HAMNETT v POLICE
[2000] SASC 126
Magistrates Appeal: Criminal
MULLIGHAN J The appellant pleaded guilty on 1st March 2000 to charges of driving a motor vehicle while disqualified from holding or obtaining a driver’s licence, behaving in a disorderly manner in a public place, urinating in a public place, using offensive language in a public place and resisting police officers in the execution of their duty. On 10th March 2000 he was sentenced by a learned Magistrate at Christies Beach to imprisonment for a total period of three months and fourteen days and ordered to pay various fees, levies and costs. The sentences of imprisonment were not suspended.
He appeals against the sentences on the grounds that they are manifestly excessive and that the learned Magistrate erred in failing to suspend them.
The offence of driving whilst disqualified was committed on 12th January 1999. On 21st October 1996 he was disqualified from holding or obtaining a licence to drive a motor vehicle until further order, having been convicted of a drink driving offence and the offence of driving without a licence. At about 9.30 am on 12th January 1999 the appellant drove a motor vehicle on Main South Road at O’Halloran Hill when he lost control and the vehicle rolled over. He was charged with that offence on complaint but not until 1st July 1999.
The appellant’s version of the circumstances of the offence was that he had earlier been at home with his de facto wife of some eight and a half years. There had been a serious argument between them. He walked away to cool off and upon his return the argument continued. He was distressed and not thinking clearly. He saw her keys on a table, took them and drove away in her motor vehicle. He was also angry and upset and intended to drive to the home of a close friend to talk about his problems. He says that he did not turn his mind to the disqualification. Whilst driving an elderly woman driving a motor vehicle cut in front of the vehicle he was driving causing him to brake. He acknowledges that his mental state at the time is a reason for the accident. The car slid and rolled over. He says he had not consumed alcohol on this day. He does not dispute any of the circumstances of the other offences.
The offence of disorderly behaviour was committed at about 6.00 pm on 26th December 1999. The appellant was yelling loudly outside a chemist shop at a shopping centre at Morphett Vale and was banging on the window. He then went into a drive-through bottle shop next door. He was upset and he swore in the presence of the attendant and a customer. This shop had shut and the appellant was told that it had closed a few minutes earlier. He then told the assistant that he had better serve him or he would “bash the shit out of [him] and take every bottle…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hamnett v Police No. Scgrg-00-271 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SASC 126
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Mulligan J found that the sentence of imprisonment for two months for the offence of driving disqualified was manifestly excessive. The offence was committed on the spur of the moment and in consequence of an agitated state following an argument. A sentence of 14 days would have been appropriate. Mulligan J also found that the sentence of imprisonment for one month with respect to the three offences committed on 28 January 2000 was excessive because the offence of urinating in a public place did not carry a penalty of imprisonment. The court quashed that sentence. Mulligan J concluded that, despite the past record of the appellant, there was good reason to suspend the sentence. Hamnett is a relatively young man who has a stable, if at times volatile, relationship with the mother of his three children. He had previously sought assistance with his alcoholism. The psychiatric evidence established that prison would compromise the appellant’s chances of resolving his problem. The appellant expressed the wish to continue his employment and his family life and his resolve to beat the problem. The court found that the learned Magistrate did not have due regard to the progress which the appellant had made since he commenced work and that he did not give adequate consideration to the prospects of rehabilitation. Mulligan J concluded that it was appropriate to suspend the sentences. The appeal was allowed. The sentence on the charge of driving disqualified was quashed and a sentence of imprisonment for 14 days was imposed. The sentence of 14 days imposed with respect to the offence of disorderly behaviour committed on 26 December 1999 was confirmed. The sentence of imprisonment for one month with respect to the three offences committed on 28 January 2000 was quashed. The appellant was convicted without penalty on the charge of urinating in a public place. On the other two charges of using offensive language and resisting police, the court imposed one sentence of imprisonment for 20 days. Each of the sentences was to be served cumulatively. The total head sentence was 48 days. The sentences were suspended upon the appellant entering into a bond in the sum of $100 to be of good behaviour for a period of 12 months with the conditions that he be under the supervision of a probation officer and that he obey all directions of the probation officer as to employment, place of residence and treatment and counselling for alcoholism and management of anger.
Background
Background to the litigation
The appellant was sentenced by a learned Magistrate at Christies Beach to imprisonment for a total period of three months and fourteen days and ordered to pay various fees, levies, and costs on 10th March 2000. The sentences of imprisonment were not suspended. The appellant appeals against the sentences on the grounds that they are manifestly excessive and that the learned Magistrate erred in failing to suspend them. The appeal was heard by Mulighan J.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence of 2 months for driving disqualified is manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the learned Magistrate erred in not suspending the total sentence.
Held
1. The sentence of 2 months for driving disqualified was manifestly excessive. The court considered that a sentence of 14 days would have been appropriate.
2. The learned Magistrate erred in not suspending the total sentence. The court found that there were good reasons to suspend the sentence given the appellant's prospects of rehabilitation and the importance of his role in caring for his children.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MULLIGHAN J
The court considered the appellant's extensive record of prior offending, including many driving offences, which justified a severe penalty. However, the court found that the offence of driving disqualified was not contumacious and was committed on the spur of the moment and in consequence of an agitated state following an argument. Therefore, a sentence of imprisonment for 2 months was manifestly excessive. The court considered that a sentence of 14 days would have been appropriate.
Regarding the other sentences, the court found no basis to impugn them except for the error in imposing a sentence of imprisonment for the offence of urinating in a public place, for which only a fine was permitted. The court considered that the former approach of convicting the appellant without penalty was appropriate.
The court found that there were good reasons to suspend the sentence despite the appellant's past record. The appellant had a stable relationship with the mother of his three children and had been in full-time employment for most of 1999. The psychiatric evidence established that prison would compromise the appellant's chances of resolving his alcohol problem. The court considered the impact of a sentence upon dependants and found that the appellant's presence in his home and the assistance he could give his de facto wife were clearly matters to consider.
The court found that the learned Magistrate did not give adequate consideration to the prospects of rehabilitation and that the material before the Magistrate justified a sentencing approach which would afford the appellant another chance to avoid serving another sentence of imprisonment. The court found that the present circumstances of the appellant supported the suspension of the sentence, particularly his role in caring for his children. The court allowed the appeal and suspended the sentences upon the appellant entering into a bond in the sum of $100 to be of good behaviour for a period of 12 months with certain conditions.