Hammoud v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL

CITATION:

Hammoud v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2025] NSWPICMP 420

CLAIMANT:

Ahmed Hammoud

INSURER:

Allianz Insurance Australia Limited

REVIEW PANEL

MEMBER:

Alexander Bolton

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Shane Moloney

MEDICAL ASSESSOR:

Drew Dixon

DATE OF DECISION:

13 June 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; review of Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC); threshold injury dispute; causation considerations of whether a right shoulder injury tear of the supraspinatus tendon was as a result of the accident or a degenerative condition; light impact collision; insurer relied on expert biomechanical report; weight of medical evidence was to the effect that the impact forces were not of such a degree that the claimant could have suffered a shoulder tear as a result of the collision; Held – Review Panel satisfied that all injuries suffered by the claimant were threshold injuries; Medical Assessor found that none of the claimant’s injuries arose from the accident but the Review Panel concluded the claimant did suffer soft tissue injuries but that these were threshold injuries; MAC revoked; new certificate issued.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION

1.     The Panel revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Assem dated 3 April 2024.

2.     The Panel finds that the claimant has suffered the following injuries:

(a)    cervical spine -soft tissue injury;

(b)    right and left legs - referred pain from the lumbar spine - no separate injury diagnosed;

(c)    lumbar spine -soft tissue injury, and

(d)    right and left shoulders -soft tissue injury,

and that these are threshold injuries.

3.    The Panel is not satisfied that the claimant suffered a right shoulder injury causing a tear in the middle third of his supraspinatus tendon as a result of a motor vehicle accident on 3 May 2021 and that this was a non-threshold injury pursuant to the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application by the claimant for review of a certificate and reasons of Medical Assessor Assem (the Medical Assessor) dated 3 April 2024.

  2. This is a dispute between the claimant and the insurer about whether the injury caused by the motor accident is a threshold injury under Schedule 2, s 2(e) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the Act).

  3. The following injuries were referred by the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) for further assessment:

    (a)    cervical spine -soft tissue injury;

    (b)    leg - referred pain from the lumbar spine - no separate injury diagnosed;

    (c)    lumbar spine -soft tissue injury, and

    (d)    shoulder - soft tissue injury.

  4. The claimant has confirmed that both the left and right shoulder and left and right leg are to be reviewed by the Panel.

  5. The following injuries referred to the Medical Assessor for assessment were assessed and determined to be not caused by the motor accident:

    (a)    cervical spine -soft tissue injury;

    (b)    leg - referred pain from the lumbar spine - no separate injury diagnosed;

    (c)    lumbar spine - soft tissue injury, and

    (d)    shoulder - soft tissue injury.

  6. Because of his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hammoud v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPICMP 420
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hammoud v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was a case before a Review Panel under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The dispute centred on the validity of a Medical Assessment Certificate (MAC) which stated that the injuries sustained by the claimant, Mr Hammoud, in a motor vehicle accident were not threshold injuries and therefore not compensable. The claimant argued that the Review Panel should overturn the MAC and recognise his injuries as threshold injuries. The insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, maintained the Medical Assessor's findings, arguing that the injuries were either pre-existing or not caused by the accident.

The key legal issues for the Review Panel to decide were whether the injuries sustained by Mr Hammoud were indeed threshold injuries as defined by the Act and whether these injuries were caused by the motor vehicle accident. The Panel needed to assess the weight of the medical evidence, including the biomechanical report, and determine the causation of the injuries. The Panel also had to consider the credibility and weight of the expert evidence presented by both parties.

The Review Panel concluded that the Medical Assessor’s determination that none of Mr Hammoud’s injuries arose from the accident was not supported by the preponderance of evidence. The Panel found that the weight of the medical evidence indicated that the impact forces from the collision were insufficient to cause the injuries claimed. However, the Panel recognised that Mr Hammoud did suffer from soft tissue injuries, which were deemed to be threshold injuries. Consequently, the Review Panel revoked the original MAC and issued a new certificate acknowledging the soft tissue injuries as threshold injuries.

In conclusion, the Review Panel’s decision recognised Mr Hammoud’s soft tissue injuries as compensable threshold injuries, overturning the insurer’s position that the injuries were not related to the accident. The new certificate issued by the Panel was intended to reflect the Panel's findings and ensure Mr Hammoud received appropriate compensation for his injuries.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By way of conclusion and diagnosis, the Medical Assessor reported;“…the low-speed collision in question, which resulted in minimal damage to the vehicle, is highly unlikely to have caused physical injuries leading to pathology that would result in permanent impairment. I concur with Mr Michael Griffiths' biomechanical analysis, which highlights the collision's low-impact nature. His findings indicate that the forces experienced by Mr Hammoud and his passengers did not surpass those encountered in daily activities, such as eating or drinking. This significantly challenges the probability of the accident causing the extensive symptoms claimed.Additionally, the fact that Mr Hammoud's daughter, who was also in the vehicle at the time of the accident, sustained no physical injuries corroborates the assertion of minimal impact force.Furthermore, radiological findings, particularly concerning the cervical and lumbar spine, suggest pre-existing degenerative changes rather than acute traumatic injuries. These degenerative changes, commonly asymptomatic and widespread among individuals in manual labour or advanced age, are attributed to gradual wear and tear. Research indicates that a significant proportion of individuals over 60 exhibit asymptomatic rotator cuff tears, pointing to age-related degeneration as the likely cause of Mr Hammoud's findings, rather than the accident.The delay in seeking medical attention for more than three weeks post-incident, along with Mr Hammoud's ability to continue driving and working shortly thereafter, contradicts the expectations of acute trauma from a significant motor vehicle accident. This delay, coupled with the absence of immediate, severe symptoms, is inconsistent with the type of trauma that would lead to structural derangement and permanent impairment.Conclusion:From a medical perspective, it is highly improbable that Mr Hammoud sustained any physical injuries from the subject accident. The pathology identified on radiological imaging is unrelated to the accident. Based on the comprehensive evidence and analyses presented, I conclude that none ofthe injuries claimed are causally related to the motor vehicle accident on 3 May 2021.” The Medical Assessor concluded that the injuries referred to him for assessment were not caused by the accident and consequently that a decision whether these injuries were a threshold injury was not required. There is a report of Michael Griffiths, expert Bio-Medical and Mechanical Engineer, relied upon by the insurer. He found “…complete lack of any visual damage including evidence of light superficial contact such as scratches or minor abrasions” and concluding that in this low speed collision, “there was no mechanism which could apply a load to the arm relative to the shoulder that would be any greater than that experienced in routine daily activities such as eating or drinking.” He found that it “is not possible for a simple rear impact to a motor vehicle which applied a forward force to the shoulder and adjacent anatomical structures by the seat back, to target the supraspinatus or biceps tendon”.