether that document, or any of that class is or has been in its possession, custody or power and, if it has been but is not presently, to state when the party parted with it and what has become of it.
Rule 58.04(e) is in terms similar to its predecessor Order 31 r 16 which, in turn, was based on the former English rule Order 31 r 19A. When explaining the rationale of the English rule in Thornett v BarclaysBank (France) Ltd [1939] 1 KB 675 at 682, Lord Justice Scott said:
“Rule 19A was invented thirty or forty years ago, in a slightly different form from that which it wears to-day, for the express purpose of getting over a difficulty in relation to discovery. The difficulty arose out of a principle regulating discovery under our system of procedure, which puts upon the party, whose duty it is to make discovery, the burden of honestly swearing what are the documents which are relevant, that affidavit being prima facie conclusive subsequently on the scope of relevance. It was found that documents became omitted accidentally, and there was no procedure to get at them; hence the specific documents rule, which allowed the opposite party to impeach the view of relevancy upon which the opposing party’s affidavit had been framed. The method allowed to the impeaching party was to file an affidavit saying that in his belief there was in the possession of the other party documents which did relate to the matters in question; and he had then to specify what they were. Subsequently the rule was altered by allowing the affidavit of impeachment to refer to classes of documents in order to get over the difficulty of specifying the individual documents.”
In the well known case of Mulley v Manifold [1959] 103 CLR 341 at 343 Menzies J explained the nature of the High Court equivalent of the rule, O 32 r 18. After referring to the conclusiveness of an affidavit of discovery his Honour said:
“It was in order to relax this rule to some extent that O. 32, r. 18 was introduced; this rule does permit an application for further discovery based upon the filing of an affidavit that there have been particular undiscovered documents in the possession of the other party which relate to a matter in question in the proceeding. Pursuant to this rule,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hancock v SA Tourism Commission No. Scgrg-99-658 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 172
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court was required to decide involved the interpretation and application of Rule 58.04(e) of the Supreme Court Rules. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether there were sufficient grounds to order the defendant to file an affidavit concerning the existence, possession, custody, or power of specific documents or classes of documents that the plaintiff sought to discover. The plaintiff sought further discovery of eleven categories of documents, which included board papers, notes, diaries, and other documents related to her employment and dismissal.
Duggan J found that the plaintiff's application for further and better discovery was too wide and nebulous, particularly in the case of board papers and other documents where the absence of a reference to a particular topic was sought to establish a negative inference. The court rejected the plaintiff's argument that documents should be discovered simply because they might support a negative inference, such as the absence of complaints about her performance over a certain period. The court held that there were no grounds for belief that such documents existed or that their discovery would be relevant to the proceedings. Duggan J concluded that the order for further and better discovery was inappropriate and dismissed the appeal.
In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed, and the orders made by the Master were upheld. The court found that the plaintiff had not established sufficient grounds for the defendant to file an affidavit under Rule 58.04(e) for the majority of the document categories sought. The decision underscores the importance of specificity and relevance in applications for further and better discovery under the Supreme Court Rules.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: DUGGAN J